I can't answer this without adding to your challenge, so I suspect you will just dismiss my answer.
Anyway.
If you create this man with no memories, and a body that showed no evidence of disease, or accident, so their was no history to it, then there is no deception and no intent to decieve that I can see.
If you create this man with 60 years of memories, an apendictomy scar, a trick need and the memories of the account that caused it etc, then I would say you are being deceptive, certainly to that man. You have made him believe he is 60 years old, and given him evidence he cannot refuse. He is either 60 years old or he is 1 minute old with 60 years of fake history.
Now, I assume this is in relation to the embedded age of the earth idea. If you tell me you created the man as per senario 1, I would agree that you personally are not being deceptive. However, I will agree that this is analogous to the earth. The earth is (if it was created ex-nihilo 6100 years ago) was created as per senario 2.