Reason does not work. Certain elements amongst scientists demand that everything be on the terms it sets, or it will not consider. Its a fixed deck. There is no reasoning with that. Its a bully pulpit from the First Secular Church of pseudo Science.
What kind of peer review? LOL! You have no idea. Again, you are imposing a standard that does not fit with the Christian way of life.
Really? have you ever watched in on theological debates? Its no different than debating you. You are just stuck in a secular sphere of traditional thought that is sacred to your heart. Reason will not reach such a person. For they live in a world of their own making. Its a hiding place to make the world stop spinning.
There have been many debates between Young earth Creationists and GAP proponents. It does not solve a thing for the most part. For, man has a stubborn unreasonable side to match the side that had been open to receive an idea. The ones that appealed to their own way of viewing reality is what they melded with.
God is separating men from men.. by means of what they choose to believe. All men. In Christianity God allows for false doctrine to stay its course. For those who are doing the will of God will find the truth. Those who are not, will accept lies. If we were all forced to believe only one thing? It may give an outward appearance of unity. But, it would fail to reveal the real person. God is after the real person. That is why God allows for all sorts of lies to permeate the atmosphere of any given society. The stupid stubborn ones (though they may be proud of their high IQ) will always choose some form of lie which they must defend with their wits. That gives them a challenge to pump up their sense of pride in who they are. Others, will find truth. Those who find truth do not mock and scorn like you do who do not agree with what you want others to believe. Truth has an amazing way of stabilizing a soul in the middle of a storm of reaction.
Now... as far as having a peer review amongst Christians?
God is having his way by not forcing us all to agree to seeing things one way! Even when the Truth has been made clear! Men are still free to reject reality.
There can be no effectual peer review for the Church. Only debate and conflict. Those gaining truth enter a peace, but not from winning and defeating his opposition. It comes from God while those opposing continue down their path of spiritual destruction.
Some will repent when exposed to correction. But, there can be no consensus at the end of the day. For man is a fallen creature with a nature that is contrary to peace and honest reasoning.
Here is why there can be no peer review for the Church.
1 Corinthians 11:18-19
In the first place, I hear that when you come together as a church,
there are divisions among you, and to some extent I believe it. No
doubt there have to be factions among you to show which of you
have Gods approval.
God is in effect heating up the church to skim off the dross, so that the pure gold is His to keep. The dross are those who follow lies and deceptions willingly. They choose to be that way. Done in stubbornness and unreasonableness ... Yet, all done in the guise of being objective and reasonable
.
Only winners win in the end. Not to those who only appear to be winning to their like minded peers.
Matthew 19:30
But many who are first will be last, and many
who are last will be first.
Read the last one. It applies to you.