Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
That was Italy.
I doubt that the trains ever ran on time in the USSR.
Maybe cloudyday2 meant post-USSR Russia when he wrote "USSR." It would be very hard to argue, with evidence, that there was much progress under Communism in the days of the USSR.
Mainly I was thinking of progress towards an religion-free society ("imagine no religion..."), but that was only one of the communist goals. There was also equality of sexes, equality of races, more equal distribution of income, investment in science, investment in economic infrastructure (factories, railroads, ...).That was Italy.
I doubt that the trains ever ran on time in the USSR.
Maybe cloudyday2 meant post-USSR Russia when he wrote "USSR." It would be very hard to argue, with evidence, that there was much progress under Communism in the days of the USSR.
I can't really consider that to be progress, but if that's what you meant, I see where you were coming from. My view is that one of most repressive, vicious, and backwards regimes in all human history and the word "progress" just don't go together--even if the onlooker dislikes religion.Mainly I was thinking of progress towards an religion-free society
Actually, a lot of that is myth, but we might as well not go into it here. It's just a footnote to the topic of the thread.There was also equality of sexes, equality of races, more equal distribution of income, investment in science, investment in economic infrastructure (factories, railroads, ...).
Mainly I was thinking of progress towards an religion-free society...
Have as many children as you want, because after they are exposed to the facts they will probably join our ranks.Since atheists have about 1/2 as many children as religious believers, I suspect you have an uphill road on building that one.
Tough to build an atheist future when so many atheists don't choose to help create the next generation in the most tangible and literal way possible - as parents.
Since atheists have about 1/2 as many children as religious believers, I suspect you have an uphill road on building that one..
I don't think our progress as a civilization depends so much on procreation. Obviously we have to have some children to have a future, but we would do just fine with at half the size we are now.
The problem with this theory is that we should see increasing theism in the US, but instead we see increasing atheism. I assume the theist children are converting to atheism quicker than the theists can give birth.That's half as many per generation. If we estimate 4 generations per century, that results in 1/16th as many great-great grandchildren. So we can see why demography is destiny.
Mainly I was thinking of progress towards an religion-free society ("imagine no religion..."), but that was only one of the communist goals. There was also equality of sexes, equality of races, more equal distribution of income, investment in science, investment in economic infrastructure (factories, railroads, ...).
I'm not saying the USSR was Shangri La, but they did have some worthy goals. Unfortunately the original leaders were too willing to use draconian measures to achieve their goals, and the later leaders probably had no goals except for personal power. Plus communism was not as efficient as capitalism.
Irony: the USSR was Marxist. Marxism has a goal to dissolve contradiction in society. The USSR became a nation of contradictions.
Probably Marx's biggest mistake was imagining that a dictatorship of the proletariat would lead to a withering away of the state. But then I suppose we could argue as to whether there was ever a dictatorship of the proletariat. In fact communist revolutions took place in countries that were still largely feudal by Marx's definition. IMO that is why they largely failed. Socialism was intended to an answer to the contradictions of industrial society, but they don't create an industrial society. Capitalism does a much better job of that, as does (I hate to admit) corporatism.
Yep. I would agree. A communist revolution can advance a society (depending on the state of the society at the beginning) but once a society gets to a certain point, it is a hindrance to development.
The problem with this theory is that we should see increasing theism in the US, but instead we see increasing atheism. I assume the theist children are converting to atheism quicker than the theists can give birth.
Another factor in family size is education. People with more education usually defer marriage and children, so they have fewer children. People with more education are also more likely to be atheist.We can be pretty sure that atheist genes are being strongly selected against, though. That is not something that was nearly as strongly the case in the past. You can thank the pill, and Tinder for that. I suspect that people who are more naturally inclined towards religion will be increasingly dominant in the gene pool as atheists self-select out of parenthood.
The other thing is that religions will be adapting themselves better to modernity and post-modernity. I already see a lot of evidence of this in the beliefs of my young theist friends versus those of gen-X and baby boomer generations. For example, I find that most serious Christians of 50+ are exclusivist, while I find that most serious Christians in their 20s are much more open to the possibility that other religions might also be true.
As a Baha'i, I would say that young people of every religion are being influenced by God's will for this age, and either responding in a positive way (inclusivism) or reacting against it (think ISIS and the like).
Another thing that might have gone wrong with both the French Revolution and the Communist Revolution is the attempts by other nations to overthrow the revolutionaries. This created a paranoid environment that made the terror campaigns seem expedient.I'm actually suggesting the opposite. Communism does not create an industrial society, capitalism or corporatism does that. What Socialism can do (a la Social Democrats, Labor Party, etc.) is do something about the excesses of unbridled capitalism. At the end of the day, a mixed economy is best. All of the developed countries in the world have found this to be the case, even and especially Communist China.
We can be pretty sure that atheist genes are being strongly selected against, though. That is not something that was nearly as strongly the case in the past. You can thank the pill, and Tinder for that. I suspect that people who are more naturally inclined towards religion will be increasingly dominant in the gene pool as atheists self-select out of parenthood..
When the general makes a suggestion, it's an order.Why not look at all the forms of revelation that you listed as ideas rather than commandments?
With respect, I think your persistent implicit suggestion that personal communication from the Lord is delusional disorder in this thread is, as you noted "off topic again." However, it is certainly sane to make sure we do not confuse the two sources of ideas. That's why I said:The idea should be evaluated through reasoning, consulting friends, etc. A woman with delusional disorder told me that she tries to ask another person's opinion before reacting to anything. She gave the example of seeing a building on fire, but due to her illness she wanted to be sure that it wasn't a hallucination before calling 911.
The bottom line seems to be: How does one distinguish between personal revelation from Above and
What can we look for in order to recognize personal revelation, so as to not be confused and led into needless errors and sorrows?
- mental disorder?
- feelings and thoughts engendered by personal emotions?
- intuition based on past personal earthly experience?
- spiritual communications from below?
The scriptures are a rich source of research. There are precious, simple patterns there that illustrate how, where, why and how people have obtained personal revelation from God over thousands of years. Not surprisingly, those patterns are quite similar in the scriptures of Judaism, Christianity, Buddhism, Islam, Sikhism, and Hinduism that I have read.So if the voice of Baal tells you to buy stock in some company, then do some research, talk to friends, and make a wise decision.
My Czech relatives still live in Bohemia, as they did before, during and after the Communist occupation. They seem pretty clear and united that the greatest progress that the USSR ever made was to go away."after the USSR had made so much progress."
?!
The Soviet Union went bankrupt building weapons on the backs of starving people and killed tens of millions of its own citizens over its 70 year history. So far Putin hasn't slaughtered tens of millions of Russians.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?