Was the point He doesn't punish or doesn't afflict disease?Please Read The Op And Post Appropriately.
Upvote
0
Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
Was the point He doesn't punish or doesn't afflict disease?Please Read The Op And Post Appropriately.
Jimmie, the closest you get with the first scripture is nondescript "plague" mentioned once--and in conjunction with "bloodshed" in verse 17. I don't think you realize that what you're posting isn't what I'm asking for. Yes--it's violent, scarey stuff--but it does not meet the OP's criteria of God putting sickness or disease (these words aren't even mentioned!!) on His people to teach or chastise (was He teaching or chastising??). Surely you see this--it's not the same thing as what the OP isn asking for.
Let's step back and take a look at the two possibles that we have come up with so far:
1. Daniel's son
2. Miriam
Of course it's offensive. Don't lie, you mean to be offensive and we all know it.However, these same faithless unbelievers (I hope that truth isn't offensive)
must also conceed that it is possible that, at least in the case of Miriam, that the law of sowing and reaping could be at play.
In the case of Daniel's son, it is also possible that the sins of the father (Daniel) have been visited upon the son. Actually, this is painfully obvious--which doesn't necessarily take away from what is also obvious to a faithless unbeliever, which is that God specifically targetted the child for affliction with sickness or disease for the purpose of teaching or chastisement.
You also seem to admit that God was chastising/punishing/disciplining someone in this example.Oh--wait...that may not be the case either. What was being taught/who was chastised through this event? Or was it the law of sowing and reaping in effect?
So the score, if generously observed, is
Opposition to the OP: 2 possible
Events in accordance with the OP: Never been any.
I've seen much better strawmen than that in my day. This is just pathetic.So, the opposition bases its entire belief system of God using sickness and disease to teach us (which is the reason they say God cann't be depended upon to heal today through faith) upon two flimsy-supported events in the old testiment.
Let's step back and take a look at the two possibles that we have come up with so far:
1. Daniel's son
2. Miriam
Two possible cases where God specifically targetted His children for affliction with sickness or disease for the purpose of teaching or chastisement. From the standpoint of someone who does not know or believe that God is good, I can see how this might be proof that God has done this in these two cases.
However, these same faithless unbelievers (I hope that truth isn't offensive) must also conceed that it is possible that, at least in the case of Miriam, that the law of sowing and reaping could be at play. In the case of Daniel's son, it is also possible that the sins of the father (Daniel) have been visited upon the son. Actually, this is painfully obvious--which doesn't necessarily take away from what is also obvious to a faithless unbeliever, which is that God specifically targetted the child for affliction with sickness or disease for the purpose of teaching or chastisement. Oh--wait...that may not be the case either. What was being taught/who was chastised through this event? Or was it the law of sowing and reaping in effect?
So the score, if generously observed, is
Opposition to the OP: 2 possible
Events in accordance with the OP: Never been any.
So, the opposition bases its entire belief system of God using sickness and disease to teach us (which is the reason they say God cann't be depended upon to heal today through faith) upon two flimsy-supported events in the old testiment.
Nice.
Your response is missing the point entirely.
Everything is sowing and reaping based upon the systems God had put in place. We reap what we sow. Is it God's fault that Adam and Eve ate from the tree because He put the tree there? Is it His fault we fall and hit the ground if we walk off the roof?
The OP has defined a specific type of situation for a specific purpose. We aren't going to get anywhere if we continually lump a whole lotta other stuff in with it.
The point of the thread is that we simply cannot base an entire belief system of God using sickness and disease to teach us (which is the reason folks say God can't be depended upon to heal today through faith) upon two (so far) flimsily-supported events in the old testiment.
It's rediculous. PLEASE STAY WITHIN THE BOUNDS OF THE OP OR START YOUR OWN THREAD AND CONCEED THAT THE OP IS CORRECT.
There is a great difference between good and bad...that some folks do not understand--or choose not to accept. If they knew the God of the Bible, they would know that He does not inflict sickness or disease upon His people to chasten or teach. There is no instance in the Word ANYWHERE of Him doing this...to His people...to chasten or teach.
Bring it...so others can see the Truth.
These folks aren't just mistaken--they actively, purposefully promote anti-faith and purposefully steal others' hope for healing for their own selfish, prideful purposes.
Amazing but true.
Let's have it--start posting all of the many, many times when God:
a. inflicted sickness or disease on His people (believers)
b. for the purpose of teaching or chastening.
We're waiting...
...and by the way, DON'T CHANGE THE SUBJECT--JUST POST ALL OF YOUR MANY, MANY REFERENCES THAT MEET THIS CRITERIA.
Sigh
this thread is saddening, yet only proves what goes on daily, day after day
You know, I will be honest, from what some of you said on what suffering is and goodnes, using evil for good, God 'allowing' it for some purpose etc etc
from what you have said, I hope that I never meet you, LOL in all honestly,'
If that is what you believe about goodnes, life and God, what He does,
dont encourage me, dont be around me.
You wont bring life, but hurt and death to people, sorry to be blunt.
You know its honestly, sickening, what some of us christians believe on goodness and what love is.
for petes sake, GOOD IS GOOD! LOVE IS LOVE, there is EVIL or BADNESS In GOOD, you cannot turn darkness in with light, because it wont be light anymore, it will be a shade, and we know God is light, and there is no darkness in Him,
if but what I read on this thread. God allows stuff, sends trials my way the way some of you explain it. Are we not suppose to be images of Christ. IF then, lets all allow the poor person to learn, lets not help him, for it will not be in Gods will. Let all us not help someone for we might be going against Gods will! let the person learn, suffer!
sighI dont know every much at all. but as a Son of God, my own brothers and sisters condemn, we are one of the most judgemental people, not even willing to admit we are wrong, self-righteous people. COMPASSION, ACCEPTANCE LOVE!! is what we are. we dont tolerate sin, BUT we do meet people where they are, with HOPE! and LOVE! Because its God who changes people, not us!
oh well, the human mind again, if it feels right, looks right, logic seems right, everyone says its right, must be right eh?
yet the guy next door believes another thing, yet he is right in his own mind.
hey evern Hilter was right in his mind, look at the lot who followed him?
God bless
Forum Cruiser, I am 26,
and alot of bad things have happened to me already and are, mentally abused, toremented, two chronic illnessesses, chronic depression, and living with the scars of OCD, and being exposed to false doctrine.spiritually abused..
Not bragging at all.. My suffering is no badge of honor, in this all I have questioned my believes, what i believed, what I am beginning to see, what the Devil has done to me, Yes I made bad decisions, but I also now their are things that happened to me that was not of my own sin, nor anyone elses, but of this fallen world. things jsut happen. plus the Devil.
what I am seeing, that alot of what people are saying on this thread of God and suffering and Him casting or being apart of it, whatever ya call it, is not good...its not right...
There hasnnt been a day, only a few in my life that I can say I was truly happy or had joy.
however, I think i am learning that this is not Gods will for me, that He wants me well, and whole, that this depression this illness is not of Him, this OCD which causes me mental anquish is something that breaks His heart, Him watching me struggle daily with physical disability causes Him to sigh, and bring pain to His heart. I think that this heart, when he sees it, brings Him pain, that this tattered body that He paid a price for, brings Him grief, because just maybe, just maybe He wants me whole, since I am His temple.
If there is a lesson in this, it is I was never meant to be like this, the discipline that I needed, was in His word after all.
Maybe the Devil, who was behind it all, thought God as that way, and thus Tried to destory me. Just maybe
However, God bless you all, in your enthusiam and what your honestly, but one thing I will not bless, is what you teach. I am not write and do misunderstand alot of all you said. However, I am right in this, something what you say is not right of God.
There has been difficult times in my life, for each a young age, it is no honor of me, I lost. However, what I learned and hopefull will fully accept and learn, THIS is not Gods will for me, He desires me WELL.
anyway, God bless, I really dont care what you say![]()
My heart is at right now is for my fellow Christians to know to watch what they say,
there are tons of lost sheep out there, because of us
Our so called kindness and love has infact been nothing more then a evil tool to drive people away from Christ and to lose hope of thousands.
We are to help, what we or people do in the sake of God to be kind to be righteous is sometimes not righteous at all, its all suppose to be in love!
our bad attitudes and unkind nature hurts people, we are believers of Christ, how do you think God feels if broken vessels come to the Church become His Children and then get broken even more?
Ichabod 2, you make good points, I dont disagree there.
yes all praise to God. I know i need to give glory and praise God for that!
However, I am not disputing here that people love God nor serve Him
I am saying there is something wrong in how we or some people here who portray God, it is wrong. I am not saying they are all wrong. something in what is said is wrong, it is like they are concentrating alot on God's power refining, wrath etc etc, its like if desiring good things, the good and loving things others teach of is wrong and fleshy. and like its not good.
Yes God is a consuming fire. However, He is good and love. That He is. LOVE
Love is kind, patient and gentle. etc
People here seem to tell of refining the purging process as if they get some righteousness out of it, as if it is right and good. IT IS!!! boy refining is good, burning that unholy stuff out. BLESS THAT!
however, be open, maybe its not what you think it is. Maybe God is nicer and kinder then you think! Yes He does use everything for good, He turns things into good.
However maybe its not what you think it is
I have noticed alot of people judge their beliefs on their circumstances, and the like. what has happened to them, what they see and feel. I cannot say what I see, sorry these words are not right, but its there.
God is good, I am saying you are painting a bleak picture of a Good God, and loving one at that. WRATH and ANGER can be righteous, but maybe its beacuse of the pain and others feel of sin, that what God really angry and wrathful about is how He wants good and love for all, that people dont have it cause of sin! that they cannot worship Him
I see here people concentrating heavily on refining purging like the movies and how they view Christ, Purge! Purge!, yes indeed, but remember love and what it truly means to be kind and gentle
if God is the best at everything, He is the also the most Gentlest and Merciful of all
We all sin in so many ways we though not we do, yet we are not all punished,
Maybe Christ really did take my punishment on the Cross
I wonder what He is punishing me for now? I thought he paid a one time price
peace
I agree, He does want us whole. And He also allows suffering and giveshowever, I think i am learning that this is not Gods will for me, that He wants me well, and whole, that this depression this illness is not of Him, this OCD which causes me mental anquish is something that breaks His heart, Him watching me struggle daily with physical disability causes Him to sigh, and bring pain to His heart. I think that this heart, when he sees it, brings Him pain, that this tattered body that He paid a price for, brings Him grief, because just maybe, just maybe He wants me whole, since I am His temple.
You bet the devil will try to destory you. And me and all Christians,Maybe the Devil, who was behind it all, thought God as that way, and thus Tried to destory me. Just maybe
I agree, He does want us whole. And He also allows suffering and gives
us tools and grace and power to overcome.
That should be a hint to us when we read that we're overcomers...
That we WILL have some things to overcome.
You bet the devil will try to destory you. And me and all Christians,
it's his job, kill, steal and destroy.
Keep standing Child of God!