@mindlight , your post (#1) prompts vital reflection on America’s history and White Male Protestants’ (WMPs) role, but I challenge its framing and reject misleading progressive narratives that vilify WMPs which only serves to sow division. Scripture calls us to speak truth in love (Ephesians 4:15), honoring God’s sovereignty (Romans 11:36) and Christ’s redemptive work (Colossians 1:15–20).
Let’s address your questions:
1. Is this a fair description of U.S. political history?
No, it’s incomplete. WMPs significantly shaped America’s founding—crafting God-inspired documents like the Constitution and Bill of Rights—but their role reflects
divine providence, not racial or gender supremacy (Psalm 33:12).
@ThatRobGuy (#9) rightly notes diverse contributions: Black slaves, some immigrants who adhere to the RCC, and Native allies built alongside WMPs. The claim that others were “in the way” (#1) oversimplifies, plus equating slaves to low-paid workers (#14) minimizes slavery itself.
@Larniavc (#15) is correct: slaves were property, not laborers. America’s story glorifies God’s grace through all peoples, not one group.
Misleading progressive narratives, like critical race theory which you mentioned in post (#10), falsely paint WMPs as perpetual oppressors, dividing believers (Galatians 3:28). As both Calvin and Sproul teach, history serves God’s glory, not human pride.
2. Is a more equitable vision desirable?
Biblical justice—opportunity based on merit—is God’s command (Proverbs 16:11). Hispanics, women, Blacks, and Catholics should all prosper through faith and work (Colossians 3:23). But progressive “equity” (equal outcomes) defies Scripture, rewarding sloth over diligence (2 Thessalonians 3:10).
@ThatRobGuy ’s Ford vs. NASA examples (#9) show fairness depends on truth, not forced narratives. I personally champion a merit-based society, rejecting systems that fracture and divide.
3. Which is the greater threat to WMP power?
Secular elites—the 1% pushing godless agendas (e.g., abortion, gender ideology)—threaten all Americans, not just WMPs (1 Timothy 6:10). Their wealth and influence choke the church’s witness (Revelation 3:17). Merit-based social mobility aligns with God’s justice (Proverbs 22:29) and isn’t a threat
@ThatRobGuy ’s data (#9) shows Protestants trail in education/income, debunking WMP “power.” Your elite concern (#13) is biblical; they oppose Christ’s reign. As Paul Washer warns, we battle spiritual forces, not flesh and blood. (Ephesians 6:12).
4. How can hope be restored, and what are the barriers?
True hope rests in Christ alone (Psalm 37:5), not human systems.
@ThatRobGuy ’s trade/vocational training (#9) reflects biblical stewardship (Luke 16:10), cutting debt and opening prosperity, as Germany shows. Barriers—inflation, government overreach, family decay (Ephesians 6:4)—stem from rejecting God’s design.
Progressive policies (e.g., welfare traps) enslave to debt (Proverbs 22:7). Christians, per Spurgeon’s call, seek revival through prayer, repentance, and policies honoring work and faith (2 Chronicles 7:14).
America’s history, with its triumphs and sins, points to one truth: Christ is King (Colossians 1:16–17). As sinners—WMPs, Blacks, Hispanics, all—we fall short (Romans 3:23). Yet Christ’s blood atones for all who repent and believe (John 6:37), uniting us in His kingdom, where “there is neither Jew nor Greek” (Galatians 3:28). Misleading progressive narratives divide, but Christ reconciles.
As Spurgeon preached, “Come to Jesus, weary soul, and find rest.” Whether angry (#10) or seeking hope (#1), turn to Christ. He alone restores nations and souls (Revelation 21:5). Will you trust Him today?
In Christ’s sovereign love.