MrMoe
Part-Time Breatharian
I simply do not have time to acknowledge all of this. But "twilight zone"? Try concocting a story that has people at the wedding are drunk (instead of having had drunk wine), that Mary asks Jesus to do something sinful (create wine) and that what Jesus actually creates is "better wine" that's not fermented? Ok.
I never said this. What are you talking about?
You said "'Woman what have I to do with you?' is Jesus dismissing her, showing that he is his own man. Notice how Jesus doesn't call her mother. Nowhere in scripture does Jesus refer to Mary as his mother" and when I pointed out that Scripture most certainly acknowledges Jesus as mother, you backtrack with "I never said Jesus did not acknowledge her as her mother".
Sigh, I don't think you understood what I meant. I'm certainly not backtracking. I said " Nowhere in scripture does Jesus refer to Mary as his mother" I did not say "Nowhere do the scriptures refer to her as his mother" or that Jesus did not acknowledge him as his mother as I explained to you. Understand now?
If you believe that Jesus publicly "dismisses" her to "show that he's his own man" and associate that with her "never calling her mother" -- then you are essentially accusing him of showing her little to no respect. That's the bottom line.
So if God asked you to not do something and your mother asked you to do that very thing would you do it in order to not disrespect your mother or would you obey God? Do you do everything your parents want when your an adult in order to not disrespect them?
I would also suggest you look up the word "rather" in the dictionary, and instead of interpreting that to mean "on the contrary", try the first definition "with better reason" or "more correctly speaking". Jesus statement that "rather blessed are those who hear the word of God and keep it". Jesus is not dismissing the blessing Mary received in being his mother (as Elizabeth under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit professes). He is pointing that with better reason Mary, and those like her will be blessed for hearing the word of God and keeping it.
"with better reason" and "more correctly speaking" we come to the same conclusion that Jesus is trying to emphasising God's word over himself or his mother. I never said Jesus was trying to dismiss the blessing given to Mary. You keep putting word in my mouth
And "going about his father's business" doesn't equate to his having a ministry? Teaching in the temple has nothing to do with this ministry?
It doesn't say he was teaching.
You're clearly ignoring what I and the verse say in order to fit your theology
You say "Where does it say that in the scriptures? I have read Luke 2 and all it says is Jesus was sitting with the teachers, listened to them and asking them questions" Jesus questions his parents with "Do you not know that I must be about my Father's business"? So yes, he was ready to go, and they do curtail him, and the Scripture says he was obedient to them.
All these people who pray for people in the prayer requests thread, are they not going about God's business? Does that mean they have their own ministry too?
Also you just ignored the whole problem of your argument which I stated with this whole curtailing business. I guess that means you have a curtailing ministry.
The basic problem with all of this is not that Catholics "elevate" Mary to the level of God. It's that we recognize that God elevated Mary above the rest of us when he chose her to become the mother of the Eternal Word. That's the general rub for many people -- Mary can't possibly be any more important in the kingdom of God than me.
You need to read what Jesus said about who would be great in the kingdom of heaven. I think you'll be suprised
Also Jesus made it clear he had more than one mother so that means there should be several queens of heaven not just Mary.
Upvote
0