One of the great Christian contributions to Western Civilization is the idea that even bad people are entitled to respect and decent treatment, since all people, even the very worst, are created in the image of God. America doesn't (officially, anyway) torture prisoners or mistreat prisoners of war. And it is an established principle of American law that an accused person's past conduct that is not directly related to the case is not admissible as evidence by the prosecution.
And, just for good measure, odds are that George Floyd was passing a bad bill without knowing that it was bad. Happens all the time in convenience stores. When the customer expresses surprise, it is usually genuine. The actual counterfeiter is several steps back in the past.
So what you're arguing here is that we Americans ought to go back to the good 'ol uncivilized way that things were done before those wimpy Christians spread their weak, loser philosophy everywhere.
*