Mecca?

[MercuryAndy]

Why aren't i allowed in mecca?

EDIT: see Mod Hat post

 

[français]

because we're not muslim.

i guess it's just predjduced.

if the jews ever tried to block muslims from visiting jerusalem, there would be riots everywhere.

 

[MercuryAndy]

We should riot.

 

[HumbleSiPilot77]

Why aren't i allowed in mecca?

What does this tell you?

 

[MercuryAndy]

What does this tell you?

why do you try and answer a question with another question?

 

[HumbleSiPilot77]

I was not answering you. There is a reason you ask this question, furthermore someone else already gave you a reason. At this time, you should have the thought process as to "why" you are not allowed? Now based upon that can my question "What does this tell you?" be NOT answered?

 

[MercuryAndy]

I was not answering you. There is a reason you ask this question, furthermore someone else already gave you a reason. At this time, you should have the thought process as to "why" you are not allowed? Now based upon that can my question "What does this tell you?" be NOT answered?

my question was why arnt i allowed in mecca. I know non muslims are not allowed into mecca and thats why i asked.

 

[HumbleSiPilot77]

OK, so you know non-muslims are NOT allowed, what does this tell you?

 

[I_are_sceptical]

If someone puts up a sign that says "Private property. No trespassing" do you think their wishes should be respected?

 

[français]

If someone puts up a sign that says "Private property. No trespassing" do you think their wishes should be respected?

depends on the situation.

if it's at a home, and someone doesn't want others on their property, then yes, we should respect their wishes. but if there was a resturant that said "whites only" we should not respect it. so it all depends on the situation.

but when you make a city where only muslims can go.. that's crazy!

 

[Raul7]

depends on the situation.

if it's at a home, and someone doesn't want others on their property, then yes, we should respect their wishes. but if there was a resturant that said "whites only" we should not respect it. so it all depends on the situation.

but when you make a city where only muslims can go.. that's crazy!

That's a horrible analogy, everyone can become Muslim but no-one can change the color of their skin.

 

[français]

That's a horrible analogy, everyone can become Muslim but no-one can change the color of their skin.

so if america only allowed christians to live here, you wouldn't have a problem with that? because you can always become christian.

if europe decided to stop letting immigrants in from muslim nations, and made everyone be required to be chrsitian, you would be ok with that?

even if not a whole nation or a continent, but let's just say a city. if you had to be christian to enter paris or jerusalem, or something like that, you would have no problem with that?

 

[I_are_sceptical]

depends on the situation.

if it's at a home, and someone doesn't want others on their property, then yes, we should respect their wishes. but if there was a resturant that said "whites only" we should not respect it. so it all depends on the situation.

Okay, suppose a non-Christian group wanted a rack for their books, pamphlets, films, and music in a Christian bookstore. Should that be allowed?

but when you make a city where only muslims can go.. that's crazy!

Who makes that decision?

 

[I_are_sceptical]

let's just say a city. if you had to be christian to enter paris or jerusalem, or something like that, you would have no problem with that?

Let's say Vatican City. What percentage of the population is non-Catholic? Should synagogues and mosques be allowed there?

 

[français]

Let's say Vatican City. What percentage of the population is non-Catholic? Should synagogues and mosques be allowed there?

vatican city is a government place. besides the officials of the catholic church, no one lives there. but i'm sure that if they did have homes, non catholics would be allowed to live there. plus non catholics can enter vatican city!

 

[czach8]

because we're not muslim.

i guess it's just predjduced.

if the jews ever tried to block muslims from visiting jerusalem, there would be riots everywhere.

Actually, many Palestinians were once Jews at one time, so your comparison is frivolous.

 

[czach8]

Well mormons do not allow outsiders in their church. Even country clubs will not allow non-members in their club. Therefore, if you are not a part of the Islamic club, then you are not allowed in mosque in Mecca. In any case, I have heard reporters, not Muslim, were allowed in the mosque. Come to think of it, anyone can enter the mosque in Mecca, for it is not that hard.

Peace.

 

[czach8]

depends on the situation.

if it's at a home, and someone doesn't want others on their property, then yes, we should respect their wishes. but if there was a resturant that said "whites only" we should not respect it. so it all depends on the situation.

but when you make a city where only muslims can go.. that's crazy!

Actually, this is not true, there are many foreigners who live in Mecca, let alone most of Saudi Arabia.

 

[français]

Actually, this is not true, there are many foreigners who live in Mecca, let alone most of Saudi Arabia.

yeah but if they live in mecca they are muslim.. they have to be lol.

 

[HumbleSiPilot77]

That's a horrible analogy, everyone can become Muslim but no-one can change the color of their skin.

Analogy might be far fetched BUT it was RIGHT on the ball. Do you know a person called MICHAEL JACKSON? Tell me his skin color!