• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

  • CF has always been a site that welcomes people from different backgrounds and beliefs to participate in discussion and even debate. That is the nature of its ministry. In view of recent events emotions are running very high. We need to remind people of some basic principles in debating on this site. We need to be civil when we express differences in opinion. No personal attacks. Avoid you, your statements. Don't characterize an entire political party with comparisons to Fascism or Communism or other extreme movements that committed atrocities. CF is not the place for broad brush or blanket statements about groups and political parties. Put the broad brushes and blankets away when you come to CF, better yet, put them in the incinerator. Debate had no place for them. We need to remember that people that commit acts of violence represent themselves or a small extreme faction.
  • We hope the site problems here are now solved, however, if you still have any issues, please start a ticket in Contact Us

Status
Not open for further replies.

Funny Fundie

Active Member
Oct 30, 2008
197
10
✟383.00
Faith
Baptist
Marital Status
In Relationship
So, you're a christian. There you are. Saved, doing the right thing, and basically ready to go whenever.:holy:

You get to heaven, so does much of your family. However, many many many of your friends, acquaintances, and even some of your family did not make it to heaven.

It's ok though, they got what was coming to them. :preach:

You're safe in heaven; spending every moment of consciousness glorifying the god that allowed you to be there. :bow:

You get to spend eternity there, with the full knowledge that so many people, many whom you have loved are being tortured and in constant agony for all eternity... and there is nothing you can do about it.

Sounds like a great place.:sorry:

Dude you've been totally totally watching like waaaaaaaaaaaay too many hollywood films.
 
Upvote 0

truthshift

Bring it on
Nov 6, 2008
244
23
Phoenix
✟30,490.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Private
and here we have another person who is prideful enough to think he understands the things of God and his plan, and who thinks his mind even has the capacity to understand an eternal omnipresent God, let alone his justice and mercy.

And here we have another person who is prideful enough to think he/she can and will live forever. They think that they are part of a gods plan.

I never claimed to understand what "god" is trying to do. I'm making and inference as to what heaven would be like based on what is written in the bible. You're twisting my words out of context and it's a little ridiculous. How about you give your thoughts on what heaven might be like and give me your rationalization as to why you're ok with forgetting your loved ones in hell or ok with knowing they are there for eternity in suffering or some other possiblity.

I think that would be a lot more insightful than attempting to slander me because I clearly made you upset. You can't say you're not. People don't belittle others in a practical discussion.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0

truthshift

Bring it on
Nov 6, 2008
244
23
Phoenix
✟30,490.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Private
But, I think we become one with God, and become love - all of us.

I think that would be a novel idea. Thats actually exactly how I felt how heaven might be when I was a christian but the bible says that we will worship god in heaven and god will be on his throne.

That hints at a context where beings in heaven would be separate from god and I can't imagine a point to worshiping ones self for eternity. I actually can't imagine a point in having a bunch of people worship a being for eternity either but, that's besides the point.

Even if it were the case that all would become one with god, people would have to forget the people in hell or remain with the full knowledge that they are there.
 
Upvote 0

corvus_corax

Naclist Hierophant and Prophet
Jan 19, 2005
5,588
333
Oregon
✟29,911.00
Faith
Seeker
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Others
What movies? I'm not referencing anything.
FF is most likely wrong regarding movies
But you are wrong as well
You ARE referencing something
To wit-
The common acceptance of what Heaven "is"
And, many many many Christians disagree with that POV (Im including certain Evangelical Fundametalists in that regard)
 
Upvote 0

truthshift

Bring it on
Nov 6, 2008
244
23
Phoenix
✟30,490.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Private
FF is most likely wrong regarding movies
But you are wrong as well
You ARE referencing something
To wit-
The common acceptance of what Heaven "is"
And, many many many Christians disagree with that POV (Im including certain Evangelical Fundametalists in that regard)

Can you go further into detail please? I haven't made any comments on what heaven is. I've made the assumption that it is a place and I may be wrong but that seems to be the common belief.

Beyond that I haven't made any more mention of it. I'm merely commenting on something that would have to happen for anyone who enters heaven. You have to either remember people or forget them. There is no third option for the mind.

If it is indeed the case that we remember them but lose our understanding of pain and sadness then can we say we have free will, let alone claim to be an entirely conscious being in heaven? Even in that case, to be ok with that now is to be ok with people you did not save burning in hell.

It all seems illogical to me.
 
Upvote 0

corvus_corax

Naclist Hierophant and Prophet
Jan 19, 2005
5,588
333
Oregon
✟29,911.00
Faith
Seeker
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Others
Can you go further into detail please?
Sure thing
I haven't made any comments on what heaven is.
Actually, yes you have, in regard to a "state of mind" or perception
And that's okay
I've made the assumption that it is a place and I may be wrong but that seems to be the common belief.
"Seems" to be, yes
But there was a thread on CF a couple of years ago about what or where heaven is (in regard to the place that "the saved" go to) and there was little, if any consensus among christians about what Heaven is, where it is, what it means, etc.

Beyond that I haven't made any more mention of it. I'm merely commenting on something that would have to happen for anyone who enters heaven.] You have to either remember people or forget them. There is no third option for the mind.
Depending on one's interpretation of scripture.
And that IS what it comes down to.
Not what scripture may or may not say...but one's interpretation.


If it is indeed the case that we remember them but lose our understanding of pain and sadness then can we say we have free will, let alone claim to be an entirely conscious being in heaven? Even in that case, to be ok with that now is to be ok with people you did not save burning in hell.

It all seems illogical to me.
Trust me TS, it all seems illogical to me as well (and not just the concept that you have put forth of heaven)
 
Upvote 0

Beanieboy

Senior Veteran
Jan 20, 2006
6,297
1,214
62
✟65,132.00
Faith
Christian
I think that would be a novel idea. Thats actually exactly how I felt how heaven might be when I was a christian but the bible says that we will worship god in heaven and god will be on his throne.

That hints at a context where beings in heaven would be separate from god and I can't imagine a point to worshiping ones self for eternity. I actually can't imagine a point in having a bunch of people worship a being for eternity either but, that's besides the point.

Even if it were the case that all would become one with god, people would have to forget the people in hell or remain with the full knowledge that they are there.

I know. That is where I would have been burned at the stake for believing what I do now (and probably was back then.)

When Jesus walked the Earth, he came as a servant. He washed the feet of man, and in return, the prostitute washed his feet with her tears and dried them with her hair, showing the love that was shown to her. He didn't sit on a throne saying "adore me." Christ also said that as much as one has done to the least, so have they done to Christ.

At the time of the Bible, the idea of royalty, royal blood, Kings and Thrones were common. Today they are not. I think it was described as best as people could understand, but similar to Kungfu Panda, where everyone kneeled in honor, in thankfulness, rather than KP demanding it, so it shall probably be. However, the bible talks of "streets of gold." If there is no monetary system, then the gold will be as worthless as rubble. If we don't have bodies, then there is no need for mansions, no need for protection from the elements. There are times when I have heard people singing in tongues, and heard a chord of harmony, and for that split second, that beautiful chord seemed to be how I imagine God - like something that is all things at once, that ebs and flows in light, that is peace, that is timeless.

I can't really put it into words, but I think it will be nothing like Earth, far less limiting.
 
Upvote 0

truthshift

Bring it on
Nov 6, 2008
244
23
Phoenix
✟30,490.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Private
I know. That is where I would have been burned at the stake for believing what I do now (and probably was back then.)

When Jesus walked the Earth, he came as a servant. He washed the feet of man, and in return, the prostitute washed his feet with her tears and dried them with her hair, showing the love that was shown to her. He didn't sit on a throne saying "adore me." Christ also said that as much as one has done to the least, so have they done to Christ.

At the time of the Bible, the idea of royalty, royal blood, Kings and Thrones were common. Today they are not. I think it was described as best as people could understand, but similar to Kungfu Panda, where everyone kneeled in honor, in thankfulness, rather than KP demanding it, so it shall probably be. However, the bible talks of "streets of gold." If there is no monetary system, then the gold will be as worthless as rubble. If we don't have bodies, then there is no need for mansions, no need for protection from the elements. There are times when I have heard people singing in tongues, and heard a chord of harmony, and for that split second, that beautiful chord seemed to be how I imagine God - like something that is all things at once, that ebs and flows in light, that is peace, that is timeless.

I can't really put it into words, but I think it will be nothing like Earth, far less limiting.

No one can blame you for being unable to express an abstract idea fully. Language is just a system of symbols we use to represent everything from "tree" to "love" it's imperfect and crude and many things can only be expressed through a combination of actions, words, ect. It's why we turn to music and the like to express deep emotions.

I think that the idea of an infinite life in a 'heaven' of any sort would be fantastic, but we have to be honest to ourselves about the potential that there really is nothing there but our imaginations. Humans have great mental potential and I think that's why religion is so powerful. We're capable of grasping abstract ideas and we embrace the hype of it all very easily but we forget to follow through with our own thoughts.

It's much like when people buy a car. I sold cars for a while when I was paying for school. It's a psychological game that is played with peoples minds. You build this great image of yourself and the product you sell. Get them emotionally involved in it, make them love it, and want to own it all costs and then when they ''just cant afford not to buy it'' present the numbers and show them the reality of owning what they want.

At that point, people will negotiate a little bit but will still pay more than they intended to own the car they want because they are sold on it already. If they took all the information into account from the get-go they could make a more pragmatic decision with all the facts instead of deciding on their emotions. They would fight for the price they want more because they have a better idea of its worth.

I feel that religion is the same way. The major world religions a.k.a. the "desert dogmas" offer fantastic rewards for subscribing to their ideals. They offer an eternity in heaven with various different rewards depending on which "car" you choose. People get an information overload at the start, they think of all these great things that will happen for them and their friends and they want to share it with everyone they know. It seems like the best thing that could ever happen but again they're making the decision to love it based on what information is given at the start. By the time that theoretical questions are raised about it's legitimacy they love it too much and have put too much time into it to accept that it may have been a bad choice. So people will rationalize for it and make excuses for it in an effort to hold on to those rewards.

I mean when you look at the way religions came about and how they appeal to the masses, you begin to recognize some common trends across all of them. They're selling the same thing, a way to ease the fear of death. Religions began appearing in societies across the globe at about the time that the first sciences appeared and at about the same time that the first philosophers began walking the earth(with the exception of the egyptians).

It was a time when people began to explore their world and question existence. It's oddly coincidental that religion appears at that time and answers these questions and eases these fears and objections.

I guess that my whole point is that religions all offer these great things but, I mean:

"10
He took me in spirit to a great, high mountain and showed me the holy city Jerusalem coming down out of heaven from God.
11
It gleamed with the splendor of God. Its radiance was like that of a precious stone, like jasper, clear as crystal.
12
It had a massive, high wall, with twelve gates where twelve angels were stationed and on which names were inscribed, (the names) of the twelve tribes of the Israelites.
13
There were three gates facing east, three north, three south, and three west.
14
The wall of the city had twelve courses of stones as its foundation, on which were inscribed the twelve names of the twelve apostles 11 of the Lamb.
15
12 The one who spoke to me held a gold measuring rod to measure the city, its gates, and its wall.
16
The city was square, its length the same as (also) its width. He measured the city with the rod and found it fifteen hundred miles 13 in length and width and height.
17
He also measured its wall: one hundred and forty-four cubits 14 according to the standard unit of measurement the angel used.
18
15 The wall was constructed of jasper, while the city was pure gold, clear as glass.
19
The foundations of the city wall were decorated with every precious stone; the first course of stones was jasper, the second sapphire, the third chalcedony, the fourth emerald,
20
the fifth sardonyx, the sixth carnelian, the seventh chrysolite, the eighth beryl, the ninth topaz, the tenth chrysoprase, the eleventh hyacinth, and the twelfth amethyst.
21
The twelve gates were twelve pearls, each of the gates made from a single pearl; and the street of the city was of pure gold, transparent as glass.
22
16 I saw no temple in the city, for its temple is the Lord God almighty and the Lamb.
23
17 The city had no need of sun or moon to shine on it, for the glory of God gave it light, and its lamp was the Lamb.
24
The nations will walk by its light, 18 and to it the kings of the earth will bring their treasure.
25
During the day its gates will never be shut, and there will be no night there.
26
The treasure and wealth of the nations will be brought there,
27
but nothing unclean will enter it, nor any (one) who does abominable things or tells lies. Only those will enter whose names are written in the Lamb's book of life."


all this description of material wealth in heaven seems to go against the philosophy of money having no value in the eyes of christ. Why does god need gold and gems in heaven? If I lived in ancient times and someone told me that this is what heaven is like, why would I not sign up?

The rewards and punishments in the bible seem to strangely coincide with what a man living in those times would desire:

wealth in gold and gems

no same-sex sex

[SIZE=-1]
"Women should be silent in the churches, for they are not permitted to speak, but should be submissive, as the law also says."
[/SIZE]
[SIZE=-1](1 Corinthians 14:34)[/SIZE]
[SIZE=-1]
[/SIZE]

[SIZE=-1]"Slaves, obey your human masters with fear and trembling, in the sincerity of your heart, as to Christ."[/SIZE] [SIZE=-1](Ephesians 6:5)[/SIZE]

[SIZE=-1]"Slaves are to be submissive to their masters in everything, and to be well-pleasing, not talking back ."[/SIZE] [SIZE=-1](Titus 2:9)[/SIZE]


[SIZE=-1]--------------[/SIZE]


The Qur'an and Islam is just as ridiculous in its beliefs, rewards, taboos, and punishments. I can understand how people can initially overlook the contradictions and the ridiculous expectations of religion but how people continue to rationalize it upon its discovery is beyond me.


[SIZE=-1]My whole point is that heaven is described as this grand place that contradicts much of Christianities own ideals and that even in heaven, you must recognize that there are those that do not enter and you must either forget them or be there for eternity separated from them with no way to get them.[/SIZE]


[SIZE=-1]Beyond the OP of this thread, the actual motive was to get people to start examining their beliefs. At what point will we grow up and drop our prejudices, fears, and superstitions? We willingly choose to not understand, not tolerate, and not think because of a text that was supposedly written by a god that appears to tailor to greedy chauvinists.[/SIZE]


[SIZE=-1]I will say that the bible holds some good moral truths in it though. We all recognize that it's bad to murder and steal and such but did we really need the bible to tell us that?[/SIZE]


[SIZE=-1]And as I have said before; I do not know what is right but I know what is wrong. There may be a god but its not /that/ god. There may be a heaven but it's not /that/ heaven. At least I would hope not. Streets of gold seem kind of tacky to me.
[/SIZE]

[SIZE=-1]
[/SIZE]

[SIZE=-1]One can't find the truth if they've already found it.[/SIZE]


[SIZE=-1]Edit: sorry for the long post
[/SIZE]
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0

nesian

Dance 'til you're dead
Aug 1, 2008
1,624
28
New Zealand
✟24,416.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
So, you're a christian. There you are. Saved, doing the right thing, and basically ready to go whenever.:holy:

You get to heaven, so does much of your family. However, many many many of your friends, acquaintances, and even some of your family did not make it to heaven.

It's ok though, they got what was coming to them. :preach:

You're safe in heaven; spending every moment of consciousness glorifying the god that allowed you to be there. :bow:

You get to spend eternity there, with the full knowledge that so many people, many whom you have loved are being tortured and in constant agony for all eternity... and there is nothing you can do about it.

Sounds like a great place.:sorry:

It's why many are called, but few are chosen.
 
Upvote 0

chingchang

Newbie
Jul 17, 2008
2,038
101
New Braunfels, Texas
✟25,259.00
Faith
Christian Seeker
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Libertarian
TS,

I'd like to take a stab at this...my comments below...

So, you're a christian. There you are. Saved, doing the right thing, and basically ready to go whenever.:holy:

You get to heaven, so does much of your family. However, many many many of your friends, acquaintances, and even some of your family did not make it to heaven.

Yeah...that is basically what the Bible says. Many are on the path that leads to destruction.

It's ok though, they got what was coming to them. :preach:

Hmmm...sad that Christians would feel that way.

You're safe in heaven; spending every moment of consciousness glorifying the god that allowed you to be there. :bow:

You get to spend eternity there, with the full knowledge that so many people, many whom you have loved are being tortured and in constant agony for all eternity... and there is nothing you can do about it.

A couple things. One...you don't know we'll be conscious of the fact that people went into destruction. Two...you don't know that people are going to be "tortured and in constant agony for all eternity". There is plenty of debate as to the nature of hell. As one who use to hold the "traditional view" of hell...I can tell you that there is more evidence IMHO that hell is a place where people will ultimately be destroyed.

Sounds like a great place.:sorry:

The place you described doesn't "sound" like that great of a place...but where would you rather be? I would suggest that your scenario will not be reality...but is the opinion of people that have generally accepted teachings from a biased and flawed theology.

All IMHO,
chingchang
 
Upvote 0

truthshift

Bring it on
Nov 6, 2008
244
23
Phoenix
✟30,490.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Private
TS,

I'd like to take a stab at this...my comments below...

Yeah...that is basically what the Bible says. Many are on the path that leads to destruction.

Hmmm...sad that Christians would feel that way.

A couple things. One...you don't know we'll be conscious of the fact that people went into destruction. Two...you don't know that people are going to be "tortured and in constant agony for all eternity". There is plenty of debate as to the nature of hell. As one who use to hold the "traditional view" of hell...I can tell you that there is more evidence IMHO that hell is a place where people will ultimately be destroyed.

The place you described doesn't "sound" like that great of a place...but where would you rather be? I would suggest that your scenario will not be reality...but is the opinion of people that have generally accepted teachings from a biased and flawed theology.

All IMHO,
chingchang


I maintain my motive behind the OP regardless of what description of heaven we use.
 
Upvote 0

Beanieboy

Senior Veteran
Jan 20, 2006
6,297
1,214
62
✟65,132.00
Faith
Christian
When I read How To Quit Religion without Quitting God, Zender argued that either Jesus died for the sins of the world, or he didn't. Either, all are now saved through the sacrifice, or no one is.

Once I realized that that might be true, that Christ dying saved the whole world, it was the first time I ever thought of the Gospel as Good News. And as the understanding came to me, my mind was filled with the image of millions of presents raining down on God, a Yes moment of clarity, and I was overjoyed.

I believe this true.
 
Upvote 0

truthshift

Bring it on
Nov 6, 2008
244
23
Phoenix
✟30,490.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Private
When I read How To Quit Religion without Quitting God, Zender argued that either Jesus died for the sins of the world, or he didn't. Either, all are now saved through the sacrifice, or no one is.

Once I realized that that might be true, that Christ dying saved the whole world, it was the first time I ever thought of the Gospel as Good News. And as the understanding came to me, my mind was filled with the image of millions of presents raining down on God, a Yes moment of clarity, and I was overjoyed.

I believe this true.

I don't think that I quite follow you on this one. I may be interpreting it wrong. The bible gives stipulations to being saved. You must accept jesus into your heart and have faith in god. How can all or none be saved?
 
Upvote 0

truthshift

Bring it on
Nov 6, 2008
244
23
Phoenix
✟30,490.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Private
These people are like the old saying, you can drag a horse to water ,but you can't make them drink.God isn't going to drag you to heaven against your free will, so hell is the total affirmation to your free will.

But, at the same time when all knowledge is gifted by god and god knows everything before it will happen and everything is part of a greater scheme, how can there be any free will? It's contradictory.
 
Upvote 0

jcook922

Defender of Liberty, against the Left or Right.
Aug 5, 2008
1,427
129
United States
✟24,746.00
Faith
Humanist
Marital Status
In Relationship
Politics
US-Libertarian
I've thought about this too. It's a good question-a difficult one too.

I'm not sure if in Heaven we will have "brothers", "sisters", "husbands", "wives" etc. I think there will be just one great big body of people, all perfectly and equally interelated to one another. Everyone will be "friends", nobody will be a bloodline of someone else. Even Jesus said that there will be no marriage in Heaven.

The Bible also says that the memories of former things will be wiped away. You won't miss a friend or family member because those memories will be gone, and everyone else will be a perfect spiritual family in eternity.

I'm not a theologian, but that's my understanding of it.

What would a Christian perspective be if I were to say I didn't want that because it sounds like my version of hell? I thought the point of Heaven was to continue to exist? If you don't have your memories you can't appreciate that you still exist after death.
 
Upvote 0

Verv

Senior Veteran
Apr 17, 2005
7,278
673
Gyeonggido
✟48,571.00
Country
Korea, Republic Of
Gender
Male
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
It's hardly dishonest. I assume that you're an intelligent person and you must face yourself with this question. What we understand of heaven comes from the same place that you get your understanding of heaven.

It's merely speculation as to what it is like based on what we know. You honestly have to ask yourself if you're ok with having all knowledge of friends and family wiped from memory, which would mean you don't really care about them now. Or if you're ok with them suffering for eternity while you are in heaven for eternity with no ability to do anything, which could potentially make you a sadist.

There is no twist on what heaven is. I never described what heaven would be like in regards of sensory information or went into detail about what kind of activities would take place there. I went from what I read in the bible. The same bible that everyone reads.

Regardless of what it's like; the reality of those two understandings of heaven/hell is still there.

They will be in hell for eternity.
You will be in heaven for eternity.
It will not change, ever.
Do you not care for them now?
or will heaven be a sad place?

You do know that there are interpretations where hell is not eternal, correct? There are some references in the New Testament to people having their soul destroyed in the lake of fire, their existence being wiped out.

The Bible is too vague for me to go into detail about all this.

And yes, I am OK if some of my friends and family end up in hell. It is exactly where they sent themselves.

God even told us that now is a time to have a new sort of family:

Luke 8:21
He replied, "My mother and brothers are those who hear God's word and put it into practice."

Families get divided.

Yes, same here, when people talk about heaven and hell I get the distinct impression they are making it up as they go along, whilst simultaneously making themselves sound completely and utterly absurd, as seen in this thread *winks@BlackSabb*

I don't think, however, there is anything wrong with atheists pointing out that these common interpretations do sound absurd.

Credit to you though, jmverville, for avoiding giving your own interpretation and more or less saying we can't know, I think I think I'd do exactly the same in your shoes. ;)

Fair response here. Appreciated.
 
Upvote 0

Spherical Time

Reality has a well known Liberal bias.
Apr 20, 2005
2,375
227
43
New York City
Visit site
✟26,273.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Single
Politics
UK-Liberal-Democrats
And, many many many Christians disagree with that POV (Im including certain Evangelical Fundametalists in that regard)
There's a clear representation of what many evangelical fundies believe is heaven in the "Left Behind" series of books.

To most atheists, what is contained in that representation is still quite horrifying.
 
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.