• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

Paul versus the Essenes

ContraMundum

Messianic Jewish Christian
Site Supporter
Jul 2, 2005
15,666
2,957
Visit site
✟100,608.00
Country
Australia
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
I haven't read through the responses so someone may have already brought this up. I don't want to be off-topic but have you heard Israeli professor Rachel Elior's opinion that the "Essenes" never existed but were in fact Zadokite (Sadducee) Priests ousted during the political chaos that preceded the Hasmonean revolt in the second century BCE.

The Hasmoneans, a priestly family but not of the Zadokite line, cast out the Hellenizers from Jerusalem but instead of restoring the Zadokite line installed their own members in the high priesthood. Some of the Zadokites and their followers challenged the legitimacy of the Hasmonean priestly leadership and seceded from Temple service. This conflict between the Zadokite "secessionists," as Elior calls them, and the Hasmonean usurpers is the theme of many of the most interesting scrolls found at Qumran. Elior views the Qumran scrolls as a Zadokite library, not an Essene library as has been the consensus view. Amid the chaos and intense religious ferment of the Hasmonean period (152-37 BCE), new voices began to be heard - those of scholars known as Pharisees who disputed the legitimacy of the Hasmonean priests and kings and who argued with the Zadokite priests about the solar calendar and their claims to possess an open line to the divine. These scholars, who would become known as rabbis or sages, were unhappy about the exclusiveness of the priests and the power they had accrued through their claims to esoteric knowledge as confidants of angels. In a game-changing move, the rabbis declared that the age of prophecy had long since ended and that the priesthood had been severed from ongoing access to higher authority.
http://www.jpost.com/Magazine/Features/From-the-sun-to-the-moon

I have heard of this too. Which is exactly why I don't get overly excited every time someone comes up with a new theory or a revised history regarding the Bible. All this mental energy is better spent doing things that mean something, IMHO. People that get obsessed with textual revision, endless theories, conspiracy, alternative histories and that kind of thing end up living rather confused lives due to their uncertainty and constant change of mind regarding their religion (in my experience). That can't be healthy.
 
Upvote 0

Hoshiyya

Spenglerian
Mar 5, 2013
5,285
1,023
✟39,686.00
Faith
Marital Status
Married
I haven't read through the responses so someone may have already brought this up. I don't want to be off-topic but have you heard Israeli professor Rachel Elior's opinion that the "Essenes" never existed but were in fact Zadokite (Sadducee) Priests ousted during the political chaos that preceded the Hasmonean revolt in the second century BCE.

The Hasmoneans, a priestly family but not of the Zadokite line, cast out the Hellenizers from Jerusalem but instead of restoring the Zadokite line installed their own members in the high priesthood. Some of the Zadokites and their followers challenged the legitimacy of the Hasmonean priestly leadership and seceded from Temple service. This conflict between the Zadokite "secessionists," as Elior calls them, and the Hasmonean usurpers is the theme of many of the most interesting scrolls found at Qumran. Elior views the Qumran scrolls as a Zadokite library, not an Essene library as has been the consensus view. Amid the chaos and intense religious ferment of the Hasmonean period (152-37 BCE), new voices began to be heard - those of scholars known as Pharisees who disputed the legitimacy of the Hasmonean priests and kings and who argued with the Zadokite priests about the solar calendar and their claims to possess an open line to the divine. These scholars, who would become known as rabbis or sages, were unhappy about the exclusiveness of the priests and the power they had accrued through their claims to esoteric knowledge as confidants of angels. In a game-changing move, the rabbis declared that the age of prophecy had long since ended and that the priesthood had been severed from ongoing access to higher authority.
http://www.jpost.com/Magazine/Features/From-the-sun-to-the-moon

That may or may not be so, but I think this misses the point.

Someone lived at Qumran and wrote the Qumrani texts, such as 4QMMT (Miqsat Maaseh ha Torah), which contained such teachings as are referenced, and combated, in Pauline texts.

That much is fact, and apparently Qumran-researchers and Dead Sea MSS researchers have pointed this out previously (as far back as 1994).

As to whether this is coincidence or something more, that's not for me to decide.
 
Upvote 0