A friend of mine asked this question..... Where did God learn how to forgive if He never had reason to forgive before? Thoughts?
Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
Stormy,A friend of mine asked this question..... Where did God learn how to forgive if He never had reason to forgive before? Thoughts?
Did you really mean to indicate Jesus as having life in the past tense as you wrote? Or that Jesus is only 2000 years old?Jesus of Nazareth, the man who lived 2000 years past
A friend of mine asked this question..... Where did God learn how to forgive if He never had reason to forgive before? Thoughts?
A friend of mine asked this question..... Where did God learn how to forgive if He never had reason to forgive before? Thoughts?
God never learned anything. He already IS. Forgiveness, and the grace and mercy that prompts it are part of Who He is. It's part of His inecxplicable character.
Does God then forgive his enemies as he has asked us to do to ours?Did God learn how to forgive, or is forgiveness inherent to His character? My thought would be the latter.
Stormy,Does God then forgive his enemies as he has asked us to do to ours?
Does God then forgive his enemies as he has asked us to do to ours?
A friend of mine asked this question..... Where did God learn how to forgive if He never had reason to forgive before? Thoughts?
I think, yes, God forgives His enemies. But what does forgiveness mean? God defines it as follows: "But I say unto you, Love your enemies, bless them that curse you, do good to them that hate you, and pray for them which despitefully use you, and persecute you. That ye may be the children of your Father which is in heaven: for he maketh his sun to rise on the evil and on the good, and sendeth rain on the just and on the unjust....Be ye therefore perfect, even as your Father which is in heaven is perfect." Matthew 5:44,45,48.
Which brings another question to mind, Stormy: Does forgiveness involve bringing someone back into your life who does NOT want to be in your life?
If forgiveness involves restoration, and what is being restored is a relationship... then I would say yes it does.... On a cosmic scale I don't know of anyone who after knowing all the facts would choose destruction.... so then if a person, after their encounter with God understands what is at stake, I think they would choose life... I believe that those people that some say are hell-bound just don't have all the info... and when they do, they will decide to live...
Since God is the Creator and sustainer of all life, we can never be unplugged from Him.... Outside of God life ceases to exist, that is what I believe... As for the sacrifice of Christ, that's a whole different discussion....I don't think God had to learn to forgive. God is love, and forgiveness is an inherent part of love, so as soon as a situation arose where forgiveness was needed, God was ready to forgive.
God's forgiveness, though, apparently involves more than just saying, "Okay, I forgive you, come on back." A physical law of the universe went into operation when man unplugged himself from the source of life. Science and physics took over and God worked within His own laws to make a way back for us. That process involved laying down His own life and taking it back up again, in order to create a path back for lost mankind.
Why did God have to die in order to save us? I don't understand the physics of the universe enough to understand such a drastic remedy. But I'm sure it would make a fascinating study. Thoughts?
Laodicean,I think, yes, God forgives His enemies. But what does forgiveness mean? God defines it as follows: "But I say unto you, Love your enemies, bless them that curse you, do good to them that hate you, and pray for them which despitefully use you, and persecute you. That ye may be the children of your Father which is in heaven: for he maketh his sun to rise on the evil and on the good, and sendeth rain on the just and on the unjust....Be ye therefore perfect, even as your Father which is in heaven is perfect." Matthew 5:44,45,48.
Which brings another question to mind, Stormy: Does forgiveness involve bringing someone back into your life who does NOT want to be in your life?
I think Satan is the ultimate prodigal son, and no I don't think any being that has been created by God knows all the facts... likewise I believe that a God who exists outside of time and eternity has no problem waiting for his created beings to understand.... be it 100 yrs, 1000 yrs, or a million yrs.... time is a non-issue for God, and if he knows that after 20,000 yrs his created beings will have a "lightbulb moment" I believe he'll wait 20k yrs...Originally Posted by Laodicean
Which brings another question to mind, Stormy: Does forgiveness involve bringing someone back into your life who does NOT want to be in your life?
You've triggered two more questions for me:
1. Do you think satan knows all the facts?
2. Is it possible to restore a relationship in which one party is no longer interested?
Whether all the facts are known or not, what if it's a case in which a person has lost interest in the relationship? I mean, that does happen, and often. A person can know that their ex-husband or ex-wife still loves them to death, but they have just plain lost interest. Can such a relationship be restored?
Since God is the Creator and sustainer of all life, we can never be unplugged from Him.... Outside of God life ceases to exist, that is what I believe... As for the sacrifice of Christ, that's a whole different discussion....
I think Satan is the ultimate prodigal son, and no I don't think any being that has been created by God knows all the facts...
likewise I believe that a God who exists outside of time and eternity has no problem waiting for his created beings to understand.... be it 100 yrs, 1000 yrs, or a million yrs.... time is a non-issue for God, and if he knows that after 20,000 yrs his created beings will have a "lightbulb moment" I believe he'll wait 20k yrs...
Is it possible to restore a relationship when someone does not want to? Sure from a human standpoint,
but we aren't talking about humans... We are talking about God in relationship to all that he has created.... for that situation my comments above apply... but that's just how I see it....
isn't being "outside of God" the same as being "unplugged" from Him? When I unplug an appliance, I have placed it outside of the flow of electricity. Maybe I didn't understand what you said.
We are not lost... God knows exactly where we are, and we have never left the place we were created, i.e. earth.... We don't know everything, so the question is what will God do... As a parent, I know what I do when my child makes a decision without having all the facts... I think the Infinite Ruler of all is much wiser than I, so its His call...Does that mean that if we are lost, it's not our fault, since we can't know all the facts? And if satan is the ultimate prodigal son, do you think he will return to God? And if he doesn't return, and if he gets burned up in the lake of fire, will it be God's fault that this happens?
We don't know that.... or let me say I don't know that they died refusing to believe in God... and if they did, again, I believe he will take into consideration what they knew, and how it played out in their living.....Okay. So what about those who have already died without having a chance to know all the facts and who, with what facts they did have in hand, have refused to believe in God? Will they, after millions of years, have another chance to be brought back to learn all the facts?
Well, if God knows that humanity will eventually come to him, then it is possible that no one will be lost... There is a text that says God is not willing that any should perish.... so the question is how determined he is to make sure no one does....It sounds to me as if you are saying that no one will be lost. Am I right in that conclusion? And if so, what is your basis, scriptural or otherwise, for holding this position?
What I attempted to say is with human interactions there are times when a relationship cannot be restored. However, we are talking about God, and a different set of rules apply I think...What examples do you have of human relationships being restored when one or the other does not want to return to the relationship? Or maybe I misunderstood what you said, the way you phrased it?
Fault suggests that there must be someone to blame, which is negative.... however it is God's "fault" that we were created... I think a better word would be responsible.... God is responsible for everything that is created, so I think he will take his responsibility seriously ensuring that His relationship with those beings he created will be restored...So if any of us are lost, it would be God's fault? Since I'm fairly sure that you don't believe that God can be at fault, then maybe your position is that all will eventually be saved, right?