Davebuck said:
This is circular reasoning. "Yahweh hasn't smited the devil (or other evil folks) because he his perfect. Yahweh is perfect therefore he doesn't smite the devil or other evil folks." It doesn't explain anything!
no. you are not taking my meaning. not what i am trying to say. what i am trying to say is that GOd is perfect, that's why he has high standards. and what i am saying is that one little thing we do must be huge to him since he never sins! so no, i'm not saying that he's perfect so he doesn't smite, but that every sin before GOd is tremendous.
Davebuck said:
And, this devil fellow supposedly isn't some joe-schmoe that has impure thoughts once and a while. We're not saying it's surprising why Yahweh doesn't kill every human. But, given his track record... So, it's reasonable to wonder the logic behind Yahweh previous actions of drowning babies or killing all kinds of folks in his various wrathful stages but continues to let this devil guy hurt everyone.
dude. GOd does things for purposes. he's uncomprehensible, thus, you'd never understand Him and as somewhere in the BIble states, "My ways and thoughts are too lofty for you to obtain.' You'll never understand why. It also seemss crazy that God takes people away so suddenly. i mean, a mom dies of cancer, a family dies in a car crash, a brother commits suicide, a volcano plummets down a mountain, etc. You never really know why GOd takes people away at the times that He does, but trust me, he has a purpose on this earth, under or over this earth, to fulfill by that. so keeping the devil around must have a purpose, but we'll never understand it i guess, because GOd is so above us.
Davebuck said:
What you say must be false. If an omnipotent god didn't want something to happen (e.g., folks to go to hell) he could get rid of hell.
May I quote C.S.Lewis:
'...He is a strange GOd, you will say... how can anything happen contrary to His will?
...anyone who has been in authority knows how a thing can be in accoradance with your will in one way and not in another. It may be quite sensible for a mother to say to the children, 'I'm not going to go and make you tidy the schoolroom every night. You've go to learn to keep it tidy on your own.' Then she goes up one night and finds the Teddy bear and the ink and the French Grammer all lying in the gate. That is against her will. She would prefer the children to be tidy. But on the other hand, it is her will which has left the children free to be untidy. The same thing arises in a regiment, or trade union, or school. You make a thing voluntary and then half the people do not do it. That is not what you willed, but your will has made it possible.
'It is probaly the same in the universe. God created things which had a free will. That means creatures which can go either wrong or right. Some people think they can imagine a creature which was free but had no possibility of going wrong; I cannot. If a thing is free to be good, it is also free to be bad....'
so every time some person evil pops up- kill him! ... totally not radical.
y'know, some good rises out of every situation. good came out of the holocaust, persecution, etc. You know, Christians have been and are persecuted cruelly in some countries- does God kill all the persecuters? NO, because good came out of it. Strengthened Christian leaders, great missionaries, inspired Christians, converted Roman soldiers, converted Muslim captors, etc. I mean, living in the Roman days, no one could ever see what good could come out of burning Christians at the stake, sawing in half, tearing apart by lions, etc come to be of God's will. But it was. However crazy it may seem man, it was.
Something good comes out of everything, however long it takes. take a look at the way groovy butterfly. a catterpillar seems to disappear and never come out of a cocoon. but lo and behold, soon enough, a beautiful butterfly pops out. it seemed to have been the butterfly's death in that nasty cocoon, but when it emerges out, what happens- something good. wonderful, is it not?
And take the story of Joseph in the BIble. Joseph was traded off by his mean brothers to some slave traders. God's nice little boy- how could this happen? How come God didn't smite the brothers? Perhaps soon enough, Joseph moved on and grew up to serve God and save all of Egypt and the latter parts from utter death of starvation. So that's why Joseph's apparent good-for-nothing-evil brothers were not smitted (smitten?).
the more powerful the being, the higher the potential for the person to be good- or bad. sure there have been HItlers and Stalins in this world, but there have also been Martin Luther King Jrs and Mother Teresas. I can't seem to see how you can have the lattter without having the former. If you have the potential to oppress and slay millions, you also have the potential to liberate and love millions. so it was with Satan.
So something good does come out of Satan- us seeing how much we really need God. et cetera.
Davebuck said:
But, according to you, not only does he not get rid of this hell thing, he makes it so the only way to avoid it is to believe that his son is his son. Again, that's messed up! Instead of believing that this Jesus guy is a god, how about making the rule this: you avoid hell if you are good person. Still not much of a "choice" either way. It's like hitler saying to a Jew, OK, you can stop believing in your religion or you go to the gas chambers and so do your kids.
Believing in Jesus as the Son of God is like an admission slip, a key, a ticket, etc to heaven. Heaven is amazing. You know how expensive it would be in worldy dollars? Everything in the world would never amount to any admission to heaven. but in order to get in, you have to pay the fare. Because of our sins, we've lost our ticket. We've been so ignorant, careless, sinful, etc that we have lost our admission. Jesus is offering you a second chance- for free. Jesus is saying, the only way to get to the Father is through me. So come through me. I'll give you a ticket. Just ACCEPT IT. Accept the ticket. That's all you have to do.
and about HItler. it's got nothing to do with this situation.
that's because Hitler's ideas were wrong in saying that. He was telling no truths. God was, is and always will tell the truth. God has the best in mind for you. He loves you. Whereas Hitler wasn't.
Davebuck said:
Instead of believing that this Jesus guy is a god, how about making the rule this: you avoid hell if you are good person.
in addition to what was said above,
may i quote from a book:
'Morality can keep you out of jail, but only Jesus's blood can keep you out of hell.'
just because you are a good person, doesn't mean you are heaven-bound.
Davebuck said:
HITLER SHOULDN'T HAVE HAD GAS CHAMBERS!!!
well then. Ask God. I don't know. For the moment anyways.
Davebuck said:
So, it's still a very good question of why this so called Yahweh would not stop this devil guy from hurting people and why he doesn't do away with hell. Is all the suffering that this devil causes just to teach him a lesson? That's also not very nice to use people's lives as means to an end.
Not just to teach the devil a lesson. God can use all things for good. God can use the devil's temptations to bring you closer to Him. God can use the things that the devil does to bring a sinner into a situation in which he finally repents his sins. God can use someone elses sins to get something good out of it all.
Davebuck said:
No matter how you look at it, the whole business about the devil and hell and Yahweh's decisions for how he set up these rules you believe are just unethical.
well you're wrong.
