Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
again, I notice you didn't answer the question.billmcelligott said:Philip no dodge
billmcelligott said:Repeat of previous post, With regard to morman Church.
Masonry can no more stop people from going off and starting a new Society, than a Church can stop a member of the congregation starting a new Church.
Its a personal choice and I would not wish to stop that choice.
Apparently I am not alowed to leave links in to take you to the source material.
I am not knowledgeable about the 'left behind series', so I am sorry I am unable to comment on that other than I had never heard of it . Which is an answer in itself. There is no connection.
You say Mormon as if it were a dirty word. There is no connection between Masonry and the Mormon Church. It was founded I believe by a Mason, probably as he was not encouraged to create an new religion within the Craft. I do not wish to get involved with any detriment to any Christian Church.
A Falsehood is a contrived thing. I am not saying there is nothing within the Masonic ritual to which an eyebrow could not be raised. But first you should show Masonry to be an alternative doctrine , an opposing force.Tribe said:billmcelligott, you are not talking to someone who has gotten his information third- or fourth-hand.
OK , niehter have I. I am a Past Master in Craft and Chapter I am UK which means UGLE.
1.) The oath includes several penalties, one of which entails having one's throat cut ear-to-ear for revealing secret information. Whether it is said to be symbolic or no, the threat is included.
Well it does matter if it is symbolic and as I said it refers to oaths taken during the 18th Century, when it was an actual oath as you described. There has never been a recorded incident of this oath being carried out.
2.) Candidates for initiation are required to believe in only ONE god. During the interview process, the candidate is allowed to explain what they consider to be "one" god. Such as the aforementioned Pagan Freemasons who explained that they considered all of their gods and goddesses to be facets of one supreme Deity.
To continue to insist that this questioning does not take place is disingenuous at best, and false at worst.
I can only speak for UK . The question and I have asked it many times is as I have already reported. " Do you believe in a Supreme Being".
Albert Pike had quite a few things to say which you don't quote - about Adonai, about the Bible, about the equality of religions, etc. About how only the vulgar man believes that the Bible is literally true, etc.
Agreed, my point was just as I have done one should not just pull out a few quotes that suite your argument. Pike was a prolific writer and quite often changed his mind and contradicted himself. You are quite right we should not use just a few sentances.
Say what you will; I leave it to good Christian men to pray and search scripture so that falsehoods may not mislead them.
how about these quotes from Pike?billmcelligott said:Morals and Dogma page 597 For ever, In all the nations, ascending to the remotest antiquity we find, seated above all gods a still higher Deity, silent, undefined, incomprehensible, the Supreme, one God, from Whom all the rest flow or emanate, or by Him are created. Morals and Dogma page 134 Speak kindly to your erring brother! God pities him; Christ has died for him; Providence waits for him; Heavens mercy yearns toward him; and Heavens spirits are ready to welcome him back with joy. Morals and Dogma page 14
Masonry does not pretend to be a religion; but it is not irreligious or irreverent. It does not assume to take the place of any religion, or claim to make religion unnecessary. To charge it with this is to libel it. It requires its initiates to believe in one God and a Divine Providence, and that the soul survives the dissolution of the body. Thus it teaches those great primary truths on which all religion must repose; and it inculcates those principles of pure morality which have commended themselves to the good and wise of all ages."
It never hurts for a mason to research deism to find out more about the masonic faith system.billmcelligott said:A Falsehood is a contrived thing. I am not saying there is nothing within the Masonic ritual to which an eyebrow could not be raised. But first you should show Masonry to be an alternative doctrine , an opposing force.
do you think that is in any way related to the fact as you point out - that they love it?We who love the Craft see it as a support sytem to the faith adopted by the individual. It is not our place to force any belief system on anyone.
Plan 9, you're a member of the Order of the Eastern Star? Can you tell us why your organization chose as its symbol an inverted pentagram?Plan 9 said:I'm an American member of OES and I was asked this question. As a Christian, I could honestly answer it in the affirmative, did so, and was not asked to elaborate further regarding my religious beliefs.
geocajun said:how about these quotes from Pike?
[font=trebuchet ms, arial, helvetica]I posted the Morals and dogma quotes against the quotes you have listed ( by a previous poster) to create a balance. I have no wish to instruct anyone . But Pike was a prolific writer and often contradicted himself. We therefore see that he as you have indicated did not keep to one line of thought.[/font]
[font=trebuchet ms, arial, helvetica]In his Encyclopedia of Freemasonry, Albert G. Mackey writes:
Who can deny that it is eminently a religious institution?...But the religion of Masonry is not sectarian...It is not Judaism, though there is nothing in it to offend a Jew; it is not Christianity, but there is nothing in it repugnant to the faith of a Christian. Its religion is that general one of nature and primitive revelationhanded down to us from some ancient and patriarchal priesthoodin which all men may agree and in which no men can differ. It inculcates the practice of virtue, but supplies no scheme of redemption for sin...Masonry, then, is indeed a religious institution; and on this ground mainly, if not alone, should the religious Mason defend it" (pp. 617-619[/font]
So we see we can agree or we not differ,
I will accept "Its religion is that general one of nature and primitive revelation "
"but there is nothing in it repugnant to the faith of a Christian".
[font=trebuchet ms, arial, helvetica]Hannah posed the basic dilemma of the Masonic oaths when he wrote: [/font]
[font=trebuchet ms, arial, helvetica]"Either the oaths mean what they say or they do not. If they do mean what they say, then the candidate is entering into a pact consenting to his own murder by barbarous torture and mutilation should he break it. If they do not mean what they say, then he is swearing high-sounding schoolboy nonsense on the Bible, which verges on blasphemy" (Darkness Visible, p. 21).All of these quotes are from a masterful document written within the Catholic Church regarding Freemasonry and can be read here: http://www.john654.org/bishltr.html
Well I can accept the high sounding schoolboy , but not the nonsense. There are anumber of these guys that are quoted again and again. We evolve the Church, Christianity has evolved. People evolve, you can't pin today down by referring back into papers written 100 years ago.
The Catholic Church is nothing like it was between 1650 and 1900. Why should anyone expect Masonry to use the same tired Ideology.
[/font]
Morals and Dogma Published 1871
Hannah published 1952
At least 52 years old. It has merit they both do. Pike published thousands of pages praising Masonry and a few pages with questionable comments. nothing wrong with either but they are not LAW. They are a persons opinion.
So you are willing to acknowledge that masonry is a religion in at least the general sense?billmcelligott said:[font=trebuchet ms, arial, helvetica]Who can deny that it is eminently a religious institution?...But the religion of Masonry is not sectarian...It is not Judaism, though there is nothing in it to offend a Jew; it is not Christianity, but there is nothing in it repugnant to the faith of a Christian. Its religion is that general one of nature and primitive revelationhanded down to us from some ancient and patriarchal priesthoodin which all men may agree and in which no men can differ. It inculcates the practice of virtue, but supplies no scheme of redemption for sin...Masonry, then, is indeed a religious institution; and on this ground mainly, if not alone, should the religious Mason defend it" (pp. 617-619
So we see we can agree or we not differ,
I will accept "Its religion is that general one of nature and primitive revelation "
"but there is nothing in it repugnant to the faith of a Christian".
[/font]
I can accept that the writer observed the relationship between the fundamentals of life and the need to have some structure in both.geocajun said:So you are willing to acknowledge that masonry is a religion in at least the general sense?
If that is the case, then how can a person adhere to two religions?
Be Both Christian and Mason? Especially when one is based on direct revelation (Jesus) and the other is based on subjective image interpretation to teach deism?
Modern science was very much founded by Christians who were excited by the opportunity to learn more about God through his creation, nature. I don't think Bill is dodging in the least.geocajun said:well aside from you dodging my question, you do seem to continue to affirm for us that Masonry is teaching about revelation from God and it isn't compatible with direct revelation that we find in Christianity.
Tribe said:The Order of the Eastern Star and the Pentagram: http://www.ankerberg.com/Articles/new-age/NA0302W4.htm[/QUOTE]
I belong to the Order of the Eastern Star and I don't have to read a link to know the Star's symbolism, all of which is taken from the Bible. Tribre, what is the star seen in the ?East, who followed it and what did they find because they did?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?