May I suggest that you read
THIS and reall
all of it.
Very thoroughly and with an open, receptive mind and heart.
Thank you and God Bless!
Oki, I read it.. here is what I think.
I don't know if you are aware of this, but did you know that non believers make the same arguments against Christianity in general? For example, a while ago I saw this documentary on tv, about how the whole story of Christ is so 'similar' to 'pagan religions' especially Egyptian mythology?
What would you say to that?
So why the double standard?
Christian apologists have come up with several good explanations for this btw! About how these other religions are the devil's attempt to 'copy' the truth, or that they are sort of like 'prophesies' to prepare the world for the real thing, etc.
In this particular case....the 'sun' imagery is not particular to pagan religions. It was chosen here merely for symbolic value. Jesus is the light of the world, the bright morning star, etc. The sun is the brightest object that we can see, so it makes sense.
As for the rest of it, I'll just say....you know those people who see conspiracy theories in everything? I'm not saying you're one of them, but the author of the article might be. The thing is..if you seek something, you'll eventually find it - even if it's not there.
Also..frankly I find it ridiculous that they used Exo 20:4 as one of their arguments...that's very weak. Everyone knows that Catholics are not worshipping the monstrance LOLL. Or were they perhaps talking about the Eucharist itself? In that case... They might as well take the next logical step and deny the Incarnation, and become Gnostics!!
Lastly, I'd just like to say that God knows people's hearts, and He knows that Catholics are not worshipping the sun or the monstrance, but Him in the Eucharist! It's silly how they said "A Catholic cannot walk past this sun symbol without acknowledging it by kneeling and or making the sign of the cross with their hands."

it's not the monstrance they are kneeling to!! Then they admit this...but then make the (rather cheap) excuse that the host is ALSO a sun symbol because of some artwork.. well if Catholics have portrayed the host as the sun, why does that have to imply sun worship??? Why can't that simply be symbolic of Christ being the light of the world, etc?
Maybe we should all start believing that the sun represents darkness, just to be safe, and use another symbol for light. LOL.
Then in the end they say how...oh no Catholics worship the Eucharist, not God! lol..yea because..we believe that it's Christ's Body and Blood, duh =)
I believe in the Eucharist for several reasons.
One, it's taken right out of the Bible. The Catholics and the Orthodox take the passages literally...Protestants take them symbolically, but I don't know why. I think it's much easier to believe that Jesus meant it literally, like mostly everything else He said. "for my flesh is real food, and my blood is real drink".. and when people were shocked at this teaching and left, He didn't stop them saying "no wait guys I meant it as a metaphor!!" He let them leave. Why? And why does Paul say that by taking Communion unworthily, we are sinning against the very Body and Blood of the Lord?
Sola Scriptura alone supports the Eucharist.
But there's more
Every single church father I came across who said anything about the topic, interpreted Communion as being literal. Even Justin Martyr, who lived around 150 AD. We can safely assume that what the entire church believed in 150 AD is probably what the Apostles taught.
And finally, I have my own experience... One day, I felt God telling me that the Eucharist is real..and I know it wasn't just in my head, because it was a very deep, lasting conviction I got..and it didn't fade..and I really, really didn't want to accept it. In fact I cried when He first told me this LOL and resisted Him for a couple of weeks. Well I can't really deny that experience.. and when I began to take the Eucharist, I grew a lot closer to the Lord, and it is changing me for the better. The Bible says that you'll know everything by its fruits, and the fruits have been good.
so that's my reply to the article
God bless!
monica