• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

  • CF has always been a site that welcomes people from different backgrounds and beliefs to participate in discussion and even debate. That is the nature of its ministry. In view of recent events emotions are running very high. We need to remind people of some basic principles in debating on this site. We need to be civil when we express differences in opinion. No personal attacks. Avoid you, your statements. Don't characterize an entire political party with comparisons to Fascism or Communism or other extreme movements that committed atrocities. CF is not the place for broad brush or blanket statements about groups and political parties. Put the broad brushes and blankets away when you come to CF, better yet, put them in the incinerator. Debate had no place for them. We need to remember that people that commit acts of violence represent themselves or a small extreme faction.
  • We hope the site problems here are now solved, however, if you still have any issues, please start a ticket in Contact Us

  • The rule regarding AI content has been updated. The rule now rules as follows:

    Be sure to credit AI when copying and pasting AI sources. Link to the site of the AI search, just like linking to an article.

My Relationship Experience (Feedback/Advice Requested)

GeorgiaGuyinAtlanta

Regular Member
Mar 13, 2006
1,081
244
Atlanta, Georgia Metropolitan Area, U.S.A.
✟15,479.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Before I pour out my heart about my relationship, let me tell you a few things about myself. First, I am a 28 year old single man. I have been dating a girl (hereto known as "my girlfriend") for a year.

Where do I start.

Ah. Let me start off by saying that I'm writing this in an effort to get some sincere feedback about my relationship.

Here goes:

I met my girlfriend last March while chatting online. When I met her, she seemed so nice, friendly, and like an answer to God's prayers. Earlier that day, I had written a letter to God asking Him to send a mate my way, but that I was finally going to give it over to God. So, the night of that letter, I meet my girlfriend in a christian chatroom. I had resigned myself to "I'll look tonight (as I had done many times before with little success), but if no fish bite, I'm not going to worry about it any longer". So I meet this girl, and we hit it off. She was very kind, considerate, funny, and we seemed to share a lot of interests. Over the next couple weeks, we chatted on instant message through the computer, and then I finally called her.

Once we started talking on the phone, she, unlike many other women that I had spoken with, was interested in meeting. There was one problem. She lived in another state. Granted that it was a neighboring state, the distance from my house to hers was five and a half hours.

In April, I had originally felt that we shouldn't meet until summer, June to be exact. My reasoning was that I couldn't quite grasp her impatient nature of wanting to meet so soon, which was quite uncommon compared to most females I had spoken with. I wanted to make sure that she would still like me for me, and that she was balanced. Yet, one April night, I called her up and asked her out for the following weekend.

One morning in April, I drove halfway between my house and hers to meet her, and we rode together into the metropolitan area in which I live. After a day together, having fun, I drove her back to the half-way location. I kissed her goodnight.

From April to June, we were still in the "dating phase", meaning that I hadn't committed myself to exclusively dating her, though we weren't seeing anyone else. In June, I asked her to be "my girl". Yet, one of the things that has gotten me about me asking her to be my girlfriend, was the nature of the time surrounding it. As early as May, my girlfriend had been asking me when I was going to ask her to be "my girl". I was taken back by this, as it seemed unusual for her to be talking about being her man after only a month, and not letting things naturally progress. In May, she had a "freak out" episode at the end of a good date, in which she all of a sudden started saying, "Why don't you know" (about wanting her to be my girl). This episode lasted over an hour, in which she shed many tears. She apologized and said that it wouldn't happen again.

In June, I asked my girlfriend to be "my girl". Everything seemed to be running smoothly. We were going on short road trips, and my feeling of love for my girlfriend was growing, as I have felt this feeling with a past girlfriend. However, only about a month after I asked her to be my girl, my girlfriend started the "why don't you know if you want to marry me" business. These were similar to the freakout episode in May, but with a different twist on them. Usually the episodes would last about an hour, and they'd come about once every two weeks. Needless to say, these episodes literally killed most of the "love" feeling that I was developing for my girlfriend. It made me begin to feel uneasy and question her emotional well-being. Furthermore, regaining that lost feeling wasn't easy, since our distance only allowed us to see each other every weekend.

From July to September, came very good times and very anxiety-filled times, compliment of the "worry sessions" courtesy of my girlfriend. Certainly, she wasn't making it easy for me to love her like I wanted to, being filled with constant uneasiness and being impatient like anyone I had ever seen. Needless to say, the comments of, "when are you going to see me as someone who wants to marry me," lasted for two or three months until I said that I could see marrying her.

Since October, only six months after meeting my girlfriend, and only four months after asking her to be "my girl", harps of "wanting to get married" have been so frequent that it has prohibited the natural progression of the relationship. She gets frustrated with me, as "I'm not in the same spot as her". I, on the other hand, get frustrated, as I feel like she worries too much, hasn't allowed for the relationship to blossom like it naturally would, and that it has been more forced than anything.

Over the time, though, despite all the hardships, I have developed a real love for my girlfriend, but the relationship has no fire, at least on my side. I do not get butterflies in the stomach, the infatuation, or anything like that, and I haven't had that at all since her freak-out episodes first began to appear, despite her being attractive.

In the relationship, I often feel that I have no freetime, despite the fact that we only see each other on the weekend. At times, she calls me about ten times per night. While I love to talk to her, overkill can occur on anything. There are times that I just want to wind down, and she sometimes gets upset if I request for her to allow me some free time.

I had become understandable about her emotions, and the ways to best keep her happy. I've come to realize that if I don't do things in the ways that she wants me to do it (for example: she wanted me to change my cell phone plan, as well as she wanted me to open a savings account), she'll get upset. I've resorted to lying, saying that I've looked into things, in which I often haven't, as I've viewed her persistence as meddling too much into affairs that only relate to me.

Regarding the idea of marriage, she talks about it constantly, and while I want to get married, given the frequent worry sessions, constant "asking me to do something", impatient nature, etc., I haven't been excited to get married. My girlfriend, I believe, perceives this, and she'll say, "we're not on the same wavelength". I have practically been backed into a corner in which she constantly talks about marriage, "wanting a ring", and asking, "when am I going to get my ring". She sends me ring advertisements, and I've been "forced" to say my hesitantcy in not asking her yet is because I haven't acquired enough money to purchase a ring (partly true, but mostly not). She has practically set a date for when I shall have asked her, but I never really was allowed the opportunity for the relationship to flourish, given the emotional "warfare" since last May. Furthermore, she hasn't been my girl for even a year, and she's ready to get married.

My girlfriend talks about events as "wasting her life". If she sees no relevance or significance, or if she doesn't get what she wants when she wants it, she gets aggravated, believes she is wasting her life with it, etc. Just tonight, she told me that she's going to break up with me if I don't ask her to marry me soon, and even then, the "date" for asking her seems to have moved to the end of March/early April. She said, "Don't be surprised if I don't stick around". Yet, she unabashedly claims that she loves me "so so much".

My girlfriend always seems to make me into the one who is being unfair, and her the victim. Usually, after carefully explaining to her that I have not done anything wrong, or done anything intentional to hurt her feelings, it is still to no avail. I then try to subtly admit some responsibility (as well as admitting her responsibility as well) so as to save face. These times can be very emotionally draining. There are times when she absolutely refuses to get off the phone, of which any answer that I give her is no good. If I hang up, she gets very upset. She starts saying, "You don't want to talk to me". She then gets more noticeably upset, and it further weighs on my body. Sometimes we'll be on the phone and very little is said. However, if I suggest we cool off, or that we not spend the time on the phone at that moment, her feelings get hurt, and she claims that "she doesn't matter". She's kept me up until 1 am in the morning, calling me back, time after time.

Given all of this, what's your take on my situation? What do you think about it? Is this normal? Should I marry her. Should I break up with her? Should we slow down? Any feedback would be greatly appreciated.
 
I

Inperfected

Guest
So mate... i have to say it.. it's breaking up time.

You aren't happy, and that is SO clear... How old are you and her, she sounds like a 15 yearold to tell you the truth, and i infact know a 13 year old who did the same thing virtually (minus the marrying bit)...

She is emotionally unstable from all you've siad, and i woudn't be suprised if she's a relationship rebounder (i was and she sounds quite similar to how i also was a few years ago)

I suggest not sticking around, and no doubt she'll say she'll kill herself, so have a back up plan for if that comes to pass (back up is NOT you, it is a close friend or family member).

Good luck and i'm praying for you
 
Upvote 0

GeorgiaGuyinAtlanta

Regular Member
Mar 13, 2006
1,081
244
Atlanta, Georgia Metropolitan Area, U.S.A.
✟15,479.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Inperfected said:
So mate... i have to say it.. it's breaking up time.

You aren't happy, and that is SO clear... How old are you and her, she sounds like a 15 yearold to tell you the truth, and i infact know a 13 year old who did the same thing virtually (minus the marrying bit)...

She is emotionally unstable from all you've siad, and i woudn't be suprised if she's a relationship rebounder (i was and she sounds quite similar to how i also was a few years ago)

I suggest not sticking around, and no doubt she'll say she'll kill herself, so have a back up plan for if that comes to pass (back up is NOT you, it is a close friend or family member).

Good luck and i'm praying for you
Inperfected, she's 26. You are also correct that she did get out of a relationship prior to meeting me.

She was engaged to another man from December of the prior year (2004) to February of last year.

She tells me that God got her through her past relationship, and that she's been so blessed. She's mentioned that I'm "her blessing from God".

If anyone else would like to provide feedback, please do. I need as much as I can get.
 
Upvote 0

Becstacy

Member
Feb 17, 2006
13
2
39
✟22,643.00
Faith
Christian
Politics
US-Democrat
the guilt trips, the forced lying, the hidden agenda, the smothering, the possessiveness, her own insecurity and immaturity, the freak out sessions, how demanding she is, the impatient nature, the threats. maybe you didn't mention the positive things that make your relationship worthwhile, but from your story, it seems like all the above are ingredients for a painful, one-sided, emotionally exhausting "relationship."

i don't like finalizing things without giving the person one last chance, so i say talk to her one last time. tell her how you genuinely feel without giving in to her attempts to win your sympathy. set things straight, or otherwise state your terms. if she still resists, my advice is to end it.

because she has pushed things along so unnaturally fast, can you even say without a doubt, and without her threats hovering over your conscience like an iron fist, that you love her? you even described it as getting backed into a corner. everything you've described makes me see her as a spoiled, selfish woman who has led you into a full-time job, not a relationship where both sides give and receive equally. her uncompromising ways and lack of consideration for your needs spells a recipe for disaster. in the end, if you've thought about it and are convinced that you really love her, stick with her. but do not allow yourself to be tricked into believing that you love her.

best of luck to you
 
Upvote 0

GeorgiaGuyinAtlanta

Regular Member
Mar 13, 2006
1,081
244
Atlanta, Georgia Metropolitan Area, U.S.A.
✟15,479.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Inperfected said:
ONe question... Did she get out of a relationship or did he?

Note that there was another engagement, and i suspect with no change on her part...
She got out of the relationship. She tells me that it was a painful three month engagement, of which she "was crying everyday. She says that she knew that he wasn't the man for her, and that she had been trying to convince herself that it was to be.

Earlier in our relationship, I remember her saying that her ex-fiance had complained of stuff "she does", and that he was complaining about the "stuff she does". I imagine that that "stuff" was the impatient nature. The difference between me and him is that he actually wanted to marry her at the time, and I'm not ready for it. In fact, he still calls her from time to time, hoping to rekindle something, of which she wants no part of it, regardless of whether she is in a present relationship with me.
 
Upvote 0
L

loved

Guest
I say break up with her also.

She sounds Psycho, seriously.

I love my SO so much but I would never try to "manipulate" him into marrying me before he was ready.

I also wouldn't want to ring him 10 times a night- I feel blessed if he makes an effort to ring me once a night because I know he is always busy busy busy.

A relationship is supposed to be fun, you're not married to this girl, you can still escape!!! run run run
 
Upvote 0

YouthPastor

Name = Brett
Feb 11, 2003
702
33
Visit site
✟23,526.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
ummmm how do I say this.....

RUN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I did not read your whole post - I couldn't.

Try this... remove yourself from the situation for a minute... then go back and read your post.

Does she sound healthy (mentally/emotionally)?

Does what she is doing sound right?

SHouldn't she want to become friends before pushing into marriage?

let me put it this way..

RUN!!!!!!!!!!

DO not marry her!!!! if you do.. you think it ias bad now.... just wait until after you say I do.

You read your post - read it as if your were reading about someone else -

and then - answer the questions you asked?

Should this guy marry her?

Is this woman normal?

SHould he break up with her?
 
Upvote 0

bliz

Contributor
Jun 5, 2004
9,360
1,110
Here
✟14,830.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
There are huge red flags flying in your face.

It seems very clear that her agenda is to get a husband, as opposed to wanting to spend her whole life with you. This is not about love. This is about something else, and it isn't something good or healthy.

Her hissy fits have been working, so who can blame her for using them over and over again? I second the advice.... RUUUUUUNNNNNNNNNNNnnnnnnn.
 
Upvote 0

Theogonia

Well-Known Member
Jan 9, 2006
9,103
142
35
Bethlehem, Pennsylvania
✟10,109.00
Faith
Pantheist
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Democrat
I don't see why you think it's not normal for her to want to marry you after a only year. My mom and dad knew they wanted to get married after a week. But all the other stuff is not normal. I think you need to break it off. If she's like this now, it's almost certain she'll be like this after your married.
 
Upvote 0

beautifully_chaotic

Active Member
Feb 15, 2006
231
4
perth
Visit site
✟381.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Engaged
Politics
AU-Liberals
do you honestly think you would be able to survive a long term relationship with her and remain sane?

i would say if your not sure... then either slow things Right down so you control the pace or just breakup! its not worth the heartache!
 
Upvote 0

TheReasoner

Atheist. Former Christian.
Mar 14, 2005
10,294
684
Norway
✟44,662.00
Country
Norway
Gender
Male
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Married
This sounds like my ex. It only got worse from the point you seem to be in. Had you not stated this was in the states I would have wondered if your gf is my ex. I know that three days after I (finally) left she found another guy, three weeks after that they got engaged. Three months later she left him for another guy. She was sick, and seemed to have a fascination for the number three :p
Before that, when we were "an item" she said she could not live without me, that I meant the world to her. Even after I left her she kept on going on like that for about four or five days. Notice how it took her THREE days to get together with a another guy?! Bad news.

Regardless.
For me, things got a lot worse. This girl, like my ex, has problems. Issues she needs to deal with before she is ready to marry anyone.

I am sorry, I know this must be hard for you. But I think it is breakup time.

Oh. And if she is anything like my ex, she will get a LOT worse the first few days after you break up with her. She will probably call you, and may even threaten to take her own life. Then she will probably get over you very quickly. Because what you are describing is a mental illness. And it is FAR from love.
Should she threaten you, remember this;
That will be HER decision if she does so (which she extremely likely will not). You cannot loose your life to her. She has no right to control or manipulate you like she does - and will do for as long as you stay with her. Get out is my advice. Do NOT allow her to overrun you any more. Do not allow her to manipulate and force you to do hings against your will, or so on. Just get out!
My advice, and I put all my weight behind this advice;
RUUUUNNNNNNNN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Upvote 0

YouthPastor

Name = Brett
Feb 11, 2003
702
33
Visit site
✟23,526.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
ScottyL said:
I don't see why you think it's not normal for her to want to marry you after a only year. My mom and dad knew they wanted to get married after a week. But all the other stuff is not normal. I think you need to break it off. If she's like this now, it's almost certain she'll be like this after your married.

The part you just mentioned is not the real issue - it is everything else.

By itself - wanting to get married after a year is not bad. But if I recall correctly she was hounding him for marriage within months!
 
Upvote 0

Amy47

Well-Known Member
Oct 12, 2005
607
15
39
Kingsville
✟23,386.00
Faith
Christian
Politics
CA-Conservatives
It's time to break it off.
That being said, one thing I would like to mention is, it seems like you are scared of marriage. I know You don't think it's an issue but what is the issue then? It takes two for a relationship to work and you mentioned all the things that your gf did wrong, but you didn't tell us what you've done to help the situation. I'm not saying you should stay with her, I mean if you're not happy, obviously that's not a good sign, but take a better look at the whole issue. What could you have done to save the relationship.

God Bless
 
Upvote 0

GeorgiaGuyinAtlanta

Regular Member
Mar 13, 2006
1,081
244
Atlanta, Georgia Metropolitan Area, U.S.A.
✟15,479.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
YouthPastor said:
ummmm how do I say this.....

RUN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I did not read your whole post - I couldn't.

Try this... remove yourself from the situation for a minute... then go back and read your post.

Does she sound healthy (mentally/emotionally)?

Does what she is doing sound right?

SHouldn't she want to become friends before pushing into marriage?

let me put it this way..

RUN!!!!!!!!!!

DO not marry her!!!! if you do.. you think it ias bad now.... just wait until after you say I do.

You read your post - read it as if your were reading about someone else -

and then - answer the questions you asked?

Should this guy marry her?

Is this woman normal?

SHould he break up with her?
Why certainly, I don't think that she's exactly treating me in the best manner. However, she does have a lot of good qualities:

1. She's a Christian
2. We read the Bible together
3. She makes me things (croched two blankets; made a sock cap for me; makes cds)
4. She buys me things (it's the thought I like).
5. She compliments me.
6. She loves me.
 
Upvote 0

GeorgiaGuyinAtlanta

Regular Member
Mar 13, 2006
1,081
244
Atlanta, Georgia Metropolitan Area, U.S.A.
✟15,479.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
YouthPastor said:
The part you just mentioned is not the real issue - it is everything else.

By itself - wanting to get married after a year is not bad. But if I recall correctly she was hounding him for marriage within months!
That is correct. I would have had no problem asking her to marry me if I wouldn't have been subjected to the constant hounding. It has weighed on my emotions and prevented the relationship from developing to the point where it needs to be.
 
Upvote 0

GeorgiaGuyinAtlanta

Regular Member
Mar 13, 2006
1,081
244
Atlanta, Georgia Metropolitan Area, U.S.A.
✟15,479.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Amy47 said:
It's time to break it off.
That being said, one thing I would like to mention is, it seems like you are scared of marriage. I know You don't think it's an issue but what is the issue then? It takes two for a relationship to work and you mentioned all the things that your gf did wrong, but you didn't tell us what you've done to help the situation. I'm not saying you should stay with her, I mean if you're not happy, obviously that's not a good sign, but take a better look at the whole issue. What could you have done to save the relationship.

God Bless
I'm not scared of marriage. It's the nature of the relationship that I am in. If she would not have been so anxious, harping on marriage, I'm sure that I'd have asked her by now. It caused the relationship to become stunted.
 
Upvote 0

nahMish

Regular Member
Apr 24, 2004
125
7
42
Sydney, Australia
✟22,791.00
Faith
Protestant
GeorgiaGuyinAtlanta said:
Why certainly, I don't think that she's exactly treating me in the best manner. However, she does have a lot of good qualities:

1. She's a Christian
2. We read the Bible together
3. She makes me things (croched two blankets; made a sock cap for me; makes cds)
4. She buys me things (it's the thought I like).
5. She compliments me.
6. She loves me.

what about things like:
*she is a woman of GOd
*she loves people and is willing to give whatever it takes to help someone
*she is perceptive & a good listener
*she has a quiet spirit and sees the best in things...and in me !
*humble
*she's my best friend
*i cant believe SHE wants to be with ME
*she puts others before herself
*she sees a hurt in me before i can even put a finger on it
*we are good at compromising during arguments..can get our points across without things going crazy.

anyway...maybe those things are some of th ethings that should be on your list.
and for others reading this-please dont pick apart the list..its just a few ideas thats all: i wrote it in 1 minute flat.
 
Upvote 0