Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
I wish I was good at making charts and graphs but I'm notI'll digest all of that and draw it out. I do better with diagrams than words alone, as I am a very much visual learner and not super great with pure text. Thanks for all the feedback though - it does help.
no, I do not. This thread is really not intended for that sort of discussion. The other thread I made, which you have been participated in is better suited - which it seems you are posting some charts over there as are you trying to put some clarity on the rapture views.Doug do you have a graph comparing pre-trib, mid-trib, pre-wrath and post-trib all from a Futurist POV?
I added your screen name to Pre-trib rapture, and to Dispensationalism.I am a
Free Grace (salvation), Grace Evangelical Society
Flat Earth (God's creation),
Pretribulation Rapture,
Dispensationalism Israelology
( What is Israelology? | GotQuestions.org )
https://www.amazon.com/ISRAELOLOGY-Missing-Link-Systematic-Theology/dp/1935174649
I am surprised all who claim a pre-trib rapture, do not claim that as the Second Coming.No.
Pre wrath is Covenant confirmed (peace treaty is an assumption, but that's not the actual language in Daniel 9), 3.5 years, Antichrist claims Deity, Great Tribulation begins (campaign of persecution similar to the Holocaust but worse, 5th seal), 6th seal cuts it short, Rapture, Wrath of God, Armageddon.
The other thing that needs to be understood is that for Pre Wrath, "the second coming" BEGINS with the rapture, it's not a singular event of Revelation 19, like the first coming isn't just Jesus' birth it's all the events from His birth until His ascension to heaven. The second coming begins with the rapture at the 6th seal, and Armageddon is just one event within the overall second coming. The Second Coming in fact, lasts eternally because Jesus will never be apart from us again when He appears in the clouds, we will ALWAYS be with Him, if He's in heaven we're in heaven, if He comes to earth we come with Him.
The thing that is crazy is that pretrib DON'T consider the rapture to be the second coming. Paul says outright in 1 Thessalonians 4
If the Lord descends from Heaven to meet us in the air, is that not His second coming?
The biggest (and first) error of prewrath is imagining that the cosmic signs at the 6th seal are the very same cosmic signs "after the tribulation of those days." The truth is, these are TWO different signs, for TWO different purposes and will be seen over 7 years apart.No.
mid trib means at the midpoint. the abomination of desolation takes place at the midpoint. the Great Tribulation takes place AFTER the abomination of desolation, and pre wrath observe the Olivet Discourse as containing rapture timing in it, in Matthew 24:29-31. That is after the Great Tribulation is the rapture... but it is also before the wrath of God. Specifically it's at the 6th seal where the signs Jesus gave with the darkening of the sun and moon take place. To us, that is the end of the Great Tribulation.
That last point deserves emphasis.
The Trumpets and Bowls, are not the Great Tribulation.
Both Pre Trib, and Post Trib, see the Trumpets and Bowls as part of the Great Tribulation.
Jesus said nothing about trumpets and bowls as signs of His coming, and gave the sign of the sun and moon darkening AFTER the tribulation of those days. IMMEDIATELY after for emphasis.
The Sun and Moon darken at the 6th seal, the 5th seal, is the Great Tribulation.
The other thing that should be emphasized, is that you should question your interpretation of Revelation, because in the book, the Mark of the Beast, one of THE things most associated with the Great Tribulation, is in chapter 13, while the 6th seal is in Chapter 6, and Jesus said that the darkening of the sun and moon came after the Tribulations.
If you hold to a Chronological order of Revelation, you may want to rethink that.
Mid Trib also does not separate "Great Tribulation" from the Wrath of God.
It is the key understanding of Pre-Wrath rapture to separate them. The Wrath of God and Great Tribulation are not the same thing and they don't start at the first seal. The Wrath of God begins at Revelation 6:17.
Pre Wrath shares some of the "we don't know when it'll be" characteristic of Pre Trib, where Mid Trib and Post Trib can effectively date set by knowing Daniel and Revelation very well because they give specific time markers.
Pre Trib obviously sets it before any of the events of the 70th week of Daniel but doesn't know when, and they dispute about whether it's JUST before the "7 year tribulation" (such an unbiblical term) or it can even have a gap between the rapture and the start of the "7 year tribulation"
Pre Wrath.. means it's sometime after the midpoint, and some time before Armageddon, leaving a ~3 year window (5th trumpet takes 5 months so it's at least that far back before Armageddon) where we don't know when it'll be, keeping it consistent with Matthew 24:36.
Pre Trib has the doctrine of immanency. Pre wrath has immanency but it only becomes imminent after the abomination of desolation, because that's the sign Jesus and Paul gave in Matthew 24, and 2 Thessalonians 2.
Pre-wrath is actually short for "Post Trib, Pre Wrath"
the Great Tribulation takes place AFTER the abomination of desolation,
Futurist seems like an oversimplification.Grand experiment.
Because there are so many posters here, which it is sometimes hard to keep track of each persons fundamental position(s), especially when discussing. I am going to try on a voluntary basis, for each of you to fit yourself under each of these categories. Yourself only and not what you think someone else is.
In your post, please keep it simple by saying....for example.... furturist, pre-trib
That's all I need. Thanks.
Make a post, and I will add your screen-name alphabetically in each category. If there are some categories I left out - let me know.
Amil
Christian Gedge
Dave L
Hank77
Hazelelponi
Jipsah
JM
kdm1984
mkgal1
soverigngrace
Spiritual Jew
TribulationSigns
Anytime rapture
Douggg
TribulationSigns
Covenant Theology
claninja
grafted branch
Hazelelponi
mkgal1
nonaeroterraqueous
soverigngrace
TribulatonSigns
Dispensationalism
christiansoccerplayer
d taylor
Michael Collum
nolidad
Rachel20
Futurist
christiansoccerplayer
Douggg
Handmaid for Jesus
jamdoc
jeffwhosoever
JIMINZ
Marilyn C
Historicist
Christian Gedge
Cshuffle777
JM
Saint John
StephenDiscipleofYHWH
Idealism (of Christian Eschatology)
soverigngrace
Spiritual Jew
Mid-trib rapture
New Covenant Theology
ChristianGirl_96
Christian Gedge
Hank77
No rapture (traditional)
keras
Llleopard
Michael Collum
Non-dispensationalist
Cshuffle777
Douggg
Hazelelponi
jamdoc
mkgal1
nonaeroterraqueous
soverigngrace
Spiritual Jew
TribulationSigns
Partial Preterism
claninja
grafted beanch
Gundy22
Jipsah
Josheb
Maria Billingsley
mkgal1
parousia70
Postmillennialism
JM
Post-trib rapture
Christian Gedge
DavidPT
ewq1938
soverigngrace
Spiritual Jew
StephenDiscipleofYHWH
TribulationSigns
Pre-mil
christiansoccerplayer
Cshuffle777
DavidPT
Douggg
ewq1938
Handmaid for Jesus
jamdoc
jeffwhosoever
iamlamad
Marilyn C
nolidad
Rachel20
Rebecca4Christ
Timtofly
Pre-trib rapture
christiansoccerplayer
d taylor
Handmaid for Jesus
iamlamad
JustRachel
Marilyn C
nolidad
Rachel20
Pre-wrath rapture
Deep Truth
jamdoc
Rebecca4Christ
Recapitulation Theory
Christian Gedge
Dave L
soverigngrace
Spiritual Jew
Sabbatarian
Cshuffle777
Not sure if I fit some of these categories or not but here are my beliefs.Grand experiment.
Because there are so many posters here, which it is sometimes hard to keep track of each persons fundamental position(s), especially when discussing. I am going to try on a voluntary basis, for each of you to fit yourself under each of these categories. Yourself only and not what you think someone else is.
In your post, please keep it simple by saying....for example.... furturist, pre-trib
That's all I need. Thanks.
Make a post, and I will add your screen-name alphabetically in each category. If there are some categories I left out - let me know.
Amil
Christian Gedge
Dave L
Hank77
Hazelelponi
Jipsah
JM
kdm1984
mkgal1
soverigngrace
Spiritual Jew
TribulationSigns
Anytime rapture
Douggg
TribulationSigns
Covenant Theology
claninja
grafted branch
Hazelelponi
mkgal1
nonaeroterraqueous
soverigngrace
TribulatonSigns
Dispensationalism
christiansoccerplayer
d taylor
Michael Collum
nolidad
Rachel20
Futurist
christiansoccerplayer
Douggg
Handmaid for Jesus
jamdoc
jeffwhosoever
JIMINZ
Marilyn C
Historicist
Christian Gedge
Cshuffle777
JM
Saint John
StephenDiscipleofYHWH
Idealism (of Christian Eschatology)
soverigngrace
Spiritual Jew
Mid-trib rapture
New Covenant Theology
ChristianGirl_96
Christian Gedge
Hank77
No rapture (traditional)
keras
Llleopard
Michael Collum
Non-dispensationalist
Cshuffle777
Douggg
Hazelelponi
jamdoc
mkgal1
nonaeroterraqueous
soverigngrace
Spiritual Jew
TribulationSigns
Partial Preterism
claninja
grafted beanch
Gundy22
Jipsah
Josheb
Maria Billingsley
mkgal1
parousia70
Postmillennialism
JM
Post-trib rapture
Christian Gedge
DavidPT
ewq1938
soverigngrace
Spiritual Jew
StephenDiscipleofYHWH
TribulationSigns
Pre-mil
christiansoccerplayer
Cshuffle777
DavidPT
Douggg
ewq1938
Handmaid for Jesus
jamdoc
jeffwhosoever
iamlamad
Marilyn C
nolidad
Rachel20
Rebecca4Christ
Timtofly
Pre-trib rapture
christiansoccerplayer
d taylor
Handmaid for Jesus
iamlamad
JustRachel
Marilyn C
nolidad
Rachel20
Pre-wrath rapture
Deep Truth
jamdoc
Rebecca4Christ
Recapitulation Theory
Christian Gedge
Dave L
soverigngrace
Spiritual Jew
Sabbatarian
Cshuffle777
okay, Bob. I won't put you under any of the categories. Thanks for sharing.Not sure if I fit some of these categories or not but here are my beliefs.
I believe in the millennium but I believe it is the life time of a believer. while here on earth.
I don't believe in any rapture.
I don't know what covenant theology is even after Googling it.
I'm not dispensationalist nor futurist, nor Historist, nor partial preterist.
Yes I think I fit the no rapture for sure.okay, Bob. I won't put you under any of the categories. Thanks for sharing.
I have one category as "no rapture (traditional)". Would you like for me to list your screen name under that one?
btw, you can browse through the list in the first post - and kinda see where a lot of the other posters here stand. It is often helpful in discussions.
Personally, I put some of the information about myself under my screen-name avatar, to inform others who I might be discussing with or reading my posts.
Okay, done. Thanks for participating Bob.Yes I think I fit the no rapture for sure.
I believe in mid-tribulation.
Like actual midpoint of the 70th week?
could you explain why and what scriptures you use? I've just never heard of someone who was actual midpoint rapture before and am curious how they come to that position.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?