Why is Suicide Wrong

Introverted1293 · Jul 24, 2018

There are people who are happy and healthy; and they just enjoy life. But there are people who suffer a lot in this life. There are people who are disabled and they see the people who are not disable being able to do stuff that they cannot do. It makes them want to kill themselves. And some people deal with actual pain, not emotional, but physical pain. Why can't they just end it all?

Sometimes it seems unfair to say that it is wrong to kill yourself, for those who are actually suffering. (Just to let you know, this is not me).

I watched a video on 9/11 attack, and people were jumping out of the windows. These people were going to die anyways. Then I watched a family who talked about their son. This was a Catholic family. They were talking about an unknown man who jumped out of the building, but they couldn't tell if it was their son or not. The picture was blurry. But you can tell that he was a cook just like their son by the clothes he was wearing. But they were pretty sure that it was not the son. They were saying that he knew not to commit suicide, for it is a sin against God. They were disappointed that anyone would even ask if that was their son. That was the only reason why the believe he wasn't their son. They couldn't tell by the picture. It was a little blurry, but you can clearly see what clothes he had on.

So, the question is, would they be disappointed if that was their son? Why would God tell someone that they have to suffer through the pain?

This guy was in a burning hot building, and breathing all this smoke. Do you know what that is like? Well, I'm sure you do. But it hurts your lungs. Why wouldn't he jump to alleviate the suffering? Sometimes suicide is the only option.

2tim_215 · Jul 24, 2018

General answer: Suicide is murder.

Doug Melven · Jul 24, 2018

Suicide is the ultimate act of self-worship.
As long as you are alive you have hope, once you end your life hope is gone.
Man will tell people that there is no hope of recovery or living without pain.
God is a pain-taker.

Nobody should commit suicide, because with God there is always hope. Even if He doesn't take the pain away, some people won't let Him, He gives the strength to endure the pain.

teresa · Jul 24, 2018

Introverted1293 said:
There are people who are disabled and they see the people who are not disable being able to do stuff that they cannot do.

To address this part of the OP, sometimes, a move to a better area with mass transit can change ones view point or perspective. Otherwise, feeling stagnant can contribute greatly to ones depression and despair.

A fresh start can profoundly change ones quality of life.

Transportation can add a richer quality to ones life, as one can get to various support groups and can participate in life through more opportunities to work or to volunteer, even be mentored.

When one feels needed and wanted, and has a sense of purpose, life is so much better.

Brightmoon · Jul 24, 2018

Got into an argument with someone right after 911 over the same issue . It takes about 10 seconds to fall from that height and you die so fast your nerves don’t have time to feel the pain. Versus taking up to 20 minutes to burn to death . That’s not suicide that’s choosing to die painlessly and quickly instead of slowly and in agony

2tim_215 · Jul 24, 2018

Dr. Kevorkian is in jail, fortunately.

teresa · Jul 24, 2018

Jesse your life is worthwhile, brother in Christ.

I love you and Jesus loves you and God made you!

hang in there, read gods word, study scripture, watch a youtube video, send pms, ask for prayer

teresa · Jul 24, 2018

Doug Melven said:
Suicide is the ultimate act of self-worship.
As long as you are alive you have hope, once you end your life hope is gone.
Man will tell people that there is no hope of recovery or living without pain.
God is a pain-taker.

Nobody should commit suicide, because with God there is always hope. Even if He doesn't take the pain away, some people won't let Him, He gives the strength to endure the pain.

He gives strength to endure!

teresa · Jul 24, 2018

going to work now, ttyl and keep reaching out, love ya,

kat1

yeshuaslavejeff · Jul 24, 2018

Introverted1293 said:
Sometimes suicide is the only option.

This is false. Dying might be unavoidable (try avoiding dying for, let's say, 200 years) ...
But willingly murdering ones own self or anyone else is a deadly sin.

Willingly dying is not the same as suicide, btw. Yahweh knows the inner thoughts of the heart, and all the motives involved. He Judges Rightly.

yeshuaslavejeff · Jul 24, 2018

Brightmoon said:
Got into an argument with someone right after 911 over the same issue . It takes about 10 seconds to fall from that height and you die so fast your nerves don’t have time to feel the pain. Versus taking up to 20 minutes to burn to death . That’s not suicide that’s choosing to die painlessly and quickly instead of slowly and in agony

It may well still be suicide.

Southernscotty · Jul 24, 2018

Jesse, God has made you in His own image and likeness, God never makes mistakes friend. You are the way that you are for a reason, and you are very special to God, So let us reason here, You have a gift somewhere and somehow that you can use to glorify God, Tell me what is something that you like to do? What is your hobbies? What would you like to do??

2tim_215 · Jul 24, 2018

I don't know for sure if it were true or not but it was reported that when one of the buildings was collapsing during 911 a person actually slid down the building and survived. Person jumping out of windows during that tragic day may not have been attempting to commit suicide, maybe faced with the horrible circumstance they were facing, that was what they felt was their best alternative and who knows, maybe by some miracle they could have survived. If you believe in God's word, anything is possible. That's where faith comes in. As believers, we should never give up as there's always hope.

Sam91 · Jul 24, 2018

Introverted1293 said:
There are people who are happy and healthy; and they just enjoy life. But there are people who suffer a lot in this life. There are people who are disabled and they see the people who are not disable being able to do stuff that they cannot do. It makes them want to kill themselves. And some people deal with actual pain, not emotional, but physical pain. Why can't they just end it all?

Sometimes it seems unfair to say that it is wrong to kill yourself, for those who are actually suffering. (Just to let you know, this is not me).

I watched a video on 9/11 attack, and people were jumping out of the windows. These people were going to die anyways. Then I watched a family who talked about their son. This was a Catholic family. They were talking about an unknown man who jumped out of the building, but they couldn't tell if it was their son or not. The picture was blurry. But you can tell that he was a cook just like their son by the clothes he was wearing. But they were pretty sure that it was not the son. They were saying that he knew not to commit suicide, for it is a sin against God. They were disappointed that anyone would even ask if that was their son. That was the only reason why the believe he wasn't their son. They couldn't tell by the picture. It was a little blurry, but you can clearly see what clothes he had on.

So, the question is, would they be disappointed if that was their son? Why would God tell someone that they have to suffer through the pain?

This guy was in a burning hot building, and breathing all this smoke. Do you know what that is like? Well, I'm sure you do. But it hurts your lungs. Why wouldn't he jump to alleviate the suffering? Sometimes suicide is the only option.

I do not see jumping from a burning building as suicide. It could be classed as a natural response to escape, even if it means certain death.

I think it is a reaction to a crisis, not the person wanting to end their life.

Dave-W · Jul 24, 2018

Introverted1293 said:
This guy was in a burning hot building, and breathing all this smoke. Do you know what that is like? Well, I'm sure you do. But it hurts your lungs. Why wouldn't he jump to alleviate the suffering? Sometimes suicide is the only option.

Jump out of a burning building right into Hell fire. 1000 times hotter. More acrid (sulfur) smoke.

Not a wise choice.

.Mikha'el. · Jul 24, 2018

Introverted1293 said:
There are people who are happy and healthy; and they just enjoy life. But there are people who suffer a lot in this life. There are people who are disabled and they see the people who are not disable being able to do stuff that they cannot do. It makes them want to kill themselves. And some people deal with actual pain, not emotional, but physical pain. Why can't they just end it all?

Sometimes it seems unfair to say that it is wrong to kill yourself, for those who are actually suffering. (Just to let you know, this is not me).

I watched a video on 9/11 attack, and people were jumping out of the windows. These people were going to die anyways. Then I watched a family who talked about their son. This was a Catholic family. They were talking about an unknown man who jumped out of the building, but they couldn't tell if it was their son or not. The picture was blurry. But you can tell that he was a cook just like their son by the clothes he was wearing. But they were pretty sure that it was not the son. They were saying that he knew not to commit suicide, for it is a sin against God. They were disappointed that anyone would even ask if that was their son. That was the only reason why the believe he wasn't their son. They couldn't tell by the picture. It was a little blurry, but you can clearly see what clothes he had on.

So, the question is, would they be disappointed if that was their son? Why would God tell someone that they have to suffer through the pain?

This guy was in a burning hot building, and breathing all this smoke. Do you know what that is like? Well, I'm sure you do. But it hurts your lungs. Why wouldn't he jump to alleviate the suffering? Sometimes suicide is the only option.

I disagree with suicide because it's unproductive. It robs a suffering person of any opportunity for the pain to ease and life to get better. While it's an automatic end to suffering, it's of no value because the person's not around to experience the relief that comes from it.

Sam91 · Jul 24, 2018

Dave-W said:
Jump out of a burning building right into Hell fire. 1000 times hotter. More acrid (sulfur) smoke.

Not a wise choice.

It isn't a choice though. You can hardly stay in an inferno unless you can't get out. We are hardwired to try to survive.

2tim_215 · Jul 24, 2018

I'd have to say that intentional suicide in some ways is the cowardly way out.

Southernscotty · Jul 24, 2018

I am sorry Jessie but I misread your post. [That will teach me to put the cart before the horse]
You have good advice above so I will just say God bless and I am relieved that you were not speaking of you.

Brightmoon · Jul 24, 2018

2tim_215 said:
I'd have to say that intentional suicide in some ways is the cowardly way out.

The next time you iron some clothes or cook, stick your hand on the hottest part. And note that you’ll react before you can think . I’m quite sure those jumpers waited until they couldn’t take it any more.

As I’ve stated, I live in NYC . A building caught fire next to the LIRR train tracks near Jamaica station . Eight tracks and we were on track 1 completely away from the side the fire was on. Every one on that side of the train got up and moved to the other side because the side facing the fire was so hot. I no longer think fires are like they show in the movies.

(Because I live here I couldn’t watch those 9-11 videos for over 10 years . You could see and smell the world trade building burning from that same LIRR train station in Jamaica, Queens . Look on a map to see how far away that is)

We hope the site problems here are now solved, however, if you still have any issues, please start a ticket in Contact Us

Why is Suicide Wrong

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Apes and humans are all in family Hominidae.

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

simple truth, martyr, disciple of Yahshua

simple truth, martyr, disciple of Yahshua

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Child of the Living God

Welcoming grandchild #7, Arturus Waggoner!

7x13=28

Child of the Living God

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Apes and humans are all in family Hominidae.

Similar threads

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency