Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
If you know what it is you believe and why, you've done philosophy.
If you've done this without knowing that you're doing philosophy, you've probably done it poorly and should consider doing it over.
No thanks, it's not important to understand psycho/philosophical mumblings. Who cares!!!
That is what the Greeks used to do, sit around and psychoanalyze philosophical nonsensical, babble stuff. Boring beyond belief!!!!! My interest is in TRUTH.
It makes no sense to me to start off with nothing and to try and explain existence when we know that there is something that we know exists.
I don't think it is a proper question to ask for a cause of existence. The question denies the primacy of existence. Existence exists and we know it. It doesn't need an explanation. It simply is and it could not have been otherwise.
Or it's like creationists disbelieving tons of mounting evidence that supports the theory of evolution. You are right. lol
I agree completely.
Some people not only can't handle the truth, they manufacture their own truth.
Can't handle the fact that most evidence suggests when we die it is the end? Yeah, I can barely handle it myself.
Wow, how sad for you! You remind me of the Sadducees (how Sad-U-cee: they didn't/don't believe what God says either).
You know...why don't you chill out. Sarah is trying to grasp belief; you would know that if you bothered looking a little deeper instead of allowing yourself to sound like another snooty voice in the wilderness.
OR
Tons of mounting evidence to support the Creation story along with evidence to support that dinosaurs walked along side man!! Yeah!
You know...why don't you chill out. Sarah is trying to grasp belief; you would know that if you bothered looking a little deeper instead of allowing yourself to sound like another snooty voice in the wilderness.
Belief in what?
Interesting replies, thank you for playing!
Observations:
Regarding the "I don't believe in nothing -- but I'm still an atheist" PLEASE explain. Words have meanings. "Atheism" means the specific disavowal of one, two or ANY Deity whatsoever.
It's a statement of overt disbelief.
So what, then, do you believe in?
___
Also, some of you are then turning it around to make ME affirmatively prove the existence of God. That's not what I'm asking here (but would be happy to answer/discuss in another thread if anyone wants). I'm asking what it would take for YOU to decide that atheism is no longer an intellectually rational belief -- or that you're now unsure of it as an absolute.
It's not "What would it take for you to believe in God."
But what would it take for you to decide that logically/emotionally/intellectually/spiritually can no longer claim to be an atheist?
I wish I would have seen this post earlier because I want to respond to it and would have done so earlier.
I am one of those people who doesn't believe in gods or the supernatural and I don't believe in nothing either.
I believe that existence exists as an absolute. It simply is, was, always will be and could not have been otherwise. I'm speaking of the metaphysically given not the man made.
I believe that consciousness is consciousness of something as opposed to nothing. Consciousnesses is secondary to existence. Consciousness is the faculty which perceives that which exists, not the faculty which creates it.
I believe that to exist is to possess a specific nature or set of attributes. I believe that everything that exists has a finite identity and that identity is existence.
I believe in the primacy of existence over consciousness, that things are what they are as absolutes unaffected by anyone's conscious actions. A is A whether anyone likes it or not. A thing can not be A and non-A at the same time and in the same respect.
Together these fundamental principles are the base of my worldview. The god belief contradicts all of them and they are what you would have to refute in order for me to become a believer. It will be a hard row to hoe.
All the things you addressed are the natural things. Now, what about things that are beyond the natural state? Even scientists talk about alternate dimensions, and those aren't things we can naturally perceive.
Question for the group: If you are an atheist, what would it take to convince you that there truly is "something" rather than "nothing"?
Or is it possible? (I have a feeling that some loathe the concept of God so much, they could watch the seas part & they would STILL find a reason to doubt.....)
Loving sin more than God to be reproved by Him can do that to a sinner to doubt on purpose.
Whoop!
My definition of Nature is synonymous with existence. It means everything that exists including consciousness, 'immaterial" things like concepts, things we can perceive and things we can't such as quarks and glueons and other dimensions that might exist. If other dimension exist then they are a part of nature.
The universe or existence is an integrated whole and our senses, like everything else that exists are finite and limited in their ability to perceive. The fact that our senses possess a finite identity is not a problem, it's what makes them possible. What we can't directly perceive we must infer but all inferences, to be valid, must be reducible to percepts. It is not possible to infer from looking at nature it's antithesis or the supernatural. That is an invalid concept. We can arrive at that concept by using our imaginations but not by induction.
I don't recognize anything that is beyond the natural state.
One has to really wonder about the athiests in here; are they seeking Him or seeking opportunities to mock and scoff, thus persecuting the faith as if they don't have better use of their time spent somewhere else? Otherwise, there are regular pubic forums for these guys to meet.
One can always hope that God is working on drawing some unto the Son to reveal Him to them through His words.
I've asked them several times why they come here, and they start out saying that my question is an act of desperation, and then say they come here for the discussion and to learn new things. My hope is that they're learning something. I like being challenged myself too. It makes me do some research into some things I hadn't thought of before.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?