Christmas Music. Sincerely Thread. Evil, or Not Evil ? When is too soon ? Are you the 3rd category of people everyone else thinks is annoying ?

tobelieveinHim · Nov 24, 2023

So, I'm not quite sure this belongs here, But I felt like it collaborated with the Halloween thread, the thread about Halloween. Christmas Music!
There are some people who think Christmas music is evil, and then there are some people who think Christmas music is evil. If you are the third category of people that everyone else thinks is annoying? Ok, But seriously now.

Alright, So is Christmas music comforting to you, Or do you not like it ? I think I have given a hint as to what I think about it, But what do you think about it. ? If you are the third category of people that everyone else thinks is annoying, Then that also applies.
When is too soon to start hearing and playing Christmas music ?

I forget how much I like it because I didn't grow up hearing it very often. It is incredibly relaxing to me.

Desk trauma · Nov 24, 2023

Any time prior to 12/24 after 12pm is too early.

public hermit · Nov 24, 2023

It's always too soon for me. I would rather not hear Christmas music for weeks. I do like Christmas hymns during services. I always listen to the Vince Guaraldi Trio's: A Charlie Brown Christmas on Christmas Day, and then I'm done for another year.

HTacianas · Nov 24, 2023

tobelieveinHim said:
So, I'm not quite sure this belongs here, But I felt like it collaborated with the Halloween thread, the thread about Halloween. Christmas Music!
There are some people who think Christmas music is evil, and then there are some people who think Christmas music is evil. Ok, But seriously now.

Alright, So is Christmas music comforting to you, Or do you not like it ? I think I have given a hint as to what I think about it, But what do you think about it. ?
When is too soon to start hearing and playing Christmas music ?

Christmas music is in no way evil. It is incredibly annoying sometimes but it is not evil. It's like butter. Everyone likes it but it should be used sparingly.

AlexB23 · Nov 24, 2023

tobelieveinHim said:
So, I'm not quite sure this belongs here, But I felt like it collaborated with the Halloween thread, the thread about Halloween. Christmas Music!
There are some people who think Christmas music is good, and then there are some people who think Christmas music is evil. Ok, But seriously now.

Alright, So is Christmas music comforting to you, Or do you not like it ? I think I have given a hint as to what I think about it, But what do you think about it. ?
When is too soon to start hearing and playing Christmas music ?

Christmas music would be nice if it was played after Thanksgiving, ideally on December 1st. Sadly, the music started in my area on November 1st, 2023 or a few days after. For me, Christmas music is good, but sometimes, the pop stars make too much profit, which some should go to helping the poor this time of year and keeping people warm. That is why I prefer the 1950s Christmas music, as none of the artists back then are around nowadays to have expensive concerts and milk millions off of people.

Terri Dactyl · Nov 24, 2023

I love Christmas music, but some of it is depressing to listen to. We had a weatherman here, who was very well liked.
I remember being at work with speaker loudly playing :" All i want for Christmas is you" when one of our employees came in and told us that beloved newsman had committed suicide.
That was years ago, and I still cannot listen to it.

And songs that remind you of long ago, when your parents were still alive, and maybe you weren't the best kid in the world, but you'd give anything to go back , loving and kind, and would change so much. Songs like this, wanting to go back, make me weep.

The fun songs like Rudolph are happy songs , and songs praising Jesus are wonderful.

My favorite Christmas song is Mele Kiliki maka It s a song I saw in a funny Christmas movie:

MehGuy · Nov 25, 2023

Yeah... it's evil in its own sugary sweet way...

Fantine · Nov 25, 2023

I'm pretty fussy about Christmas music.

My favorite album since I've been a little girl has been "Harry Belafonte's Christmas."

Simple guitar arrangements, hauntingly beautiful spirituals and lullabies mixed with a few traditional favorites.

Next comes Mannheim Steamroller. As a musician who loves to improvise, I love following the different harmonies and instrumental parts and making up my own vocals. It's very relaxing.

Josh Groban, of course.

Last of all, I love SATB Christmas pieces. John Rutter, of course, but there are loads of beautiful choral pieces. I love practicing them, playing them, singing them.

The Christmas music I dislike? Rock and pop stars making obligatory Christmas albums. So commercial.

tobelieveinHim · Nov 27, 2023

Well, I thought I actually fall under the third category of people, In which if we heard nothing but 50's doo wop, And Christmas music all year round, I would be a much happier person

tobelieveinHim · Nov 27, 2023

MehGuy said:
Yeah... it's evil in its own sugary sweet way...

I never hear Christmas music, mostly. But, from the bit of it I hear, I forget how much I like it. If we heard Christmas music more often, along with 50's and 60's doo wop more often, I thought I would be a much happier person

MehGuy · Nov 27, 2023

tobelieveinHim said:
I never hear Christmas music, mostly. But, from the bit of it I hear, I forget how much I like it. If we heard Christmas music more often, along with 50's and 60's doo wop more often, I would be a much happier person

I can only really tolerate it for about a week before it starts driving me insane.

jayem · Nov 27, 2023

I'm not a religious person. But I like Christmas. Everyone knows it's largely a secular holiday. Christians grafted Jesus's birth into the Roman winter solstice celebration. And some good music has been written for it. A few of my favorites:

Darlene Love was Phil Spector's go-to girl singer. She does the best version of White Christmas. Irving Berlin (who was Jewish) wrote a spoken introduction, which is almost never heard in most recordings. Phil added it in as a spoken interlude between the verses.

The Eagles do an excellent cover of this old Christmas blues song, Don Henley's vocals are great. The original, by Charles Brown, is on YouTube and is worth a listen.

I'm not a big fan of Taylor, but she does the best version of Last Christmas. Better than George Michael's original.

Tropical Wilds · Nov 28, 2023

Is it sinful? No.
Annoying as heck? Nonobjectively, yes.

I, like many who worked retail, cannot stand 99% of Christmas music.

I do like the new one by Cher, though.

Chesterton · Nov 28, 2023

tobelieveinHim said:
If you are the third category of people that everyone else thinks is annoying? Ok, But seriously now.

I'm definitely in the category of people that everyone else thinks is annoying, but unfortunately it has nothing to do with Christmas music.

tobelieveinHim · Nov 28, 2023

I worked retail. I still love it more than most. It's modern, and mainstream that I can't stand. The only thing I will do is still shop in retail. I love the music they play, it's apart of the appeal and the draw for me there.
I prefer Christmas music to any other contemporary thing that is out there.

tobelieveinHim · Nov 28, 2023

Chesterton said:
I'm definitely in the category of people that everyone else thinks is annoying, but unfortunately it has nothing to do with Christmas music.

Not sure what you mean, but it was funny, at least lol

tobelieveinHim · Nov 28, 2023

I don't understand Taylor Swift, or most modern women these days. And I'm a woman. Sure, it might be cute, but I don't understand my generation at all.
Been rejected a many times for my traditionalism, as well.

tobelieveinHim · Nov 28, 2023

AlexB23 said:
Christmas music would be nice if it was played after Thanksgiving, ideally on December 1st. Sadly, the music started in my area on November 1st, 2023 or a few days after. For me, Christmas music is good, but sometimes, the pop stars make too much profit, which some should go to helping the poor this time of year and keeping people warm. That is why I prefer the 1950s Christmas music, as none of the artists back then are around nowadays to have expensive concerts and milk millions off of people.

This deserves a millions of some sort

Chesterton · Nov 28, 2023

tobelieveinHim said:
Not sure what you mean, but it was funny, at least lol

Just ask @AlexB23.

Chesterton · Nov 28, 2023

Terri Dactyl said:
I love Christmas music, but some of it is depressing to listen to. We had a weatherman here, who was very well liked.
I remember being at work with speaker loudly playing :" All i want for Christmas is you" when one of our employees came in and told us that beloved newsman had committed suicide.
That was years ago, and I still cannot listen to it.

I hear you. My grandma actually got run over by a reindeer, and to this day...I can't, I just can't.

Christmas Music. Sincerely Thread. Evil, or Not Evil ? When is too soon ? Are you the 3rd category of people everyone else thinks is annoying ?

Active Member

The pickles are up to something

social troglodyte

Well-Known Member

Christian

Active Member

A member of the less neotenous sex..

Dona Quixote

Active Member

Active Member

A member of the less neotenous sex..

Naturalist

Little Lebowski Urban Achiever

Whats So Funny bout Peace Love and Understanding

Active Member

Active Member

Active Member

Active Member

Whats So Funny bout Peace Love and Understanding

Whats So Funny bout Peace Love and Understanding

Similar threads