Oh NO ... do NOT go there, please! I have one sister who LOVES to say that the Bible was written by a bunch of old Jewish men scared and hiding out in caves. If that were the case, what about the old testament, or the letters written when the apostles were traveling?cazza said:THE BIBLE WAS WRITTEN BY MEN!!!!!! I SAY NO MORE!!!!
Paul explains God's plan for lines of authority for the world to function smoothly. Note even Christ had to submit to God. This also notes God's established roles within family. In much of life we all must submit. We submit to a police officer's authority over us as citizens. We submit to our employers delagations of tasks and work load. Each town's Mayor submits to the state's Governor, as each state's Governor submits to the President and Federal Government's authority over it, and our country to the world's nations (to an extent). The word submission in the bible isn't used to indicate control or supremacy, it's used to delinate 'the source of' and is the key to a smooth functioning of family to prevent chaos. Nor is submission surrender and it certainly doesn't mean inferiority, because we all have equal value in God's eye. Rather submission is MUTUAL commitment and cooperation. If a woman doesn't want to submit to the structure of a marriage ... then she shouldn't marry and thus live alone.3Now I want you to realize that the head of every man is Christ, and the head of the woman is man, and the head of Christ is God.
I know cazza, I realized that. Keep hanging in there (moving over to your other thread now as I want to address something).cazza said:You are right Rainyday, I have barely scratched the surface regarding reading/Studying the bible. I think I am a little bitter at the moment.
Ah, but you misunderstand. I wasn't questioning the bible, but what *YOU* say it says. I'm trying to get you to look at what you perceive the bible says, and perhaps question it yourself, you know? I mean, come on, would a loving God really say "Sorry, abusive spouse? Stay with them. I command it."?desi said:You're arguing with me when I've only echoed Jesus's written words which do not appear to permit a woman to leave her husband. If you do not agree with what Jesus says I don't know what to say. You could add another book to the Bible if you feel so inspired or you could look at what happens in an abusive relationship when it continues, when the abuser is prosecuted or dealt with by inlaws, and when the relationship is terminated and the people move on. God's wisdom is not always secular common sense as many people seem to believe, this is evidenced by many of you questioning God's word. Instead of looking deeper you condemn me, a nobody spouting scripture on the internet.
It is as the Bible says, not as I say. Again look beyond what you feel and what appears obvious but in conflict with the Bible. The earth is not flat and much of life is invisible and if a woman leaves an abusive man, what happens next for both of them and any children involved?
Actually, and I know this is slightly off-topic, and should be addressed somewhere else, but I can say that's a common mistake people make is closing their eyes for a short period of time and saying that they, indeed, know what it's like to be blind. My point in mentioning this this is that you're right, you don't know what it's like unless you've been there.mlukas said:Desi, I don't quite understand what you mean by "where you are coming from" in regards to women leaving their husbands.
My wife left me, and admittantly, we had problems. But, they were problems that, at the time COULD BE FIXED!! And I was more than willing to work on them.
Now, it's all under the bridge really BUT...
I believe as you believe, but with some variations.
I think adultery is a more than legitimate reason for one to divorce, however, looking at the NATURE of God and his CHARACTER as revealed through the Bible, I find it impossible to believe that he would want anyone to stay in a situation where they are being abused, beaten, and otherwise denigrated on a consistant basis. If a man or woman leaves for those reasons, I really don't see any problem. Pragmatically or biblically.
I am glad you have been married for so long, I was married for 11 years before my ex decieded to have an affair and leave me. I pray with every fiber in my being it doesn't happen to you. As the old cliche goes, "No one ever thinks it will happen to them"
But I digress...
I felt for years with my Ex that she could care less if I lived or died, truly. We went to counseling for a while, and it helped, for a time. She decieded somwhere down the line that she no longer wanted to work on things, I, however did. But again, there's that problem of free will I could not force her to stay.
I appreciated your advice on one of my posts (Divorce, dating, and finances..) but you seem a bit judgemental of the situations people encounter.
Bad things happen in life. People leave, others do evil things to others, and I don't think that God would want people staying in a situation where they are constantly made to feel worthless, like I was.
The sick and twisted part of this is that my life is actually much better, and if I had to choose between living the way I was with my ex until the day I die or the situation I am in now, I choose the situation I am in now. Fact is, I am glad she divorced me. At the time it sucked, but looking back and given the choice I just layed out, I am the better Christian, Man, and Father for all of it.
Desi, it's hard for you to understand because, thankfully, it hasn't happened to you. And, the only way to truly relate to it is if, God forbid, it happens to you. It's like closing your eyes for 10 minutes then saying you know what it's like to be blind.
It sounds like you have a wonderful marraige, I truly hope so. I hope you will never know the pain of feeling worthless, unwanted, a ghost, an afterthought. I can see why ANYONE if they had made EVERY concevialbe effort to save their marriage, would leave given those curcumstances. I lived it.
jaspen, it's 1 Corinthians 7:10-11 and in it's entirety it reads:jaspen said:Okay, I understand the lousy leader thing...I was one of them. However, Desi is right. 1 Cor. 7 tells us that if the wife separates, not divorce, is to not marry again, but the only option is reconciliation. I believe this to be true for the husband as well. God is very clear on this. We, as Christian's today, try to make the Bible fit the way we want to live, not us live the way the Bible wants us too.
Now, that just means that if she does, she must remain unmarried. She has no other options other than to be reconciled to her husband in this verse.10To the married I give this command (not I, but the Lord): A wife must not separate from her husband. 11But if she does, she must remain unmarried or else be reconciled to her husband. And a husband must not divorce his wife.
1 Corinthians 7:10 is the command from the Lord for wives not to leave their husbands. The 'if' you quoted which follows was for people who defied the command in their ignorance. Remember Corinthians was letters to these people on how to behave, they were new in the word. Some of them were already separated, it was too late for them not to leave their husbands.rainyday said:Ah don't give her that BS ... there's no bad translation! How about YOU pull ME the quote, verse and chapter, where it states that a woman MUST stay put. Come on ... MUST STAY IN A MARRIAGE! It's not there desi. Nope, no translation bub.
There is no direct quote. Only that 'IF' a woman divorces her husband and marries another ... implying adultery in such incidents. Actually, it's giving guidance to those who DO divorce about what they can and cannot do following the divorce. So, if the wife DOES divorce her husband and remains celibate ... she has NOT gone against the bible.
Each of the above quotes implies God's hate for divorce, but also incorporates the word 'IF' ... then gives instructions what can and cannot be done following a divorce. If you need me to pull it out of whatever other translation you're reading ... let me know, I WILL DO IT!
Peter 3:1 tells wives to fit in with their husband's plans and be respectful so they will be won over by your respectful treatment of them. A woman initiating separation would seem at odds to Peter 3:1. Genesis 3:16 is where God is damning the snake and reaming man and woman. In doing this he tells woman she is to experience painful child birth and shall welcome her husbands affections and he shall be her master. Does one defy their master; should we defy our master?rainyday said:Also, to use one of your favorite words, 'DEFY' ... show me in the bible where its stated that a wife must never 'DEFY' her husband.
You seem comfortable in condemning me which I'll accept as it may have been foolish of me to start this topic. I'm an easy target for criticism. Since you wanted scripture, you have it.rainyday said:Oh, and I wasn't referring to Jesus desi as you well know ... just you. You can play with words, it doesn't bother me nor does it obstruct those reading these threads from the fact that you're not solidly defending your stand, simply responding in a childish mocking manner. If the shoe fits, AND IT DOES, wear it!
The kids acted up when I was away, not so much when I spent time with them. The harder separation was on her the better marriage looked to her. My kids are better off now for me having done what I did. It could have failed, granted, but it didn't.mlukas said:Desi,
fortunatly for you, that strategy worked. I can't really see the sense in you not seeing your kids, though. They had nothing to do with the poor decisions of your wife, as mine did not. But, as I've said, water under the bridge.
You're right. Counseling can be beneficial, but not how it is usually done. For counseling to work it must be done by people qualified to do it, people who have been married a long time and are familiar with the couple in trouble. In my case a couple from church took an interest in us and helped a bit to work things out. The counselor I gave up on was on her second marriage suggesting we use "I feel..." statements. So... I fired her!mlukas said:Just for the record, I never groveled. I'm not stupid, groveling and begging in any human relationship leads to annoyance and disdain quicker than guilting someone into something. I knew she would have to come to the conclusion on her own, and I moved out and gave her that space. Again, free will, she decieded to leave. What am I going to do, put a gun to her head and force her to be married to me?
I did everything in my power to keep it together but, again, bad things happen, people have free will and (YES!) there ARE actually people out there that really don't care about consequences, the Bible, God, etc.
And counseling, if it's done right, I don't think emasculates men. Bad counseling with some femi-nazi counselor, YES, definatly, it happens all the time. But to get someone to mediate when you can't see the forest through the trees, I can't see how you would consider that bad.
mlukas said:Also, are you proposing that EVERYTHING you did in your marriage up to when your wife wanted a divorce was PERFECT? We all have flaws, and if your wife left you for a time I find it hard to believe that you didn't have something to do with it. I'd be a liar if I said (as I stated in my last post) I was TOTALLY in the right, the perfect husband, etc.
Are you saying that you didn't have to change ANYTHING about the way you acted in the marriage and it was all just the wayward, blind wifes problem? If that is so, I think that line of thought is extremally naive and self decieving. "If we say that we have no sin, we have made Him a liar..." as the Bible says.
I'm not trying to provoke you, but just asking some legitimate questions.
M
You can read my reply to Rainyday and see what I say my Bible says; compare it to yours, and question the source if you care to.Bartimaeus said:Ah, but you misunderstand. I wasn't questioning the bible, but what *YOU* say it says. I'm trying to get you to look at what you perceive the bible says, and perhaps question it yourself, you know?
I never said he did.Bartimaeus said:I mean, come on, would a loving God really say "Sorry, abusive spouse? Stay with them. I command it."?
Wonder why the Bible condemns divorce almost without exception. Could it be God is not interested in circumstances or excuses?Warrior Poet said:The sad part here is that the presumtion of the question is set not knowing the circumstances of the divorce(s), they are all unique just like those involved, its only fair to treat them as such.
Rape, murder, and you name it else should not be an option, but it is. For us to look the other way when people defy God's word amounts to winking at sin which is condemned in Proverbs. Its not a popular line to hold. It will not get you lots of blessings or reputation here, but it is God's word.Warrior Poet said:Agreed divorce shouldn't ever be an option, but it is.
By my count Christian women by a large margin initiate separation in my personal experience and around here.Warrior Poet said:I have spent time on this forum long enough to know the the initiation is 50/50.
That's it. Misapply a general rule to a specific situation. Separation and or divorce is not a Biblical act of love in any case. I challenge you to name one exception. Or better yet, quote a verse of scripture where a woman is granted permission by God to leave her husband- I've offered several to the contrary only to be ridiculed.Warrior Poet said:Christian women are equal in life and in marriage (you can spout the different roles to me all day, they are still equal) In that instance rules apply to both parties. I believe the Commandment is "Love thy neighbor" Thats God, reiterated by Christ many times, he never says "Men love thy neighbor" So why is it assumed that this applies to women as well, there where no specifics given, right?. This, in the case of the argument presented, means this commandment doesnt apply to either gender, if you want to be literal about it.
The Bible does assign men and women different roles in marriage. I don't know why women think such things are sexist?Warrior Poet said:The Bible isnt sexist, the people reading it and not understanding there is no bias meant, wont get that.
Are you suggesting the Bible cannot be gender specific?Warrior Poet said:If Jesus is telling me that I can be put on a level playing field with a murderer who repeants and means it, same guy who walks with the unclean and with me viewing us with the same eyes and loving us with the same heart and commands me to do the same, but sit here and say, these certain rules only apply to men, seems to be a personal opinion more then anything else.
When a role is assigned by God it becomes a rule by default.Warrior Poet said:Differnt roles yes, different rules no.
Where is equality among the sexes mentioned in the Bible? You've managed to make a long post spouting politically correct nonsense without mentioning one Biblical principle, actually you've ignored a few . Answering this post makes me feel like I'm at General Apologetics arguing against an Atheist about Rational Humanitarianism.Warrior Poet said:If we start picking and choosing what can apply to one and not the other Christianity as a whole becomes another "religion" where equality is something that doesn't even exist.Thats not Christianity, equality is a large part of seperates "the men from the boys" in the religious arena. Woman dont forefit there biblical laws/rules and duties once married. Jesus never said anything of the sort.
There is nothing wrong with the the translation people are using, the problem is where that persons heart is while they read it.
Warrior Poet
You may as well have said he did, though. You keep saying there are no exceptions. Yet, when asked about abuse, you keep going back to "Only in cases of adultery", and wondering why we would question. Hmmm, could it be because you haven't answered?desi said:You can read my reply to Rainyday and see what I say my Bible says; compare it to yours, and question the source if you care to.
I never said he did.
Desi, you said:desi said:Wonder why the Bible condemns divorce almost without exception. Could it be God is not interested in circumstances or excuses?
Rape, murder, and you name it else should not be an option, but it is. For us to look the other way when people defy God's word amounts to winking at sin which is condemned in Proverbs. Its not a popular line to hold. It will not get you lots of blessings or reputation here, but it is God's word.
By my count Christian women by a large margin initiate separation in my personal experience and around here.
That's it. Misapply a general rule to a specific situation. Separation and or divorce is not a Biblical act of love in any case. I challenge you to name one exception. Or better yet, quote a verse of scripture where a woman is granted permission by God to leave her husband- I've offered several to the contrary only to be ridiculed.
The Bible does assign men and women different roles in marriage. I don't know why women think such things are sexist?
Are you suggesting the Bible cannot be gender specific?
When a role is assigned by God it becomes a rule by default.
Where is equality among the sexes mentioned in the Bible? You've managed to make a long post spouting politically correct nonsense without mentioning one Biblical principle, actually you've ignored a few . Answering this post makes me feel like I'm at General Apologetics arguing against an Atheist about Rational Humanitarianism.
Wonder why the Bible condemns divorce almost without exception. Could it be God is not interested in circumstances or excuses?
desi said:Wonder why the Bible condemns divorce almost without exception.
desi said:Could it be God is not interested in circumstances or excuses?
desi said:Rape, murder, and you name it else should not be an option, but it is. For us to look the other way when people defy God's word amounts to winking at sin which is condemned in Proverbs. Its not a popular line to hold. It will not get you lots of blessings or reputation here, but it is God's word.
desi said:By my count Christian women by a large margin initiate separation in my personal experience and around here.
desi said:That's it. Misapply a general rule to a specific situation. Separation and or divorce is not a Biblical act of love in any case. I challenge you to name one exception. Or better yet, quote a verse of scripture where a woman is granted permission by God to leave her husband- I've offered several to the contrary only to be ridiculed.
desi said:The Bible does assign men and women different roles in marriage. I don't know why women think such things are sexist?
desi said:Are you suggesting the Bible cannot be gender specific?
desi said:When a role is assigned by God it becomes a rule by default.
desi said:Where is equality among the sexes mentioned in the Bible? You've managed to make a long post spouting politically correct nonsense without mentioning one Biblical principle, actually you've ignored a few . Answering this post makes me feel like I'm at General Apologetics arguing against an Atheist about Rational Humanitarianism.