If I listen to metal, am I being a bad christian?

Tyler_W · Dec 13, 2004

Im a christian and all but:

If I listen to heavy metal (Hammerfall, DIO, etc) am I being a bad christian?

Thanks

Laia · Dec 13, 2004

honestly, i'd say first of all go with what the word of God says:

In Philippians 4:8 it says, "Summing it all up, friends, I'd say you'll do best by filling your minds and meditating on things true, noble, reputable, authentic, compelling, gracious--the best, not the worst; the beautiful, not the ugly; things to praise, not things to curse."

It doesn't matter what style of music you are listening to, what matters is the message...is it a good message? Is it pure? Praiseworthy? Would it be pleasing to God?
Those are the questions you have to ask yourself and examine your own life to determine if what you're listening to has a bad affect on your walk with God.

I don't think you're a bad Christian as long as you stay sensative with what God is trying to tell you, follow His leading in everything and you won't regret it!

Also, i don't know how many Christian metal bands you listen (if any) to but if you want any info on some let me know and i'll be happy to help.

-Laia

staugustine68 · Dec 14, 2004

Tyler_W said:
Im a christian and all but:

If I listen to heavy metal (Hammerfall, DIO, etc) am I being a bad christian?

Thanks

As a former Black metal fan, I can say it depends on what band or song you are listening to. Black metal, IMO, is horrific. Most of the bands denouce God and scream about gloom, doom and destruction (not good). Although some metal bands isn't so bad..like Dio. I can tell the difference with my mindset from the days of listening to metal, I'm not so angry now. Stay away from bands like Celtic Frost, Bathory and Cradle of Filth. I really don't listen to secular music anymore, much less metal. The closest metal band I listen to now is Blindside

holyrokker · Dec 14, 2004

Go to http://www.christianhardrock.net
http://www.disciplerocks.com
http://www.tourniquet.net
http://www.almightymetalradio.com

to get an idea of some God honoring metal. If you keep an open mind, you'll find that most of the Christian bands playing metal are better than the non-Christian bands.

LondonsBurning · Dec 14, 2004

http://www.thechariot.com
http://www.zaoonline.com
http://www.normajeannoise.com

xpunkskaterx · Dec 14, 2004

no. You can be a Christian and listen to whatever you want.

_becca · Dec 14, 2004

LondonsBurning said:
http://www.thechariot.com
http://www.zaoonline.com
http://www.normajeannoise.com

amen lol

Roo6339 · Dec 14, 2004

i listen to all types of metal, though i tend to stay away from black metal because that is outright anti-christian. i do my best at balancing my secular intake with my christian intake. i know it doesn't justify the horrid lyrics i may or may not be listening to (when you can even understand the lyrics...) but i don't feel convicted that i can't be listening to those bands. i've prayed about it many times, but i feel no guilt when i listen to most of the bands i listen to... i still make mistakes though and listen to stuff i shouldn't be listening to...

staugustine68 · Dec 14, 2004

Roo6339 said:
i listen to all types of metal, though i tend to stay away from black metal because that is outright anti-christian. i do my best at balancing my secular intake with my christian intake. i know it doesn't justify the horrid lyrics i may or may not be listening to (when you can even understand the lyrics...) but i don't feel convicted that i can't be listening to those bands. i've prayed about it many times, but i feel no guilt when i listen to most of the bands i listen to... i still make mistakes though and listen to stuff i shouldn't be listening to...

Amen brother, It shows that we are human. I, personally, felt anger within myself back in days of my headbanging years. I gotta admit, I never felt that way with Christian rock.

xpunkskaterx · Dec 15, 2004

Roo6339 said:
black metal because that is outright anti-christian

I listen to black metal and death metal. How is it "anti-Christian" Its just a genre of music.

pro_odeh · Dec 15, 2004

Music effects you more than you think! You could listen to as much metal as you would like, but I would encourage you to listen to christian metal only. Secular metal (and other music generes) often oppose the word of God, and we as christians should not listen to it! But it doesnt make you a bad christian if you do. Its just for the best of your relationship with Christ. The more you get from His word, and the less you get from the world, the closer you will grow to Him.
God bless!

Roo6339 · Dec 15, 2004

xpunkskaterx said:
I listen to black metal and death metal. How is it "anti-Christian" Its just a genre of music.

because black metal is the only genre that is specificaly against christianity. i don't just mean they sing about things that aren't christian, i mean they sing against christians. death metal deals more with... funny enough... death. of course, it's not all about death, but it's more just an angry genre of music... angry about the world, filled with hurt and sometimes senseless gore (which is really quite over the top). black metal however is filled with anger against christians and against God. they say metal is the devil's music... they should be more specific... black metal is the devil's music.

i'm not going to say you're a bad christian for listening to it. it's a personal standard i have set for myself. that's just my view on it.

xpunkskaterx · Dec 15, 2004

Roo6339 said:
because black metal is the only genre that is specificaly against christianity. i don't just mean they sing about things that aren't christian, i mean they sing against christians. death metal deals more with... funny enough... death. of course, it's not all about death, but it's more just an angry genre of music... angry about the world, filled with hurt and sometimes senseless gore (which is really quite over the top). black metal however is filled with anger against christians and against God. they say metal is the devil's music... they should be more specific... black metal is the devil's music.

i'm not going to say you're a bad christian for listening to it. it's a personal standard i have set for myself. that's just my view on it.

Im talking about Christian Black metal. So....what is it called...White Metal???

Roo6339 · Dec 15, 2004

xpunkskaterx said:
Im talking about Christian Black metal. So....what is it called...White Metal???

yeah, white metal, or unblack. i just call it Christian black... even if it is an oxymoron. but yeah, that stuff's fine... didn't realise you meant that sorry...

Sketcher · Dec 15, 2004

Kekal is a good Christian unblack metal band. Soul Embraced, Mortification, and Extol all have solid death metal releases out. I listen to the Christian hard stuff myself, and generally stay away from secular. However, I do listen to some secular hard music, just not their anti-Christian songs. I filter out a lot of otherwise good songs

mnmcandiez · Dec 15, 2004

Why not just call it black metal?

staugustine68 · Dec 16, 2004

xpunkskaterx said:
I listen to black metal and death metal. How is it "anti-Christian" Its just a genre of music.

Let's forget the fact that it's "anti-Chritian" for a second, but someone said this for me to think about a few years ago.."Either it's of the Lord, or it isn't. There is no middle". Make sense to me......

xpunkskaterx · Dec 16, 2004

staugustine68 said:
Let's forget the fact that it's "anti-Chritian" for a second, but someone said this for me to think about a few years ago.."Either it's of the Lord, or it isn't. There is no middle". Make sense to me......

well God made music, and all genres of music. So the genre itself is Gods, but the lyrics arent.

Sketcher · Dec 16, 2004

staugustine68 said:
Let's forget the fact that it's "anti-Chritian" for a second, but someone said this for me to think about a few years ago.."Either it's of the Lord, or it isn't. There is no middle". Make sense to me......

Study the lyrics of these Christian metal bands, and there is no doubt that they are for the Lord.

staugustine68 · Dec 16, 2004

twistedsketch said:
Study the lyrics of these Christian metal bands, and there is no doubt that they are for the Lord.

No doubt that Christian metal bands are for the Lord.
I was referring to Black Metal bands that denouce God.

If I listen to metal, am I being a bad christian?

New Member

Roadie

Greyhounds as pets

Contributor

You Have to Answer to the Guns of Brixton

Go Leafs Go

Senior Member

Maynard Fan

Greyhounds as pets

Go Leafs Go

-=Disciple of Jesus Christ=-

Maynard Fan

Go Leafs Go

Maynard Fan

Born Imperishable

Veteran

Greyhounds as pets

Go Leafs Go

Born Imperishable

Greyhounds as pets

Similar threads

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency