Again, this isn't about Israel.
Did you read the OP?
Not at all.
This is President Trump's proposal. If it were to be enacted, which is not likely, I suspect that Jews would get an exception to the American-only citizenship because this is not directed at Israeli-Americans but at
all other hyphenated Americans.
Because it isn't. Read the OP and consider where this proposal came from (Trump). Trump's chief anti-immigrant advisor and policy maker is Stephen Miller who is Jewish.
The question of Israeli-American dual citizenship did not arise until
page two of this thread when I asked if Jews would be the exception - no one other than you think that they would be the rule.
I agree, but not only concerning Israeli-American citizenship but other dual citizenships except for with enemy nations. My own brother has dual citizenship because he was born in Canada, which also has birthright citizenship, to American parents. His son was born in America to two native Americans, but is now Canadian (Montreal) due to his father's dual citizenship. Can you understand that I am against forcing
anyone to chose?
Nobody is saying otherwise. The proposal is from President Trump. Because this is from him (in all probability through Miller) I suspect that Israel would be the exception. Should Jews be treated the same as everyone else or should they get an exception to the rule?
This is purely in your imagination. Read the OP at the very least.