Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
On the contrary, if it were shown that information is permanently lost in a black hole, that would reinforce the information paradox; it is fundamental to quantum mechanics that information should not be lost.
"Hello, Ophiolite! Thanks for your response. Causality is cause and effect, correct? So, if determinism is obliterated, and you don't possess knowledge of a systems probable past histories, or the probabilistic outcomes of its future, all you'll know is its present state. I'm not a physicist or a philosopher, but wouldn't this impede ones attempt at understanding a systems current state, and render cause and effect meaningless? Please have mercy on me with your answer, and reply in laymens language. Thanks!"
I see no connection between those points and the loss of information in a black hole. It was that connection I was seeking an explanation for. "Obliteration of determinism" in one discrete portion of the universe, that has characteristics absent from all the rest of the universe, seems unlikely to extend the consequences from the black hole to everywhere else.
I see no connection between those points and the loss of information in a black hole. It was that connection I was seeking an explanation for. "Obliteration of determinism" in one discrete portion of the universe, that has characteristics absent from all the rest of the universe, seems unlikely to extend the consequences from the black hole to everywhere else.
That could seem like an Argument from Ignorance. That was why I was asking you to remove my ignorance. So far you have been unsuccessful.
I see no connection between those points and the loss of information in a black hole. It was that connection I was seeking an explanation for. "Obliteration of determinism" in one discrete portion of the universe, that has characteristics absent from all the rest of the universe, seems unlikely to extend the consequences from the black hole to everywhere else.
That could seem like an Argument from Ignorance. That was why I was asking you to remove my ignorance. So far you have been unsuccessful.
I see no connection between those points and the loss of information in a black hole. It was that connection I was seeking an explanation for. "Obliteration of determinism" in one discrete portion of the universe, that has characteristics absent from all the rest of the universe, seems unlikely to extend the consequences from the black hole to everywhere else.
That could seem like an Argument from Ignorance. That was why I was asking you to remove my ignorance. So far you have been unsuccessful.I see no connection between those points and the loss of information in a black hole. It was that connection I was seeking an explanation for. "Obliteration of determinism" in one discrete portion of the universe, that has characteristics absent from all the rest of the universe, seems unlikely to extend the consequences from the black hole to everywhere else.
That could seem like an Argument from Ignorance. That was why I was asking you to remove my ignorance. So far you have been unsuccessful.
Hello, Ophiolite, and I appreciate your understandable answer! But what about the, "Cosmic Censorship Conjecture", proposed by Roger Penrose? In the case of a naked singularity, would the loss of information also be localized to that particular region of space, like that of a hidden singularity(black hole)? Or would an observer, or the entire universe, suffer a collapse of quantum determinism, and have catastrophic ramifications for relativity, in general? I'm obviously no Hawking, so excuse any "elementary" questions! Thanks!
You need to sort your QUOTE boxes.
