E
Edwards1984
Guest
What about love, specifically romantic love? Is that not selfish?
I think of romantic love as necessarily, essentially selfish. I don't see how it can be otherwise. When you love someone, you wish the best for them. But that's not the end of the story. Love is a relationship. And you expect or want something from the partner for your benefit and consideration as well. We all have our own desires and expect, even demand things from our partner (like fidelity for example).
A love that isn't selfish, a love that is selfless, doesn't seem to me to be love at all. How can you have a relationship with your beloved if you aren't in the picture at all? Because of this, I remain positive about selfishness except for the instances in which the self is privileged at the expense of the other (as you point out).
I actually don't disagree that the other person should get something out of their relationship with someone else. What I said in my previous posts, however, is that we should avoid something where we are giving up something without anything given in return. I wouldn't necessarily call the desire for something in return selfishness, because we're talking about the union between a man and a woman in marriage. They are two people in one union, and hence everything they do is meant to be done (and enjoyed) together.
Let me try to explain it this way: I have known women who allowed men to do what they liked to them for the sake of the relationship (ie., "I don't want to lose him, etc."). However, they got nothing in return. That is not the Biblical definition of marriage, or even a Biblical relationship in general. To refer back to my quotation of Paul, the body of the person belongs to their partner and vice versa. When I marry a woman, I am not marrying a inappropriate content star who is supposed to please my every demand - I am marrying someone who is "bone of my bone, flesh of my flesh" (yes, I'm quoting Adam and Eve) and is my completion.
Perhaps we can clarify this further by stating that this physical relationship within marriage is a willing give and take. That is, each person within the relationship understands what Paul meant in the verse I cited before, and they submit to one another willingly, so that both parties are pleased. This would not be selfishness, this would simply be working in union the way God intended it. Have you ever been working outside on something, and you saw a friend/family member needed help with something, so you went over and, without saying anything, started helping them, and the two of you worked together? He needed help, and you supplied it to him, but it wasn't selfishness on his part. In like manner, husband and wife give themselves to one another from the natural bond within the relationship, not necessarily imposed expectations.
Now if this situation did get to the point where the man or woman demanded something from their partner, I think we're breaching the idea of a Biblical relationship. In other words, you start demanding something of them that breaches the willingness that is supposed to be there any way, so that really, logically speaking, you are making it that they belong to you, not you to them. That would definitely be selfishness within a relationship.
EDIT: Oops, I meant to add this in too!
I think the danger is that guarding oneself against sex can become just as obsessive as wanting to have sex. And that strikes me as unhealthy.
I actually agree with this too. While one should fight against lust, it's possible (as with anything) to go overboard. When a friend of mine called me some months ago and told me he was struggling with lust, one of the first things I told him was, "Stop obsessing over it." By this I didn't mean he should just give up, what I meant was the more you obsess with it, the more (ironically) you think about it. It's also easy to get into this pattern where you commit a sexual sin, feel really guilty, vow to stop, and then do it all over again. The guilt just becomes a therapeutic way of staying with the addiction. Getting control of the beast (by the grace of the Holy Spirit, of course) requires clear thinking.
Also, just to throw this out, I don't condemn everyone who struggles with lust to hell outright. I've struggled with lust since I was a preteen. I know how hard it is. All the more reason for us to realize what scripture teaches regarding it. And all the more reason for us to remember that Christ is a far greater savior than we could ever be sinners.
Last edited:
Upvote
0