- Oct 4, 2010
- 13,243
- 6,313
- Country
- United States
- Gender
- Male
- Faith
- Christian
- Marital Status
- Married
Hi AL,
As I said, the passage doesn't indicate the length of time that the sun will be darkened. It just says that it will. During the plagues on Egypt the sun was also darkened for a length of three days.
Then the LORD said to Moses, "Stretch out your hand toward the sky so that darkness will spread over Egypt--darkness that can be felt." So Moses stretched out his hand toward the sky, and total darkness covered all Egypt for three days. No one could see anyone else or leave his place for three days. Yet all the Israelites had light in the places where they lived.
This darkness was even more amazing than how the darkness is explained in Matthew. This darkness was only over the land of Egypt, but where the Israelites lived they had light. God's power and abilities in working with the physical bodies contained within this realm that He created for us to live in is awesome. He can cause the sun to stand still in its place in the sky. He can cause the sun to go backwards in its place in the sky above us. He can cause water to stand up straight and tall to create a dry canyon through it. He can surely cause the sun to darken, as this passage says, but only for a relatively short time. Further, I think it very possible that the inclusion of the moon not giving its light is said for the very purpose that we understand that the whole earth will see this 'sign'. Since we know that the light of the moon is a reflection of the sun's light, it would naturally follow that the moon would not shine if the sun was not giving light. But so that we would understand that the whole world is going to see this miraculous 'sign', the passage further includes for us that the moon will also be dark.
So, the scenario could very likely be that the sun goes completely dark for a few hours or a day or two and then comes back to giving its light as Jesus returns to take those who are his. It could also be that the sun turns dark in the middle of the day for some, remember that it is always dark somewhere on the earth. This would also explain why it includes the account of the moon. Pretty much at any time upon the earth we are either seeing the sun or the moon and so by telling us that the sun and the moon go dark, then everyone on the earth will see this 'sign'. However, supposing that the sun just supernaturally goes dark within moments by God's command, those who were just 10 minutes ago working in the field would still be out in the field. So, yes, the sun can go dark and there be people out in the fields.
Therefore, your supposition that the gathering to the Lord could only happen before the tribulation because people only work in fields when it is daylight, cannot be supported by this Scripture. I think it elementary to understand that this darkening of the sun will not be some natural phenomenon that people will see coming or that will take a particularly long time to occur. The sun will be shining one moment and the next it won't. People will be at their jobs and working in fields when this happens and it will come about quickly enough that they will still be right there where they were when moments before the sun was shining.
This is similar to the argument made that the first days of creation cannot be accurate because there wasn't any sun. By definition of what determines a 'day' upon any of the planets in our solar system, the sun is not necessary. A day is merely the time it takes for any individual planet to make one complete rotation on its axis. So, a day can pass on the earth without there ever having been a sun included in our solar system at all. They would all surely be dark days, but days nevertheless.
God bless you
In Christ, Ted
As I said, the passage doesn't indicate the length of time that the sun will be darkened. It just says that it will. During the plagues on Egypt the sun was also darkened for a length of three days.
Then the LORD said to Moses, "Stretch out your hand toward the sky so that darkness will spread over Egypt--darkness that can be felt." So Moses stretched out his hand toward the sky, and total darkness covered all Egypt for three days. No one could see anyone else or leave his place for three days. Yet all the Israelites had light in the places where they lived.
This darkness was even more amazing than how the darkness is explained in Matthew. This darkness was only over the land of Egypt, but where the Israelites lived they had light. God's power and abilities in working with the physical bodies contained within this realm that He created for us to live in is awesome. He can cause the sun to stand still in its place in the sky. He can cause the sun to go backwards in its place in the sky above us. He can cause water to stand up straight and tall to create a dry canyon through it. He can surely cause the sun to darken, as this passage says, but only for a relatively short time. Further, I think it very possible that the inclusion of the moon not giving its light is said for the very purpose that we understand that the whole earth will see this 'sign'. Since we know that the light of the moon is a reflection of the sun's light, it would naturally follow that the moon would not shine if the sun was not giving light. But so that we would understand that the whole world is going to see this miraculous 'sign', the passage further includes for us that the moon will also be dark.
So, the scenario could very likely be that the sun goes completely dark for a few hours or a day or two and then comes back to giving its light as Jesus returns to take those who are his. It could also be that the sun turns dark in the middle of the day for some, remember that it is always dark somewhere on the earth. This would also explain why it includes the account of the moon. Pretty much at any time upon the earth we are either seeing the sun or the moon and so by telling us that the sun and the moon go dark, then everyone on the earth will see this 'sign'. However, supposing that the sun just supernaturally goes dark within moments by God's command, those who were just 10 minutes ago working in the field would still be out in the field. So, yes, the sun can go dark and there be people out in the fields.
Therefore, your supposition that the gathering to the Lord could only happen before the tribulation because people only work in fields when it is daylight, cannot be supported by this Scripture. I think it elementary to understand that this darkening of the sun will not be some natural phenomenon that people will see coming or that will take a particularly long time to occur. The sun will be shining one moment and the next it won't. People will be at their jobs and working in fields when this happens and it will come about quickly enough that they will still be right there where they were when moments before the sun was shining.
This is similar to the argument made that the first days of creation cannot be accurate because there wasn't any sun. By definition of what determines a 'day' upon any of the planets in our solar system, the sun is not necessary. A day is merely the time it takes for any individual planet to make one complete rotation on its axis. So, a day can pass on the earth without there ever having been a sun included in our solar system at all. They would all surely be dark days, but days nevertheless.
God bless you
In Christ, Ted
Upvote
0