Which other denomination could you be?

I really don't care too much. As long as they try to follow Jesus, they can believe you have to swing a dead cat around your head at midnight.

Anglican or Orthodox.

Eastern orthodox, very conservative Anglicanism. I like the RCC but I'm concerned about traces of legalism I see in their theology. I also greatly respect the conservative S.B.C. but the real presence in the Eucharist is a deal breaker for me.

WELS or other conservative Lutheran synod > Conservative congregation of ELCA > Conservative Anglican > I don't know

I really like the Evangelical Lutheran Synod (ELS) and the LCMS. I would join one of those. If I had to leave Lutheranism completely I would go with the Presbyterian Church America (PCA) or the Orthodox Presbyterian Church (OPC). I could also possibly go with a really conservative Anglican denomination.

Probably Anglican or a Reformed/Presbyterian denomination (depending on local circumstances).

Yes LCMS I forgot to mention first. (I am WELS) or ELS. I would strongly consider a very conservative Anglican church I think ACNA but there are very few of those in North America and none within hundreds of miles where I live.

If I could not be a Lutheran in any sense at all, nor could I create or help create one, then I would go Anglican, than I would go Orthodox.

I would be another form of Conservative, Confessional Lutheranism. I would never be a Liberal form of Lutheranism. If I can't be Lutheran in any sense, Conservative Anglicanism (like ACNA) or Eastern Orthodox.

I could only be a confessional Lutheran, but if none were available to me (and with diminishing numbers of members it may be the case in the generation after myself), no Orthodox Chruch close by, no conservative Anglicans either, it would be Catholic. From my POV, regarding Churches close by, I would spend a whole lot less time cringing and holding my nose in the Catholic Church than any of the other options.

I would probably just attend services at the local military base, some of the Continuing Anglican Churches may be a possibility, the ACNA? not really so conservative, and I think like the NALC they will fracture and splinter until both are gone.

Calvary Chapel

I came to Lutheran doctrine through Bible study and the Book of Concord by way of Reformed/Presbyterian upbringing. I have met people who, when we really get to talking about doctrine, I could classify as Lutheran even though they stay in their Anglican, Roman Catholic churches. They focus on Christ and him crucified, they rely on faith and grace rather than works, and they believe in the Real Presence.

I'd probably go conservative Anglican. I might explore Orthodox, though I know the least about it among CHristian denominations.

None other.

If every Lutheran church suddenly vanished, I would most likely go Episcopalian/Anglican. Else I would go Orthodox, possibly one of the Ultrajectine Catholic Churches, depending.

-CryptoLutheran

Hard question to answer. I would put more emphesis on the local congregation and pastor than on the particular denomination, so I would have to spend time visiting local churches. I would certainly stick with a mainline church, not one of the independent Christian churches.

ViaCrucis said:

If every Lutheran church suddenly vanished, I would most likely go Episcopalian/Anglican. Else I would go Orthodox, possibly one of the Ultrajectine Catholic Churches, depending.

Click to expand...

I can tell you right away, VC, that you'ld have to be careful in an Orthodox church. Very beautiful, deep theology and worship, sometimes crazy people who don't have "legalism" in their dictionary. Lots of burnout and spiritual abuse, and the church probably churns out more "religious nones" than many others. Having said that, I miss it... but not the legalism. If I lived in another part of the country where they are more laid back, I might still be Orthodox.

We went to an Independent Catholic church for a while (my S.O. was baptized and confirmed Roman Catholic, but spent time in Pentecostalism with a lot of damage from that). It was liberal but the preaching was moralistic, and the leadership there was free-wheeling, and the worship sometimes bizarre: I was bit shocked by the "Salad Bar Eucharist" of just walking up and serving yourself, so I sat with the older folks and had the deacon hand me the Host. Our favorite deacon disappeared mysteriously, distressing us greatly, and the bishop wouldn't talk about it. That and a few other minor issues was enough to convince me not to stay.

Upper Cut said:

I would probably just attend services at the local military base, some of the Continuing Anglican Churches may be a possibility, the ACNA? not really so conservative, and I think like the NALC they will fracture and splinter until both are gone.

Click to expand...

Are you saying that the NALC will itself split, or are you saying NALC is too small a split-off from ELCA to be viable? NALC is currently my preferred denomination, it's just that it's already so small that there is no parish within 75 miles of me. I need to know what's going on. If you don't want to comment here, could you PM me?