I know this will sound bad, but I haven't gone to church in 6 years. After I had left the Southern Baptist church I had been a member of for years, I did try a church that was the Evangelical Free Church of American denomination, and I liked it, until they had a sermon about baptism that left me confused.
I've heard from others to try other denominations, but I do not feel right about going to churches that affirm homosexuality.
During my physical church absence, I've been listening to Charles Stanley. I used to read study guides from David Jeremiah. And now I've been reading from various authors to grow my faith, like Philip B. Payne, Beth Allison Barr, Sheila Wray Gregoire, etc.
I don't know if I'll ever go back to church.
This is why it is important for a Christian to study scripture to know the truth. I think you did the right thing. I wouldn't have stayed in a church that goes against what the Bible says, whether it be on baptism, affirming homosexuality, or some other point of doctrine.
One litmus test for churches is to go to their website and test their stated beliefs with scripture. It won't cover every doctrine they believe, but it'll go a long way toward understanding what the church believes at its core, so you can make an informed decision whether or not to attend.
I recommend YouTube for a broad spectrum of Christian content. So many churches stream their services live, and post regularly. You can see what the various denominations and individual churches are like. I watch sermons and seminars and use my computer to take notes while following along in the Bible. It has helped me to learn and grow, and I have a collection of notes. (I also keep my scriptural forum posts as notes.)
Speaking of reading... My denomination has hundreds of books and periodicals written by our church pioneers (and a long history of study guides) going back to the 1800's. I grew up reading some of them, but I didn't have a real appreciation until I revisited them in adulthood. This led me to want to put together a Christian library with references, commentaries and what not.
I started to visit my local used book stores, looking for books to add to my library. I didn't limit myself, I picked up books from various sources, not just my own denomination. In my search, I found that books from that era (the 1800's and early 1900's) are some of the best Christian books ever written. The authors knew their subject, and they were meticulous. Such joys to read. There is a wealth of knowledge in those vintage books.
I understand the need to be in a place where you share beliefs with others. There are people out there who share your beliefs, and there is a church out there for you. I have no doubt that the Holy Spirit will lead you where you need to go.
In the meantime, I have no idea whether or not we share the same beliefs, but I do know we are of one body.

You are not alone.
God bless!