• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

Marriage question

j.k.

Newbie
Jun 23, 2010
4
0
✟22,614.00
Faith
Presbyterian
I'm pretty ashamed to admit that I'm in such a situation but...it is so, so I came to ask for any biblical advice you may have to offer.

Some years ago (beginning in 2001) I was with my first "girlfriend." I was at least a professing Christian at the time, but frankly have no idea whether I had been given any saving grace. She was not Christian (and still is not from what I understand of the infrequent contacts that she still sends me, although she has once in a while mentioned an interest in learning more but it has not progressed to anything that I have noticed). We did a lot of things which I'm ashamed of..and I don't think it's necessary to go into detail on those for the purpose of this question.

She lives in a foreign country, and I would go sometimes but was not able to stay as I could not get a job or a long term visa there. One time, before I left (I am fairly confident it was during 2002), I typed up and printed something similar to a marriage contract. I don't remember the exact wording that I wrote, although I guess that I probably wrote some things that came to mind rather than copying directly from anything. It's like I wanted to have something of an assurance of having here even though I had to go away. Frankly, I didn't consider it to be an actual marriage, which makes it ridiculous that I would use such language -- but by now I'm used to doing ridiculous things. She did not want to sign it, but eventually I made her, and I did as well.

I don't know if the paper is still in existence any longer. It's possible that she may have it as she has kept some of the things that I left there the last time I was there (in 2003). I'm fairly sure that I wrote something along the lines of "...in the presence of God, and these witnesses." There were no other witnesses to have signed it in the place that I provided for their signatures...however, it's certain that God witnessed the event. Which is what I'm getting at... does God consider this to be a marriage? I know it would mean nothing in the eyes of the state, but frankly I care very little about that, because what I'm concerned with is whether by not being in a marriage with this girl I'm sinning against the Lord (that is, if it is considered a valid marriage, or not necessarily a valid marriage but still an obligation for me to enter into a valid marriage).

Another point to consider, I'm pretty sure she "slept" with someone else after that time (although I'm not completely sure, she did admit to doing so, but I think she may have retracted that admission at some time, and may have later admitted again that she did -- frankly I don't know). Sadly, though, I did this as well. So, if this were a valid marriage, I'm not even sure whether this (would-be adultery) would even qualify as a reason for ending it.

Also, I know many times she wanted to "break up" (a sign that at least she didn't consider it to be a valid marriage, because she never said she wanted to divorce me). Although I don't even remember any particular time that I agreed with her that we would, but around the end of 2005 we just stopped having an interest in continuing the relationship (and around then was when she and I both did what I mentioned above). So again, as she was an unbeliever, if this is a valid marriage, would I still be right to allow her to leave since she wanted to? And (if all that is the case), what if she wanted to get back together, would I also be required to take her back? She has occasionally mentioned some "feelings" for me, which I'm assuming means she has some remorse over our falling out.

Frankly, I'm not interested in the same things as I was back then. I want a marriage with a godly woman, if I'm to have such a relationship. However, more important than that, it would seem, is to honor the marriage in which God put us together, if it be so. Ultimately, that's what I'm trying to find out. Is this a valid marriage in the eyes of our Lord?

I may have other questions to ask...perhaps further advice about this situation, as well as other issues that I'm dealing with. However, I'd like to get started here. For any biblical, Christ-glorifying advice, I'm very thankful. If you're willing to discuss with me in private, either on this topic or other issues, please do send me a PM or notify me in this thread.
 

AndOne

Deliver me oh Lord, from evil men
Apr 20, 2002
7,477
462
Florida
✟28,628.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Calvinist
Marital Status
Married
Is this a valid marriage in the eyes of our Lord?

I think any marriage between a man and a woman is a valid marriage in the eyes of the Lord.

BUT - if I were in your shoes I would not have a romantic relationship or contemplate marriage with this woman until you are sure she is of the faith. Thats my 2 cents...
 
Upvote 0

j.k.

Newbie
Jun 23, 2010
4
0
✟22,614.00
Faith
Presbyterian
I think any marriage between a man and a woman is a valid marriage in the eyes of the Lord.

BUT - if I were in your shoes I would not have a romantic relationship or contemplate marriage with this woman until you are sure she is of the faith. Thats my 2 cents...
Hi Behe's Boy,

That's my question, of whether what I have done already is considered marriage? If it is not already one, then I'm not interested in marrying her (she's not of the faith).

Thanks for taking the time.
 
Upvote 0

AndOne

Deliver me oh Lord, from evil men
Apr 20, 2002
7,477
462
Florida
✟28,628.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Calvinist
Marital Status
Married
Hi Behe's Boy,

That's my question, of whether what I have done already is considered marriage? If it is not already one, then I'm not interested in marrying her (she's not of the faith).

Thanks for taking the time.

In my opinion it is not. I don't see how it can be seeing as it is not an official document. Most marriages liscenses require a notary or some kind of qualified official oversight. I don't see how you can draw up a document and see it as qualifying as marriage.
 
Upvote 0

j.k.

Newbie
Jun 23, 2010
4
0
✟22,614.00
Faith
Presbyterian
In my opinion it is not. I don't see how it can be seeing as it is not an official document. Most marriages liscenses require a notary or some kind of qualified official oversight. I don't see how you can draw up a document and see it as qualifying as marriage.
Thanks again, Behe's Boy. I do understand what you're saying. It certainly isn't valid, humanly speaking -- neither in her country nor mine. I think the fact that it wasn't even completed to its own requirements (there were no witnesses) also makes it invalid.

I just want to be sure that not being with her is not a further sin. That whole relationship was filled with so much... I really have no interest in restarting it. If that can be done without sin.
 
Upvote 0

Maasive10

Newbie
Aug 11, 2008
19
0
Canada
✟22,629.00
Faith
Protestant
Marital Status
Married
I agree with Behe - I don't believe it was a real marriage in the sight of God or man - there was no blessing given upon the marriage by an ordained minister - so I believe that it can't be considered valid. I would do what Behe said and ask for forgiveness, and move on.

All the best..
 
Upvote 0

Jon_

Senior Veteran
Jan 30, 2005
2,998
91
43
California
✟26,116.00
Faith
Presbyterian
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
I'm pretty ashamed to admit that I'm in such a situation but...it is so, so I came to ask for any biblical advice you may have to offer.
Any time I read a post like this on an Internet forum I feel compelled to immediately respond in this way: talk to your pastor and your elders. Christ has ordained spiritual leadership precisely for things like this. Don't rely on the advice of strangers on a forum, even if they have your best interests at heart. Your church leadership is eminently more qualified to comment on this than any of us.

Some years ago (beginning in 2001) I was with my first "girlfriend." I was at least a professing Christian at the time, but frankly have no idea whether I had been given any saving grace. She was not Christian (and still is not from what I understand of the infrequent contacts that she still sends me, although she has once in a while mentioned an interest in learning more but it has not progressed to anything that I have noticed). We did a lot of things which I'm ashamed of..and I don't think it's necessary to go into detail on those for the purpose of this question.

She lives in a foreign country, and I would go sometimes but was not able to stay as I could not get a job or a long term visa there. One time, before I left (I am fairly confident it was during 2002), I typed up and printed something similar to a marriage contract. I don't remember the exact wording that I wrote, although I guess that I probably wrote some things that came to mind rather than copying directly from anything. It's like I wanted to have something of an assurance of having here even though I had to go away. Frankly, I didn't consider it to be an actual marriage, which makes it ridiculous that I would use such language -- but by now I'm used to doing ridiculous things. She did not want to sign it, but eventually I made her, and I did as well.

I don't know if the paper is still in existence any longer. It's possible that she may have it as she has kept some of the things that I left there the last time I was there (in 2003). I'm fairly sure that I wrote something along the lines of "...in the presence of God, and these witnesses." There were no other witnesses to have signed it in the place that I provided for their signatures...however, it's certain that God witnessed the event. Which is what I'm getting at... does God consider this to be a marriage? I know it would mean nothing in the eyes of the state, but frankly I care very little about that, because what I'm concerned with is whether by not being in a marriage with this girl I'm sinning against the Lord (that is, if it is considered a valid marriage, or not necessarily a valid marriage but still an obligation for me to enter into a valid marriage).

Another point to consider, I'm pretty sure she "slept" with someone else after that time (although I'm not completely sure, she did admit to doing so, but I think she may have retracted that admission at some time, and may have later admitted again that she did -- frankly I don't know). Sadly, though, I did this as well. So, if this were a valid marriage, I'm not even sure whether this (would-be adultery) would even qualify as a reason for ending it.

Also, I know many times she wanted to "break up" (a sign that at least she didn't consider it to be a valid marriage, because she never said she wanted to divorce me). Although I don't even remember any particular time that I agreed with her that we would, but around the end of 2005 we just stopped having an interest in continuing the relationship (and around then was when she and I both did what I mentioned above). So again, as she was an unbeliever, if this is a valid marriage, would I still be right to allow her to leave since she wanted to? And (if all that is the case), what if she wanted to get back together, would I also be required to take her back? She has occasionally mentioned some "feelings" for me, which I'm assuming means she has some remorse over our falling out.

Frankly, I'm not interested in the same things as I was back then. I want a marriage with a godly woman, if I'm to have such a relationship. However, more important than that, it would seem, is to honor the marriage in which God put us together, if it be so. Ultimately, that's what I'm trying to find out. Is this a valid marriage in the eyes of our Lord?

I may have other questions to ask...perhaps further advice about this situation, as well as other issues that I'm dealing with. However, I'd like to get started here. For any biblical, Christ-glorifying advice, I'm very thankful. If you're willing to discuss with me in private, either on this topic or other issues, please do send me a PM or notify me in this thread.
Doesn't sound like a marriage to me. Signing a piece of paper is not the same as exchanging oaths in the sight of God and witnesses. You didn't exchange rings--the sign of the covenant between you, and there was never any public acknowledgment of the marriage as legitimate and valid.

Soli Deo Gloria

Jon
 
Upvote 0
A

Anoetos

Guest
I tend to agree with Jon here. An important part of Christian Marriage is the public exchange of vows. Before the people of God a man and a woman voluntarily and publicly covenant together to be married. The public nature of this exchange is essential. The mere intention to do so, whether it is written and signed or not, is insufficient since it is not public.

In addition, here in the west, it is also necessary for that marriage to have some kind of state recognition and a license granted by the governing authorities.

You may also be thinking of those places in Scripture fornication is equated with marriage, but it's important to realize that the point here is that the act is one which is equated with the married state such that performance of it outside of that state amounts to the arrogation of privileges not really available to people who are not actually married.

In short, only married people should be doing it.

It sounds like you truly regret the whole episode and everything that went along with it, so my advice to you would be to let it go and to live in the light.

ETA: I also agree with Jon that you should be talking to your elders if only to receive from them an assurance of pardon, they being the men given charge over you in these matters.
 
Upvote 0