Would it be sin?!?

[ParsonJefferson]

Wow.. So how is having a vastectomy or tubal is mutlilating yourself? Not any different than a gall bladder taken out.. Or a cancerous kidney. How is this different that any other operation?

Oh good lord, now you've done gone and kicked over the stink bucket.

You're going to be condemned to hell for SURE now!

 

[thereselittleflower]

mostly because you have no evidence to support that claim. No single person can say "All christians believed this." It's impossible.

More STRAWMAN Logical fallacy . .

No on ever said that all individual chrsitians believe something . . but that all of CHRISTIANIY taught Contraception to be a sin . . .

These are the teachings of the various Churches . .Catholic, Orthodox, Lutheran, Presbyterian, Anglican, Methodist, and so forth and so forth, which was unanimous up until the Lambeth decision in 1930 which started the landslide into contracteption and abortion and now reviving euthanasia. . .

and for your perusal:

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/amex/pill/peopleevents/e_humvit.html

Ignoring the Vatican
Within just two years of Humanae Vitae, almost as many Catholic women used the Pill as non-Catholics. By 1970, two-thirds of all Catholic women and three-quarters of those under 30 were using the Pill and other birth control methods banned by the Church. In 2002, Humanae Vitae still defined the Church's position on birth control, and many observers of the Church believed that it contributed to the erosion of the Vatican's authority during the last decades of the twentieth century.

"All Christians" apparently don't include all of the RCC.

Again, perpetuating the Strawman . . we are not takling about individuals. We are talking about what the Churches taught.

What inidivuals do has nothing to do with what their Church teaches . .


.

 

[Benedicta00]

I'd strongly suggest you do CLOSE this thread.

I think it's quite telling to hear sex within marriage referred to as "Marital Sodomy."

That's all that needs to be seen and said to understand the judgmental, unchristian attitude here.

Thanks.

who has dammed you to hell? no one has judged you.

I can go into the liberal forum ad get the same accusation. that because I speak out against liberal ideas, I'm judgemental.

 

[thereselittleflower]

Wow.. So how is having a vastectomy or tubal is mutlilating yourself? Not any different than a gall bladder taken out.. Or a cancerous kidney. How is this different that any other operation?

Is not removing a gall bladdre or cancerous kidney done to RESTORE the body to a state of welness?

How is a vasectomy restoring one to a state of health?

How is a tubal ligation restoring one to a state of health?




.

 

[thereselittleflower]

so if the child as a result grew up and had her own family and those kids found a cure for cancer--- would you still say she was stupid?

From life- anything can come. that's why we have to let God make our choices and we can't do it of we are sterile.

Yes, from life anything can come.


From sterility and death nothing can come.


.

 

[Benedicta00]

Wow.. So how is having a vastectomy or tubal is mutlilating yourself? Not any different than a gall bladder taken out.. Or a cancerous kidney. How is this different that any other operation?

HUGE difference.

You are equating fertility and pregnancy with disease and sickness. Why?

 

[Benedicta00]

Is not removing a gall bladdre or cancerous kidney done to RESTORE the body to a state of welness?

How is a vasectomy restoring one to a state of health?

How is a tubal ligation restoring one to a state of health?




.

it's not.

it's telling God he made a mistake for giving you the gift of fertility.

 

[Benedicta00]

Well, for starters, it's RIGHT ACROSS THE PAGE FROM WHERE IT SAYS IT'S OKAY TO WORSHIP MARY.

Are you calling me a Mary worshipper?

 

[Gwenyfur]

Thread Closed per OP's request

 

[IamAdopted]

Is not removing a gall bladdre or cancerous kidney done to RESTORE the body to a state of welness?

How is a vasectomy restoring one to a state of health?

How is a tubal ligation restoring one to a state of health?




.

Because for some it restores to health..There are even some couples that have children that can not be normal because of mixing the different genes together cause harm to the fetus and this child suffers greatly..