C
Caliban
Guest
Not necessarily my opinion but thought for debate!
Isaiah 7:14 says "The Virgin will be with child and will call him Immanuel." Immanuel means "God With Us." Yeshua means "God (Yah) Shall Save (Shua)." Isaiah 7:14 seems to specifically suggest that the Virgin will CALL the child Immanuel. Since "God With Us" and "God Shall Save" are not identical names, what are we to make of this?
In Matthew 1:23 we read: "Behold, the parthenos (young woman/virgin) shall be with child, and shall bear a Son, and they shall call His name Immanuel," which translated means, "God with us."
According to many skeptics, no one ever called Jesus by the name "Immanuel", which suggests a failed prophecy. In their view, because Matthew quoted from Isaiah the phrase "call his name" we should understand "Immanuel" to be taken literally since other biblical passages use names literally (i.e., Adams naming of Seth; Cains naming of Enoch; Seths naming of Enos, etc...). But if Matthew intended the name "Immanuel" to be taken literally then why do we not see any reference to it? Thought provoking? Ill say it is.