It does not matter where you are on this globe or FE... if you stand, face North, the stars must move from East to West. If you stand, face south, the stars will move east to west. This is because every single piece of ground on this earth moves from west to east as we spin.Look. You can contact many people in these hemispheres by Skype (not telling them your intentions of whether you believe in a round or flat Earth), and ask them to capture video footage for you (with them in it) that shows the constellations over a lengthy period of time for you to see the stars to rotate if you speed up the footage. I guarantee that they would have no agenda. Especially if you were to ask a bunch of them to do so on your behalf. You can currently see videos on YouTube for this and save yourself the trouble; But that false Flat Earther conspiracy theory mindset might kick to make you doubt regular people (Who do not even think about these kinds of discussions). If this is the case, then talk to a bunch of people by face chat in the Northern and Southern Hemispheres and ask them to record footage for you after you get to befriend them.
Because one vantage point is on top of the ball and one vantage point is underneath the ball. Take two stuffed animals and bend their heads back with tape, two cameras (or smart phones) and tape them to two opposite ends of each other on a beach ball. Now spin the beach ball and record the cameras and let the little stuffed animals have a nice ride. Look at the footage from both cameras or smart phones and you will see the rotation of spin is the opposite of the other. The stuffed animal on top of the beach ball will see the spin differently than the stuffed animal on the bottom of the beach ball as it spins.
There is actually a more simpler way to check this without using this method if you like. I just did it while I was on bathroom break. Try spinning while you stand (either on ice or with your own two feet on the ground).
![]()
Take one of your hands and point to the direction of where you are going to spin while you are on your two feet.
![]()
Look up at the ceiling (as you spin).
![]()
and visualize an imaginary clock on the ceiling above you as you spin.
![]()
Keep your hand pointing in the direction of the spin as you do this. Do you notice the imaginary clock spinning clock wise or counter clock wise?
Make a mental note to yourself if you see that the direction of your spin matches the hands of an analog clock going forward or backwards.
![]()
Now, look down:
![]()
Keep your hand in the same direction pointing (where you kept the same spin of direction from before):
![]()
Now star spinning on your two feet again or spin while you ice skate:
![]()
Important Note: Please keep your hand towards the same direction you pointed from the previous spin.
Now, imagine an imaginary analog clock at your feet as you spin.
![]()
Does the hands of the clock move clock wise or counter clock wise as you spin in the same direction as when you looked up at the ceiling?
If you did the experiment correctly, you will notice that the hands of the imaginary clock in your mind on the ceiling would be different than when you looked down at your imaginary analog clock on the ground.
This is the same reason why stars spin in different directions when looking at them in the Northern hemisphere vs. the Southern hemisphere.
I hope this helps, and may God bless you.
You are confusing "looking up" with "looking south" or "looking north"
Just because you are on the "bottom" of the globe... looking North is still looking north. The stars will still move the same way across the sky as the sun and moon.
Or, does the sun rise in the west down under?
It took me a while to run this through my brain. What you said made sense until I realized that you can look "up" with your left shoulder to the west, or you can look "up" with your right shoulder to the west.
One will have you facing North, the other will have you facing south. Either way... the stars, on a spinning globe must always appear to move from east to west.
Good brain teaser though.
Upvote
0