Good... I was thinking I'd have to change the title of this thread to "Masturbation and parasitic insects" ... which is a combination I'd rather not imagne.
If it is a preparation for the unitive act - foreplay - it's OK. But the "training" comparison does not hold, because the truth is, you DON'T neeed to touch to train your body for sex. And it's NOT hard work, nor does it hurt .... quite the contrary... so let's just say that this sounds suspiciously like trying to find an excuse!!!...
There was only one person who said such, which is why I made sure it was the consensus... because it seemed to be glossed over the last time I asked.
I'm not looking for "excuses" ... I'm just horribly opposed to "blanket statements." So here's a situation: MANY sexual disorders (esp. "finishing" too early or having a difficult time finishing at all) are purely psychological. It's a matter of people getting nervous or distracted or just focusing on the wrong thing. Most examples are too graphic to be listed here... but pretend a couple went to therapy because the wife just never seemed to enjoy it... which made the husband feel as though even procreative sex were a selfish thing for him to ask of her. What if she was interested in it, but she was just constantly plagued with distractions and worries, and was just so focused on pleasing her mate, she got no satisfaction herself. There's nothing wrong with wanting to please your spouse, that's a wonderful thing! But, what would be immoral about a woman "practicing" to just get to know how her own body reacts, so that she could enjoy the process as well in order for the husband to have the same sense of accomplishment. So that it could once again be a unitive, loving, mutual act... not just the wife trying to please a husband who's trying to please the wife but can't because she's too distracted to be pleased herself?
... It would be a product of love FOR her husband, not lust. So that's not an issue. And she's a girl, so there's no issue with "seed." And while she would be alone, she would be doing so FOR her husband, so it wouldn't be selfish. And doing so wouldn't deprive him of anything because she'd be perfectly capable of "fulfilling her wifely duty" after "the warm up game."
So, in what way would it be sinful?
(notice, I'm not claiming that it's not, but asking for the official catholic viewpoint. People may learn from the catholic response to this post, but teaching is void where prohibited. These are intended to actually be questions, not leads.)