• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

Is it true that Moses can survive without food and water for 40 days?

Richard.20.12

Well-Known Member
Dec 13, 2020
660
229
Vancouver
✟48,736.00
Country
Canada
Gender
Male
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
The hand symbol is different from the devil horns. That should be clear. There are similarities, but it's a completely different hand symbol.

This is the last time I will bring this up. It seems like you were condemning me based on something I repented of. Was that your intention? If it was, then you are out of line, as that should not be held against me.
I'm not condemning you! Not a bit! I'm merely making a suggestion. You're dramatizing my responses into something they're not. I understand your intentions are good. Of course. I don't understand how you can read my words and get that.

And yes, to be clear, the devil's horns does not use the extended thumb whereas other signs do (deaf people, surfers). The hand sign for Longhorn University does. See the images. As they are in what most would consider a highly Christian area this is strange. longhorn university handsign at DuckDuckGo

I hope this settles this. Just assume we are WITH you, not against you. Life works better that way. And a suggestion or even a criticism is NOT a personal attack. Focus on the subject, not yourself.
 
Upvote 0

Richard.20.12

Well-Known Member
Dec 13, 2020
660
229
Vancouver
✟48,736.00
Country
Canada
Gender
Male
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
It seems the consensus is that Moses’ fast was effected by God.

When it comes to the issue of Jesus’ fast, it seems we should be considering the fact that he was and is the God-Man which may well have affected how his human body could function. Yes he laid aside his divine attributes to accomplish his earthly assignment, but I believe the exact nature of the hypostatic union boils down to mystery, plain and simple.

The Word-Faithists claim he accomplished his miracles by virtue of Holy Spirit baptism which is untrue, and no such thing exists at any rate. He performed his miracles because he was God himself. E.g. his walking on water.

I believe he accomplished his fast either through the Providence of God as did Moses, or because he was and is the God-Man.
Lots of people all over the world have gone 40+ days without food on nothing but water. I'm one of them. All it takes is a reasonably pure diet beforehand and a comfortable bed....:) And practice so we don't misinterpret symptoms we experience. That's easy. Just read books on water fasting. Its not very complicated.

Now there are a few people that claim they can go long periods with dry fasting (no water). Personally I don't believe them. I'm still curious if its possible somehow and even if there are benefits to it.

There's another factor that nobody has mentioned about Moses who went 40 days without food or water. Look at that region he was in. Not that we know exactly what it was like back then but have you ever seen a river near the top of a mountain? Where exactly would the water come from? I don't think there was any water up there available which would explain why God would have had to intervene if He wanted Moses to remain up there for an extended period and 40 days is a very extended period.

Most Biblical references to fasting imply that someone desired greater connection with God and didn't interrupt their prayer with food because it would break up their prayer time. This actually makes a lot of sense, just as much then as today. We all hate interruptions of any kind. They stop our mental flow, our concentration. And eating would definitely interrupt whatever they were praying about. Basically it gets in the way.

It also might tell us that their prayer wasn't just for a few minutes. It was long enough that it interrupted one or more meals. How often do you hear of anyone today praying for 6+ hours at a stretch doing nothing else? That takes strong commitment. (What is interesting is when you're fasting you're pretty weak and spend most of your time lying in bed daydreaming. This makes for a perfect opportunity to commune with God and pray. And to reflect on your life, both the positive and negative. After a few days though you tend to focus on the positive and it becomes very mentally uplifting. This hugely counteracts the mental boredom that naturally occurs when you don't have the energy to do much of anything! Our mental disposition just ramps up a lot after a few days.

Esther 4:16
Go, gather together all the Jews who are in Susa, and fast for me. Do not eat or drink for three days, night or day. I and my attendants will fast as you do.

Exodus 34:28
Moses was there with the LORD forty days and forty nights without eating bread or drinking water.

If anyone knows of any other examples of dry fasting or fasting with no water please let us know. Someone would have to be mighty well hydrated to go 3 days without water and food. Most medical people claim we can't live without water for 4 days but that's in situations with no preparation, like when you get buried in an earthquake. In the wilderness people usually ration their water so they were probably in a state of severe dehydration for many days before they died. This doesn't tell us much about how it would be if the person was well prepared. No salt intake for several days + lots and lots of water for several hours before they start. Almost everyone out there is not well hydrated.
 
Upvote 0

Richard.20.12

Well-Known Member
Dec 13, 2020
660
229
Vancouver
✟48,736.00
Country
Canada
Gender
Male
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
It just occurred to me why the Bible doesn't talk about this more. Because IF you fasted a lot you would KNOW that it was physically impossible for any person to exist for 40 days without water. The problem today is almost nobody ever fasts! But back then it was common. Maybe not for 40 days but certainly a few days at a time. It was also used when people got sick because what's the first thing people feel when they get sick? They don't want any food! You lose your appetite. So do almost all animals! Just going 3 days feels like your insides are being cleansed with a bulldozer. Its really physically traumatic but in a good, yet weakened way. You have the strength of a kitten! And if you forget to drink water regularly and have a nap you tend to wake up with such a dry mouth which feels awful and this is only for a small part of the day. 40 days??? When fasting water becomes your very dear friend and companion. You wouldn't dream of leaving your home without it if fasting. Its like a lifeline. Another problem when fasting is if you forget to drink for a while: Your stomach shrinks and you get severe hunger pangs which makes fasting oh so much harder. But when you keep a constant flow of water in your stomach this doesn't happen and you don't get hungry at all when fasting. No matter how long (until your fat reserves are depleted around day 40 of course at which point you get that sudden hunger I described earlier and have to eat).
 
Upvote 0