• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

  • CF has always been a site that welcomes people from different backgrounds and beliefs to participate in discussion and even debate. That is the nature of its ministry. In view of recent events emotions are running very high. We need to remind people of some basic principles in debating on this site. We need to be civil when we express differences in opinion. No personal attacks. Avoid you, your statements. Don't characterize an entire political party with comparisons to Fascism or Communism or other extreme movements that committed atrocities. CF is not the place for broad brush or blanket statements about groups and political parties. Put the broad brushes and blankets away when you come to CF, better yet, put them in the incinerator. Debate had no place for them. We need to remember that people that commit acts of violence represent themselves or a small extreme faction.

Arguments about God

Status
Not open for further replies.

Wiccan_Child

Contributor
Mar 21, 2005
19,419
673
Bristol, UK
✟46,731.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
In Relationship
Politics
UK-Liberal-Democrats
Well, I am not schizophrenic. But, why is it that you choose to insult me with the question? I have not insulted you.
It's a legitimate question when someone displays the symptoms of schizophrenia. Would you rather us be unconcerned with your well-being?
 
Upvote 0

-Vincent-

Newbie
Nov 19, 2008
109
0
✟22,729.00
Faith
Other Religion
Marital Status
Single
It's a legitimate question when someone displays the symptoms of schizophrenia. Would you rather us be unconcerned with your well-being?

I give up. Jesus said do not cast your pearls before swine, and he was so very right. Now that you have shown symptoms of being a pig, should I ask you about that?
 
Upvote 0

The Nihilist

Contributor
Sep 14, 2006
6,074
490
✟31,289.00
Faith
Atheist
I give up. Jesus said do not cast your pearls before swine, and he was so very right. Now that you have shown symptoms of being a pig, should I ask you about that?
You're telling us god talks to you. This is widely considered a completely crazy thing to say. But if you'd rather not cast your pearls to us pigs, you know where the little red box with the X is.
 
Upvote 0
T

tanzanos

Guest
I give up. Jesus said do not cast your pearls before swine, and he was so very right. Now that you have shown symptoms of being a pig, should I ask you about that?

Pigs are highly intelligent and emotional animals that have a very similar physiology to ours. So in fact calling someone a pig is a COMPLIMENT!
You are welcome to call me a pig any time:wave:
 
Upvote 0

Inviolable

Well-Known Member
Feb 27, 2006
2,285
59
✟3,179.00
Faith
Christian
Well,

Considering no other people who claim to know God are coming forward and simply leaving poor Vincent to his fate in this thread, I'll jump in and take some of the crazy heat off of him.

I believe I know God personally.
However I have never heard his voice in my head. I was an atheist until my early 30's when I believe I "felt" Gods presence.

Before that time I didn't think God could exist and then I was overcome with a spontaneous burst of emotion that "to me" wasn't something I had invoked.

It was far to overwhelming and instantaneous to have simply been an emotion I generated on my own. Which felt like something completely foreign to me. Foreign meaning, it didn't come from me and it wasn't mine but rather an emotion of God's that he shared with me to introduce himself.
 
Upvote 0

The Nihilist

Contributor
Sep 14, 2006
6,074
490
✟31,289.00
Faith
Atheist
Well,

Considering no other people who claim to know God are coming forward and simply leaving poor Vincent to his fate in this thread, I'll jump in and take some of the crazy heat off of him.

I believe I know God personally.
However I have never heard his voice in my head. I was an atheist until my early 30's when I believe I "felt" Gods presence.

Before that time I didn't think God could exist and then I was overcome with a spontaneous burst of emotion that "to me" wasn't something I had invoked.

It was far to overwhelming and instantaneous to have simply been an emotion I generated on my own. Which felt like something completely foreign to me. Foreign meaning, it didn't come from me and it wasn't mine but rather an emotion of God's that he shared with me to introduce himself.

Sounds like your mind has gotten the better of you. But whether that's true or not, you're not here telling us that you know everything about god and you literally heard him speak.
 
Upvote 0

Wiccan_Child

Contributor
Mar 21, 2005
19,419
673
Bristol, UK
✟46,731.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
In Relationship
Politics
UK-Liberal-Democrats
I give up. Jesus said do not cast your pearls before swine, and he was so very right. Now that you have shown symptoms of being a pig, should I ask you about that?
About being a pig? Vincent, all I have done is submit your testimony to scrutiny, to better understand it and your logic.
 
Upvote 0

Wiccan_Child

Contributor
Mar 21, 2005
19,419
673
Bristol, UK
✟46,731.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
In Relationship
Politics
UK-Liberal-Democrats
I believe I know God personally.
However I have never heard his voice in my head. I was an atheist until my early 30's when I believe I "felt" Gods presence.

Before that time I didn't think God could exist and then I was overcome with a spontaneous burst of emotion that "to me" wasn't something I had invoked.

It was far to overwhelming and instantaneous to have simply been an emotion I generated on my own.
Says who?

I've had spontaneous bursts of emotion myself, but why should that convince me of the existence of God (let alone which god)?

Which felt like something completely foreign to me. Foreign meaning, it didn't come from me and it wasn't mine but rather an emotion of God's that he shared with me to introduce himself.
Spontaneously and out-of-the-blue?
 
Upvote 0

-Vincent-

Newbie
Nov 19, 2008
109
0
✟22,729.00
Faith
Other Religion
Marital Status
Single
About being a pig? Vincent, all I have done is submit your testimony to scrutiny, to better understand it and your logic.

Well, I would suppose that you have read the bible. You may have read that God spoke the ten commandments to all of the people of Israel. And, that meant nothing to you, so you haven't changed at all. You do not seem to have any ability to trust. I doubt I can do anything to change that. Well, enough of me and my delusions.

What of your wiccan oppinions, what's that all about?
 
Upvote 0

Inviolable

Well-Known Member
Feb 27, 2006
2,285
59
✟3,179.00
Faith
Christian
Says who?
I've had spontaneous bursts of emotion myself, but why should that convince me of the existence of God (let alone which god)?
I guess, I say. I use to be manic bipolar. Depressive, whatever the term is.
I've had highs and lows and this feeling was neither.
It's also been 5 years since I've had a bipolar episode.
Since that day.
Spontaneously and out-of-the-blue?
Um, yes.
It was completely uncalled for. No reason whatsoever for me to feel the way I did when I did.

I wrote down what happened for some friends
Here is what I wrote to them.
I use the word "you" a lot because I thought it would help me write everything down faster.
I hope you enjoy.

You ever have a feeling or emotion that you cant understand or figure out?
Something that can overwhelm you but the thought of how to describe it evades you.

I'm sure in one form or another someone can compare something that has happened to them that they could not explain.
At least at first.

I would like to try and describe the sensation of being in a depressive bipolar state. It boggles me and I would like to get it out.
It's destructive and I would like to lose it completely, once and for all. The thought of it, just the thought, looms over you.

It's a hallow feeling, deep and brooding. Your chest feels has if it disappears, has if it had been swallowed whole by nothing.
The entire cavity around your heart fades into a hole and that hole feels has if anything can pass through it.

When you feel the hole in your chest, you begin to notice emotions flair. Depression of the worse kind.
Fear, sadness, sorrow, anxiety. Anything related to depression seems to spontaneously emerge all at once.
This feeling becomes so overpowering that every other emotion you could have goes away.
The overpowering feeling of depression blots out everything and you become empty. Like a vessel waiting for life and not expecting any.

After the feeling of depression has completely set in, insanity begins to take over.
You wonder, how could life be worth going through this kind of pain? You begin to think of suicide, just to get it to stop.
But you can't get it to stop, because you're sick and it's part of who you are.

There is no way to control it. It doesn't matter what you think, or who you see, or where you go. The depression stays with you.

Doctors will give you lithium to control it chemically. It stops the depression for the most part. But it takes away everything else has well. With lithium the feeling in your chest goes away and the depression becomes a shadow. Constantly stalking you. The depression is no longer in you, but it is still controlling you.
The lithium itself dulls your mind and blots out any emotion. Not completely robbing you of your emotions, but turning you into a overly mellow simpleton. Clouding your mind and forcing you to forget exactly what emotions are. Leaving you with a vague idea of love and happiness. The problem is, the vague idea of happiness is ever eluding and to complicated to work out in your mind.

Yet again, insanity begins to sink in. You begin to wonder, what the point is of living if you have to live like this.
Soon, you'll do anything to be able to make a rational thought. Even let the depression catch back up with you.
So, you stop taking lithium and the process starts all over again.

You get desperate for a solution. Something that will help you to stay clear headed and keep the depression away.
You go from doctor to doctor looking for answers. Each time you see a new doctor you try a new drug and each time you try a new drug something else happens that you can not live with.
So you look for organizations and has many different therapist has you can find looking for answers. Looking for something, some where, hoping there is a drug that no one knows about. You begin to grasp on to anything that sounds promising.
You try several treatments and several more drugs only to realize nothing works. Nothing can help you.

Your life is ruined all because of who you are. Utterly destroyed. With no hope you give up entirely and resort to live out your life with no desire to live.

This is when you don't even consider a place to live to be important. You live on the street.
Moving from place to place. Staying with one friend after the other, until finally you find yourself in a homeless shelter.

Being forced into the cold, some days reaching -10 below, with a windchill of 30 below. You just walk only knowing that you're cold and not even caring all that much about it.
Has you're walking, your mind lost and the simple sight of the things around you being to much to look at you notice the words "all are welcome".

Thats when you see a church and you decide to go inside.
You notice the warmth inside and are surprised that it's comforting. You sit down and stair at the back of the seats in front of you, all the while someone is preaching. Has the words echo in your head has simple noise only slightly resembling a person speaking, you look at your surroundings. A stained glass window catches your eye. You look at it admiring the color not knowing that you are in fact admiring something.
Thats when the noise echoing in your head become words. You hear what the preacher is saying and the hole in your chest goes away. You notice that the hole is gone and another feeling begins to swell inside. At first, you know what it is but you don't understand it. It's compassion in the form of joy. Suddenly you're hit with unspeakable gratitude. Joy, pure, wonderful joy. It's so very rare in your life to have this feeling that the sudden gratitude you get from having this joy is beyond any explanation.
All you can do is cry. You repeat over and over again, thank you!
With out warning, you know what life is and the gratitude grows, even when you thought it was impossible for it to get any stronger. For the first time in a very long time you feel the warmth of your heart beating and you recognize it has your heart.
The tears fall has your heart beats and the cold goes completely away. You begin to perspire but you don't take off your coat because you are so overcome with joy that all you can do is admire it.

The preacher stops preaching and you leave the church and begin life.
 
Upvote 0
L

Legion.As.One

Guest
Allow me to just add, cut it out with the insults! How old are you?
Inviolable, I think the feeling you're talking about is reverence of life and being. The sheer joy of living. I do wonder who you're thanking, you felt this feeling yourself, no god did it for you. Sudden realisation, nothing matters, you are life, and life is in you.
THAT, is what you felt... and you created the feeling yourself...
 
Upvote 0

Inviolable

Well-Known Member
Feb 27, 2006
2,285
59
✟3,179.00
Faith
Christian
Allow me to just add, cut it out with the insults! How old are you?
Inviolable, I think the feeling you're talking about is reverence of life and being. The sheer joy of living. I do wonder who you're thanking, you felt this feeling yourself, no god did it for you. Sudden realisation, nothing matters, you are life, and life is in you.
THAT, is what you felt... and you created the feeling yourself...
Unless I'm mistaken, that's just a belief you yourself have.
Can you back that up?
Which, you didn't really quote the post and point out where you came to this conclusion. You simply sprang it on me.

Also,
I really don't see where a feeling I influenced is going to control a manic bipolar state. Over the course of 5 years and several doctors "so far" have agreed with me.
Several being 5.

You said, "nothing matters" I don't know if you've ever experienced a manic depressive state before but I was already to the point where nothing mattered. Had been for two years.
 
Upvote 0
L

Legion.As.One

Guest
I can indeed, does not all joy come from the original source. A.K.A. Life?
When a child is born. Its mother loves it, and thanks (maybe god) for it. But she has truly given thanks to life for the opportunity.
I blind man can see, life gave him the chance.
Life gives humans chances, choices, feeling. It also takes these away.

As a person with -undisclosed - mental problems myself, I live for feeling, life as a human gives me feeling. Last time I checked, I caused these feelings through MY actions and choices.

(my apologies for the randomness, I should have warned you...)
 
Upvote 0

Inviolable

Well-Known Member
Feb 27, 2006
2,285
59
✟3,179.00
Faith
Christian
I can indeed, does not all joy come from the original source. A.K.A. Life?
When a child is born. Its mother loves it, and thanks (maybe god) for it. But she has truly given thanks to life for the opportunity.
I blind man can see, life gave him the chance.
Life gives humans chances, choices, feeling. It also takes these away.

As a person with -undisclosed - mental problems myself, I live for feeling, life as a human gives me feeling. Last time I checked, I caused these feelings through MY actions and choices.

(my apologies for the randomness, I should have warned you...)
Randomness is fine. I've lived with it for a long long time.

You say, "you cause these feelings" I certainly didn't cause such a sadness in myself that I wanted to die. There was no cause and effect. It simply existed within me. As I said, it was who I use to be.
The feeling itself may have caused more harm as I felt overwhelmingly defective. However, to make myself as clear as possible.
There were no events that took place, I simply was manic.

So while you might be able to explain the joy, if in fact you can?
You certainly can't explain the sadness. Other then a chemical reaction which is well documented.

I'd also like to point out that I haven't been on any medication in the past 5 years and I've been just fine.
 
Upvote 0
L

Legion.As.One

Guest
Joy is from giving - among various other things. Sadness, is much more. It is no event, it just is. Where there is joy there is always sadness. Sadness wells up, building and building. It is nothing like joy, which can be stripped away in a moment.
Your conscious mind didn't cause it, I assume. But your physical self did?

I can't explain why I suddenly feel like dying, or why I want to burn everything on this earth or I feel like growing wings to fly. The feeling leaves as soon as it came.

I can't explain yourself to you, obviously, when I can't explain myself to me. I read and translate, which is what I was doing with your previous, previous post.
I agree you're right about my explination, (I got ahead of myself in the spur the moment).

As a christian you no doubt believe your god created you.
I have made no claim to explain anything, for I know full well I can explain nothing.

(well done with your medication, it is always pleasing to hear people overcome problems
)
 
Upvote 0

Wiccan_Child

Contributor
Mar 21, 2005
19,419
673
Bristol, UK
✟46,731.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
In Relationship
Politics
UK-Liberal-Democrats
Well, I would suppose that you have read the bible. You may have read that God spoke the ten commandments to all of the people of Israel. And, that meant nothing to you, so you haven't changed at all.
The words were just that: words. The various religious texts of the world, while occasionally beautiful, don't get any special treatment in the "Should I believe this?" department simply because they're old and religious.

You do not seem to have any ability to trust.
Of course I can trust. But I don't trust anything that happens to cross my path: trust is earned.

I doubt I can do anything to change that.
I'm a scientist. Give me a reason to believe something, and I'll believe it. Is that so unreasonable?

What of your wiccan oppinions, what's that all about?
I'm not sure I understand the question.
 
Upvote 0

griggs1947

Newbie
Jun 22, 2007
98
0
77
✟22,710.00
Faith
Unitarian
Marital Status
Single
:cool:Tanzanos, I used to be a ravenous pig, but diabetes caused me to eat just for one rather than for three - from around 196 pounds to now 150 at 5ft.6in.
Oh, Yeshua insults the woman with a slur on ethnics other than Hebrew and he harmed someone's means of living by putting the demons into those swine.
Now what are y'all's arguments about God? We ought to discuss my original argumentation against Him. What are the weaknesses and strengths thereof? Even fideists cannot escape the arguments , because if God is God, then he has to be the Creator and Designer and so forth, so that arguments that fail to uphold Him and ones that dismiss Him are integral to fideism after all! :clap:And faith, the we just say so of credulity, cannot evade the arguments after all. :prayer:Please respond to the thread the presumption of rationalism about faith.:blush:
Thanks to all !:hug:
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0

R3quiem

Senior Veteran
Jun 25, 2007
5,862
216
In your head.
✟29,623.00
Faith
Agnostic
Marital Status
Private
What difference does it make? God will answer anyones sincere prayer, schizophrenic or not. He can respond to you, and that is the only important thing that you need to know from me.
This is a pretty misleading argument used by Christians. On the surface, it sounds like a falsifiable argument. It is said by Christians that if one prays sincerely, then their god will answer. So, this claim is falsifiable because if this god does not answer, then it is shown that the original claim was incorrect. If this god does answer, however, then it shows the original claim was true.

However, Christians who make this claim turn it into an unfalsifiable argument by ignoring any sincere prayer attempts that prove to be without a reciprocating effect from this god. If one says, "I tried many years of sincere praying, but got no answer." then just about every Christian I have seen that makes this original claim will respond by either implying or stating directly that the person was either not sincere in their prayer or not listening.

So the claim that a sincere prayer will result in an answer from the Christian god is an empty claim.
 
Upvote 0

griggs1947

Newbie
Jun 22, 2007
98
0
77
✟22,710.00
Faith
Unitarian
Marital Status
Single
Vincent, all arguments from religious experience are only of ones own mental states; to aver that He plants them begs the question.
This argument from personal relationship with Him is such.Yes, you can perceive His presence. but again that is your own mnd at work. I used to experience that some malicius being was nearby. I knew better, and stopped having that experience with my medicine.
Were you of another faith, your experience would be otherwise.
Do you allebe tjat He uses telepathy to send you those messages?
As this naturalist finding serves as the answer, not only to posit Him begs the question but also flouts Ockham's Razor. Again, the presumption of naturalism rules!
Oh, the Big Bang was not a creation of Existence but a mere transformation of what was ever already there!
 
Upvote 0

griggs1947

Newbie
Jun 22, 2007
98
0
77
✟22,710.00
Faith
Unitarian
Marital Status
Single
Inviolable, please consider your quote in context, where the pigs refer to the Syro-Phoenician woman and her two children. Remember that Yeshua first was only sent to the Jews but later decided to send his message to all.:preach:
You're reifying nothing as something that since the time of the ancient Greeks means nothing whatsoever as far as substance concerns itelf!
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz's big blunder was to query why is there something rather than nothing [ title of Bede Rundle's book] is a pseudo -question implying a pseudo-answer. The question thus makes no sense! Why is there God, for the sake of argument, rather than nothing. Ah, you'd probably respond with the begged question and special pleading that He is so different, the point at issue1
For, physicists ' nothing" refers to the active, eternal quantum fluctuations whence come matter -energy in accordance with the laws of conservation. They, not He sustain Existence.Yes, He is just a redundancy to sustain it!
That argument from contingency of contingent beings and Necessary Being begs the question of that Being as Aquinas as ever does!
You were then probably a supercilious [superficial ] atheist as any well-grounded one would know better than to aver what you do! Now, this finding doesn't commit the fallacy of the no true Scotsman.
Aquinas begs the question of the Primary Cause [ the etiological argument ] as he states that should one take away the Primary Cause ,one takse away all intermediate ones.
He and Kyle Williams do argue that the Kalam First Cause argument begs the question of a starting point, William Lane Craig notwithstanding, the days go day by day eternally. Craig avers that it is impossible to reach eternity by successive addition, but that itself means there exists infinity!:groupray: Either way , infinity exists and as noted in my first post in this thread. Days arrive then on time ,yet never end.
W.L.C. and Alvin Plantinga as well as other comedian- theologians provide sophisticated solecisms of sophistry mired in wanton woo!
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.