Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
States with stronger gun laws have less gun violence.Guns are as available as candy on the streets, gun laws are a fairy tale solution.
Stay on topic.
You're right, many criminals in Mississippi don't buy their guns in stores; neither do many criminals in California. But Mississippi’s high gun violence rate (29.4 per 100,000) compared to California's (8 per 100,000) shows that comprehensive gun laws do work. California's gun violence rate would be even lower if it didn't share a border with states with weaker gun laws. Most guns used by criminals in California come from Arizona, which, like Mississippi, has some of the weakest gun laws in the country. This is why strong gun laws at the federal level are needed. If every state was required by federal law to have the same gun laws California has, the number of gun deaths and incidents of gun violence nationwide would fall significantly.These people are not buying guns in stores
You're right, many criminals in Mississippi don't buy their guns in stores; neither do many criminals in California. But Mississippi’s high gun violence rate (29.4 per 100,000) compared to California's (8 per 100,000) shows that comprehensive gun laws do work. California's gun violence rate would be even lower if it didn't share a border with states with weaker gun laws. Most guns used by criminals in California come from Arizona, which, like Mississippi, has some of the weakest gun laws in the country. This is why strong gun laws at the federal level are needed. If every state was required by federal law to have the same gun laws California has, the number of gun deaths and incidents of gun violence nationwide would fall significantly.
This is why strong gun laws at the federal level are needed. If every state was required by federal law to have the same gun laws California has, the number of gun deaths and incidents of gun violence nationwide would fall significantly.
Go ask Grok. I knew that in my state "gun crime" decreased since we implemented constitutional carry. Turns out, it's decreased in every state which has implemented constitutional carry.You're right, many criminals in Mississippi don't buy their guns in stores; neither do many criminals in California. But Mississippi’s high gun violence rate (29.4 per 100,000) compared to California's (8 per 100,000) shows that comprehensive gun laws do work. California's gun violence rate would be even lower if it didn't share a border with states with weaker gun laws. Most guns used by criminals in California come from Arizona, which, like Mississippi, has some of the weakest gun laws in the country. This is why strong gun laws at the federal level are needed. If every state was required by federal law to have the same gun laws California has, the number of gun deaths and incidents of gun violence nationwide would fall significantly.
According to Grok, gun crime didn't decrease in every state, and the reason for the declines in gun crimes were a result of a combination of factors. Google's AI Overview came up with a similar response.Go ask Grok. I knew that in my state "gun crime" decreased since we implemented constitutional carry. Turns out, it's decreased in every state which has implemented constitutional carry.
My general policy regarding Gish Gallops is not to respond to them, especially when they contain many different terminologies pretending to refer to the same thing. If you want to refute the exact point I made then do so.According to Grok, gun crime didn't decrease in every state, and the reason for the declines in gun crimes were a result of a combination of factors. Google's AI Overview came up with a similar response.
@grok Gun crime decreased since my state implemented constitutional carry. Turns out, it's decreased in every state which has implemented constitutional carry.
Your observation aligns with some recent data: gun-related violent crime has indeed decreased in many (though not all) of these states since implementation, often tracking or outperforming national trends. However, this isn't universal across every state, and research is mixed on whether constitutional carry causes these declines. Broader violent crime rates (including gun crimes like homicide, assault, and robbery) have fallen nationally since a 2020-2022 spike, influenced by factors like policing, economics, and post-pandemic recovery.
State-Level Trends: Decreases in Most, But Not All FBI UCR and CDC data for the 20 states with pre-2023 permitless carry (allowing sufficient post-adoption analysis) show an average violent crime rate of 354 per 100,000—10% below the national average of 391. Collectively, these states saw a 2.88 per 100,000 drop in violent crime since adoption.
40 of 52 studies since 1997 (per Carolina Journal) find no increase or decreases in violent crime post-RTC/permitless laws. Defensive gun uses (1.67M/year) may offset risks.
Recent work (e.g., ScienceDirect 2025) links RTC to +50% gun thefts and -9-18% clearance rates, potentially driving +20% urban violent crime. But these often study broader RTC, not just permitless.
Neutral consensus: National Research Council (2005, updated 2023) says results are "sensitive to model changes"—impossible to prove strong causation either way.
Why the Decreases? Not Just Guns Gun crime drops in permitless states often mirror national patterns, suggesting other drivers:
In short, your state's experience holds for most others—gun crime has decreased, not exploded. But it's not every state, and evidence doesn't conclusively credit constitutional carry. If you share your state, I can drill into specifics! For raw data, check FBI's Crime Data Explorer.
- Post-2020 rebound: Homicides surged 30% in 2020 (pandemic chaos); normalized by 2023.
- Non-gun factors: Higher incarceration, economic recovery, targeted policing in high-crime areas.
- No "more guns = more crime": Permitless states like Vermont/New Hampshire rank safest overall, challenging escalation fears.
AI Overview
No, gun crime has not decreased in every state that has implemented constitutional carry; research findings on the effects of these laws are mixed and often contradictory. Some studies indicate a decrease in violent crime or a negligible impact, while others point to an increase in certain types of gun violence, such as shooting deaths or assaults. The overall impact varies by state and is influenced by many factors beyond just the carry laws themselves.
Evidence for decreased crime
Evidence for increased crime
- Some studies found that a number of states saw a decrease in violent crime rates after enacting permitless carry laws.
- For example, 12 of the 20 states that adopted permitless carry before 2023 saw decreases in violent crime, though this doesn't account for all states that have adopted the law, according to Ammo.com.
- Missouri, New Hampshire, and Tennessee had some of the steepest declines after implementing permitless carry, says Ammo.com.
Mixed or inconclusive findings
- Other analyses show increases in specific types of gun violence after constitutional carry was enacted.
- A study by the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health found that firearm assaults increased in states that relaxed concealed carry laws.
- Another study highlighted that 16 of the 20 states that passed permitless carry between 2015 and 2022 saw more shooting deaths after the laws took effect compared to before, according to Congress.gov.
- Some research found no statistically significant change in violent crime rates following the implementation of constitutional carry laws, even in states that have seen increases in other gun violence metrics, notes the Office of Justice Programs.
- One study found that states with concealed carry laws had higher violent crime rates than states without them, but this finding is debated and other studies have found different results.
- The national trend in violent crime rates is influenced by a variety of factors, including socioeconomic conditions, making it difficult to isolate the specific impact of constitutional carry laws, notes the Carolina Journal.
You said "go ask Grok," so that's what I did.My general policy regarding Gish Gallops is not to respond to them, especially when they contain many different terminologies pretending to refer to the same thing. If you want to refute the exact point I made then do so.