Should Christians tithe

[Lanakila]

Is tithing taught in the NT, for NT Christians? What exactly is the tithe? Is it really 10% like we are told, or was it a tax to OT Jews that consisted of 23%? Does that mean we should be giving 23%?

I have my own opinions on this, but would like to hear what the rest of y'all think. Besides this is a fellowship forum.

 

[eldermike]

To give Caesar what is Caesar's can be calculated, it's a set amount.
To give God, what is God's is also easy to calculate, it's everything that doesn't belong to Cesar.

You cannot serve God and money.
I believe in Tithing (10%) and giving (as needed), however the word Tithing carries too much baggage. A person Tithing can still serve money. This is one of the hardest edges we come against when growing in Christ.

Great question!

Eldermike

 

[rookie]

If the 23% was a tax though, wouldn't that be a "tax" and not tithing?

I thought it was in the NT about tithing, will go look it up. Don't remember anything about it saying how much.

rookie

 

[Lanakila]

Tithing is quite a study. Many say that since Abraham gave a tithe to Melkisidek (sp) that the tithe predates the law. But, there is more to it than that. The NT example of giving was more of a missions/helps offering for starving Christians in Jerusalem. Like I said before I have my own opinion on this, but I will reserve it until later.

 

[rookie]

After doing just a little research, I'm finding all kinds of sites saying that tithing is "unscriptural" based on the New Covenant. Wow. I personally don't see a problem with tithing. We can't just take our churches for granted. Someone has to pay the electric and water and so on. Just my little thoughts.

rookie

 

[kimber1]

i think we should yes but i don't think the NT has a set clear amount. i think personally it should be given with a free and clear conscience and not be something you feel obligated to do. nor should those who don't have a set amount to give be made to feel bad that they can't give a certain amount.

 

[Lanakila]

God loves a cheerful giver. (I don't know the chapter and verse on that)

 

[rookie]

I agree, God knows our hearts. We should be doing it as a "cheerful giver." We could give thousands, but I think that if we did it, feeling it was an obligation, then it's not the same.

rookie

 

[tigersnare]

I think tithing is a wonderful practice, but it can become a problem when someone is willing to Tithe but not help out a poor person, brother, family member or basically anyone who comes to you with a need, on the grounds of "sorry can't you help you, becuase I paid my tithe and that's all I"m required to give".

This kind of person is what my pastor would call a "Spiritual Pharisee".

I try to look at it this way, it's God's money. He's just leting me use it.....so I had better use it the way he intends me to use it or he will just take it back.

Works for me anways.....

 

[BBAS 64]

Yes, tithing is a blessing for me. I heard of some that tithe and it a chore for them some complain about they have to because it is taught by their church. I give 10% to my local church and have no problem with it. IMO it does not matter if you give 5%,8%, 11%, just keep your additude in check. I do not understand when pastors will preach on if you do not give 10% tithe to the local church it is because of a lack of faith, could be for some a matter of their survival.

For His Glory Alone!

BBAS

 

[Knight]

Yes, I think Christians should tithe.
Tithing is an act of worship in giving back to God a portion of what He has given us. When you realize all that He has done for you, a tithe seems small in comparison. In tithing we also acknowledge that God already owns everything.
Tithing should not be compulsory. It should be done with a cheerful heart.

2 Cor. 9:7
Each man should give what he has decided in his heart to give, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver.

My family tithes 10% of our gross income.