yeah that's what my DH said... hence why I never watched after Rose left, 'cept one... the one where they meet Shakespeare, I think only 'cuz it happened to be on TV right before something else I wanted to watch and I was curious about Martha.
I know a number of people who found Martha to be their favourite Companion. Smart, assertive, and in a
great opening episode with the Judoon on the Moon!
Now, I loved the intensity of BSG, which I've seen all the way through twice. LOVED IT! I loved the writing, the characters, the pain, the post-9/11 influences on the script (trauma & suicidal thoughts so different to the 'cowboys in space' version of Battlestar in the 70's and 80's). As a Christian I loved the weird fusion of Sci-Fi and a sense of Exodus, as if the whole thing were a pilgrimage engineered by a (comparatively remote and removed) 'higher power'. I just enjoyed that as a back-story for some reason, even though our God is far more intimate and personal.
Then after BSG I started watching Firefly and wondered what all the fuss was about. I think I was at episode 3 and still wondering. Then by half way through it clicked: this show was just plain FUN! It still had great character writing like BSG, but wasn't about epic and important events like a whole civilisation on the run. The Firefly was the ship no body cared about. It was the opposite. It's the little cargo freighter the Enterprise would just zoom past in the infinite night of space! By the end of the movie Serenity, I was mourning the end of the series: seriously in a state of shock that it was all over!
Now, my guilty viewing pleasure is... well, not really pleasure but mostly pain and endurance. It's The Walking Dead. It's confronting and horrible, but I watch it with a non-Christian mate and it's leading into all sorts of interesting chats on a Friday night after work. But it haunts me all night long. I dream about it. I had a few years in the army straight after high school, and the one thing I keep re-dreaming, over and over again, are constant scenes of calculating how many men I had in my platoon as I faced the hoards of undead. Nasty. Not my favourite: even though it has great character writing and follows a theme I'm interested in: what happens after the end of civilisation?