What do you think of this story......

[Annabel Lee]

Originally posted by Mallory Knox


Because I used the word "bullcrap" instead of "false" it makes my opinion less well-thought out?

Yes it does. Less thought out and less considerate. I am not going to argue with you Mallory. You've given your opinion, now let's let others give theirs.

 

[lucypevensie]

It's great of course that the little girl found her way out of the woods and is safe. Something about her little "helper" is a little bit creepy to me. I know nothing in the Bible of dead people coming back to earth to help the living. I suppose angels could take on many forms--I don't know much about angels. I tend to think of angels as big strong beings who could fight in a battle, not little girly beings. I just don't know. I can conclude though that it is a good thing that the little girl is safely out of the woods. God can be thanked for that in any case!

 

[Thunderchild]

Like as though Jesus rebuked his disciples for being superstitious and believing in ghosts... Rather, he simply reassured them that they were not seeing a ghost. Whether real or not, when the Bible refers to ghosts, it makes no mention that believing in their existence is mere superstition.

 

[Mallory Knox]

Originally posted by Annabel Lee
Yes it does. Less thought out and less considerate. I am not going to argue with you Mallory. You've given your opinion, now let's let others give theirs.

For someody who's "not going to argue with me" you sure seem to be arguing with me.

 

[TheBear]

If the story is true, I'm glad the girl found her way out of the woods. I really don't have any comments on 'who' it was that led her out. Imagination and embelishment may be big factors here.

John

 

[ZiSunka]

Weird thing is, when the girl was describing what her imaginary friend was like, it turned out the girl she described was a 4 year old girl that had previously died in the woods.

Adults have such imaginations! It's unlikely that the little girl could have described her imaginary friend in such detail that she could be definitely identified as a specific child like that. It's more likely that she described her in genreal terms like, "She had blonde hair and a blue dress," and that kind of description could apply to any imaginary friend. It's probably the adults who filled in the gaps and made the imaginary friend into the dead girl.

I remember once I saw an apparition, and described her to my mom, who then discussed it with my grandma, and so on with all the relatives, and they decided that I had seen my great grandma who had just passed away, and they took me to the funeral home to see if it was the same woman, and I wanted to please them so much that I said it was, but it wasn't.

Kids are notoriuous for that.

 

[Mallory Knox]

Originally posted by lambslove
Adults have such imaginations! It's unlikely that the little girl could have described her imaginary friend in such detail that she could be definitely identified as a specific child like that. It's more likely that she described her in genreal terms like, "She had blonde hair and a blue dress," and that kind of description could apply to any imaginary friend. It's probably the adults who filled in the gaps and made the imaginary friend into the dead girl. 

That is EXACTLY, EXACTLY what I said. And people got mad. I'll wait and see how many people get mad at lambslove for the same thing they got mad at me for.

 

[Annabel Lee]

Originally posted by lambslove


Adults have such imaginations! It's unlikely that the little girl could have described her imaginary friend in such detail that she could be definitely identified as a specific child like that. It's more likely that she described her in genreal terms like, "She had blonde hair and a blue dress," and that kind of description could apply to any imaginary friend. It's probably the adults who filled in the gaps and made the imaginary friend into the dead girl.

I remember once I saw an apparition, and described her to my mom, who then discussed it with my grandma, and so on with all the relatives, and they decided that I had seen my great grandma who had just passed away, and they took me to the funeral home to see if it was the same woman, and I wanted to please them so much that I said it was, but it wasn't.

Kids are notoriuous for that.

No Mallory, this is NOT exactly what you said. What you said was, "This is bullcrap". If you can't see the difference between your response and Lambslove's response, then I am very sorry.

For someody who's "not going to argue with me" you sure seem to be arguing with me.

No..that is not arguing. And no public disagreements with staff members, Mallory.

 

[Mallory Knox]

Originally posted by Annabel Lee
No Mallory, this is NOT exactly what you said. What you said was, "This is bullcrap". If you can't see the difference between your response and Lambslove's response, then I am very sorry.

No..that is not arguing. And no public disagreements with staff members, Mallory.

What I said was , and I quote:

cough* bullcrap *cough*

If this even happened (now I'm not calling you a liar, I'm calling whoever reported it a liar), which I doubt, since this is typical urban legend material, I bet the girl was just describing a typical girl "she had shoulder-length blond hair and pretty blue eyes and loved bunnies and cookies" and people were like, "oh my god that fits the description of the girl who died!!!!"

Which is exactly what lambslove said, except I used the word "bullcrap", may god have mercy on my soul.

 

[MizDoulos]

This thread has been closed for obvious reasons.