• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

What a child really needs...

E

Everlasting33

Guest
Excellent video on child rearing and the needs that a child has. Yes, a child needs a perfect parent! In it, he discusses that people have children for the wrong reasons and many mothers want their needs fulfilled by having children (especially needs not met by their parents).

What a Child Really Needs (1 of 2) - YouTube

11 Situations in which it is not suitable to have children:

http://www.iraresoul.com/nokids.html
 
Last edited:

Softbreeze

Newbie
Oct 18, 2011
63
6
✟22,728.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Interesting message, had a lot of good points. I think that children are a blessing from God and you should always make plans to have children because there are several needs that they have and as a parent you should be prepared to meet those needs before they are born. I also think in Gods eyes we should prepare them for the future. They are the future leaders. As the bible says "God makes kings and Queens". Children should not be a burden but a blessing. I do think we should teach them the way God wants them to live. The bible gives us many examples how they should live. I am sure there are wonderful parents out there but pass habits make it difficult for us to have perfect kids. There isn't a perfect parent so there won't be a perfect kid either. Thats why we have Gods laws to teach us the right way. The bible is a guide to living a perfect life. There are so many adults with emotional and physical problems that it makes it hard to be a perfect parent. Just because someone has issus whether its financial, emotional, pjysical, etc. does not mean they won't be a good parent. If there was a perfect parent there won't be a need for God. The biggest need there is and is always talked about alot is Love according to Gods way. No matter how rich or poor we are the biggest need there is. LOVE.
 
Upvote 0
E

Everlasting33

Guest
I'm just wondering, why do you persist on posting crazy videos and crazy articles by a crazy person? Posting more of them doesn't make this guy any less crazy.

That is your intepretation of it. You haven't really given any valid reasons for why it is crazy. You are just stating it so.

How exactly is it crazy?
 
Upvote 0
I

ImperialPhantom

Guest
That is your intepretation of it. You haven't really given any valid reasons for why it is crazy. You are just stating it so.

How exactly is it crazy?
Okay, it's probably not worthwhile to even respond point-to-point to this article, and I'm sure you won't be convinced any other way besides your views, but I'll bite.

1) You are not fully enlightened.

If you are not fully enlightened it means you still repress some degree of unresolved trauma. We all have a compulsion to act out our repressed traumas on our intimates, and all the more so on our vulnerable, needy children – because they cannot refuse it or escape. Therefore, where you are not enlightened you will abuse your children to at least some degree. This is inappropriate.



Not only is this vague new-age mumbo jumbo, but he's contradicting himself, as he has stated elsewhere on his blog that he believes that nobody has ever reached full enlightenment. The wording of this paragraph shows that this guy clearly has NOT gotten past the emotional trauma inflicted upon him as a child.

2) You feel your life is incomplete.
It is a myth that children make parents’ lives complete. If your life feels incomplete without children then your job is to find a way to make it complete BEFORE you have children. Lives are made complete by internally resolving one’s traumas, not by adding new and perfect young lives to adult ones that are already traumatized. Children should not be brought into the world to meet any of YOUR needs. It is your job to meet their needs, and to devote yourself to this end. Not the other way around.


Anyone who feels that their life is, in actuality, "complete", is wrong. Your life is complete when you're dead. While he is right about bringing children into the world to meet your own needs, that has nothing to do with one's life being 'complete'.

3) You are lonely and want love.
No child deserves a lonely, needy parent. Your child will not love you. That is a myth. Your child needs you – and needs you desperately – and if you think your child loves you then you, along with most of our culture, have mixed up love and need. Now granted, if you need your child to love you, your child will quickly pick this up on his emotional antennae and will adjust his behavior toward actually loving you…but this will be devastating and perverse for his emotional development. Learn to love yourself fully before you have kids.


That's truly bizarre and again is a product of his own emotional trauma. "Your child will not love you"? What, like, ever? Really? Maybe HE didn't love his parents, but that's his issue.

4) You feel left out of the normal, conventional loop of parenting.
Yes, and the loop is SICK! If you are left out of the loop you have a FAR better chance to become healthy. And the healthier you become, the more you naturally contribute to this world, and contribute in a real and deep and honest and spontaneous way. And our world needs your contribution.


Vague, non-sequitur, no clue what he is talking about here. It's a whole lot of talk but he's not actually saying much.

5) You are single.
A single parent alone cannot effectively raise an emotionally healthy child. It’s hard enough for two parents. It’s hard enough for four! If you think you can handle it on your own then you have no idea of the extent of a child’s truest and deepest emotional needs. And this is because you have not faced the full depths of the painful limits and abandonments of your own childhood. And this is not your child’s fault.


Agreed with the premise that single people should not try to have kids, but once he starts talking about 'painful limits' and 'abandonments' he loses me. He assumes that EVERYBODY has the same limits and abandonments that he once had.

6) You are close with your own parents.
If you are close with your own parents, it is highly unlikely that you have evolved out of the family system to any degree – that is, that you have become an individual in your own right. If you have not evolved out of the family system, you will never be able to know the full limits of your own buried traumas, much less be able to resolve them. Thus you will act them out on your child. And your parents will love you for this, because this will let them off the hook for what they did to you.


This is not only idiotic, it's representative of the American worship of individualism at the expense of family. For someone who has been through the same emotional trauma that he has, then sure, but for everyone else, no. He's broadly painting everyone with the same brush that he himself was painted with.

7) You know you will have to hire help to assist you in caring for your child.
No child deserves to be raised by hired help. If you do not have the time and comfort and energy and motivation to devote to raising your child yourself, then you will be bringing your child into a deprived world. You will be at least partially abandoning your child – and your duty to your child – before he is even born. Radically unfair.


Hiring help to do ALL of the raising of your child is different than hiring help to assist with childcare. If two parents work, then it's absolutely necessary, and not all parents are called to have one staying at home. In fact, hiring help can be beneficial for a child, who might otherwise not experience having an authority figure or caretaker besides a parent, or a teacher, and whose parents are good parents.

8) You got pregnant by mistake.
This is a terrible psychic burden for a child to face. It is a clear sign that your child was not conceived in an environment of love, caring, and planning. It is a sign that you undervalue your child from the beginning of his journey – and will continue to do so all the way through his journey. You will leave him with a terrible legacy. And deep down he will know it.


Again, idiotic. Even when a pregnancy is a mistake, 9 months is more than enough time to reconcile with the realities that you're going to be a parent, and to ready one's self for it.

9) You drink alcohol, use drugs, smoke cigarettes, or take anti-depressants.
Ingesting these substances is a sign that you have a desperate need to abandon parts of yourself – and thus are not a whole person. And even after a person stops ingesting these substances, it takes years of incredibly hard internal work for him to become whole. No child deserves parents who are not whole, because by extension they will also similarly abandon him. And people wonder why substance abusing parents beget substance abusing children! (Forget genetics.)


Flawed and borderline Scientologist. Someone who drinks a beer once or twice a week or smokes a pack every week or 2 isn't automatically a less-fit parent for it. An alcoholic or a 2 pack a day smoker is a different story, but obviously, he didn't specify that. As for the anti-depressants ... sure, they are quite overprescribed in this day and age, but there are those who truly do have a chemical imbalance that needs to be corrected, and just because the author is NOT one of these people, doesn't mean that nobody else is.

10) Your relationship with your partner is not fully enlightened.
Where your relationship with your partner is not fully enlightened your family environment will be toxic – toxified by projections, fantasy, and unconscious compromises of truth. Your child deserves the best, and a partially toxic environment is anything but. Your child needs to be nurtured in an environment in which his parents live in complete emotional synchrony with life’s sacred purpose – and by extension with each other. Where you do not live in synchrony with your partner, your child will suffer. And the fault will be yours, because you brought him into the world. After all, your child never asked to be born.


SEE ALSO: my response to number 1

11) You and your partner are both not ONE HUNDRED PERCENT convinced you want a child to the deepest levels of your soul.
If you have any doubts about having children, don’t have them! There are a million other ways for you to contribute to this troubled, overpopulated, resource-exploited world without procreating. And often these other ways are far more valuable. But the primary way is to devote yourself to parenting yourself. This is the hardest way to go. This is the spiritual path.

More new age mumbo jumbo and half-truths. If you DON'T WANT CHILDREN, then don't have them. But you can certainly be unsure at the time of procreation (even if you are leaning towards having children) and sure at the time of birth.

Bottom line: First of all, this man doesn't have children. I'd trust the opinion of a Roman about Rome before I'd trust a Wikipedia enthusiast who has never been to Rome. Second, he is painting everybody with the same brush that he himself is painted with due to his own childhood traumas, but his writings clearly show that he has no ability to look outside of his own universe. Not to mention, his new-agey eastern perspective gets in the way of a lot of those pesky "facts".
 
Upvote 0

k450ofu3k-gh-5ipe

Senior Member
Apr 3, 2008
2,153
137
✟25,458.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Okay, it's probably not worthwhile to even respond point-to-point to this article, and I'm sure you won't be convinced any other way besides your views, but I'll bite.





Not only is this vague new-age mumbo jumbo, but he's contradicting himself, as he has stated elsewhere on his blog that he believes that nobody has ever reached full enlightenment. The wording of this paragraph shows that this guy clearly has NOT gotten past the emotional trauma inflicted upon him as a child.




Anyone who feels that their life is, in actuality, "complete", is wrong. Your life is complete when you're dead. While he is right about bringing children into the world to meet your own needs, that has nothing to do with one's life being 'complete'.




That's truly bizarre and again is a product of his own emotional trauma. "Your child will not love you"? What, like, ever? Really? Maybe HE didn't love his parents, but that's his issue.




Vague, non-sequitur, no clue what he is talking about here. It's a whole lot of talk but he's not actually saying much.




Agreed with the premise that single people should not try to have kids, but once he starts talking about 'painful limits' and 'abandonments' he loses me. He assumes that EVERYBODY has the same limits and abandonments that he once had.




This is not only idiotic, it's representative of the American worship of individualism at the expense of family. For someone who has been through the same emotional trauma that he has, then sure, but for everyone else, no. He's broadly painting everyone with the same brush that he himself was painted with.




Hiring help to do ALL of the raising of your child is different than hiring help to assist with childcare. If two parents work, then it's absolutely necessary, and not all parents are called to have one staying at home. In fact, hiring help can be beneficial for a child, who might otherwise not experience having an authority figure or caretaker besides a parent, or a teacher, and whose parents are good parents.




Again, idiotic. Even when a pregnancy is a mistake, 9 months is more than enough time to reconcile with the realities that you're going to be a parent, and to ready one's self for it.




Flawed and borderline Scientologist. Someone who drinks a beer once or twice a week or smokes a pack every week or 2 isn't automatically a less-fit parent for it. An alcoholic or a 2 pack a day smoker is a different story, but obviously, he didn't specify that. As for the anti-depressants ... sure, they are quite overprescribed in this day and age, but there are those who truly do have a chemical imbalance that needs to be corrected, and just because the author is NOT one of these people, doesn't mean that nobody else is.




SEE ALSO: my response to number 1



More new age mumbo jumbo and half-truths. If you DON'T WANT CHILDREN, then don't have them. But you can certainly be unsure at the time of procreation (even if you are leaning towards having children) and sure at the time of birth.

Bottom line: First of all, this man doesn't have children. I'd trust the opinion of a Roman about Rome before I'd trust a Wikipedia enthusiast who has never been to Rome. Second, he is painting everybody with the same brush that he himself is painted with due to his own childhood traumas, but his writings clearly show that he has no ability to look outside of his own universe. Not to mention, his new-agey eastern perspective gets in the way of a lot of those pesky "facts".

Dang good post IP. I'm glad you bit.
 
Upvote 0

JRSut1000

Newbie no more!
Aug 20, 2011
4,783
339
United States of America
✟29,114.00
Faith
Messianic
Marital Status
Married
I have to agree, this guy seems to think nobody is fit to be a parent. This just isnt true. Not every couple is 100% convinced they are ready to have a kid. I'm convinced NO one is fully ready to have a kid, but that doesn't mean they shouldnt have one. I was scared to have a kid but my husband and I went for it. We aint perfect but we love our little girl and look forward to conceiving sometime soon Yah willing.

I drink alcohol as does my husband, we're not bad parents for it.

Single poeple really DO need help raising the child. There should be some kind of father/mother figure that is missing to help balance the needs of the child. But that doesnt mean that the woman whos husband died is now all of a sudden going to ruin their kids life. Eeks! This person obviously doesnt think God can do all things and help those who struggle!

One can be close with their own parents, yet raise their kid totally different from what they were raised and it all turn out just fine. What is he even talking about?

I'll skip all the other points and come to this - children dont need perfect parents, children needs parents who are willing to love them the best they can. What more can you ask for? Especially when God is in the picture!
 
Upvote 0
E

Everlasting33

Guest
Not only is this vague new-age mumbo jumbo, but he's contradicting himself, as he has stated elsewhere on his blog that he believes that nobody has ever reached full enlightenment. The wording of this paragraph shows that this guy clearly has NOT gotten past the emotional trauma inflicted upon him as a child.".

Let me first say that after years of reading similiar material, this man's thoughts are much more acceptable. I have dedicated years of researching child development and psychology and the more I read, the more I am aware of how subtly a parent can negatively influence their child.

I don't agree with this point of enlightenment as much as this man does. I like a lot of what he says since he highlights the need of awareness and action.

Anyone who feels that their life is, in actuality, "complete", is wrong. Your life is complete when you're dead. While he is right about bringing children into the world to meet your own needs, that has nothing to do with one's life being 'complete'.".

Many times, a person may feel empty and incomplete in later life and they assume it is because they don't have children. This may be true but the motivation should not be their to fill an emptiness. A person should inquire more of why he or she feels incomplete.

That's truly bizarre and again is a product of his own emotional trauma. "Your child will not love you"? What, like, ever? Really? Maybe HE didn't love his parents, but that's his issue.".

I perceive him saying that a child doesn't want to feel used for a parent's need for love/approval. He wants to have his needs validated and mirrored.

Agreed with the premise that single people should not try to have kids, but once he starts talking about 'painful limits' and 'abandonments' he loses me. He assumes that EVERYBODY has the same limits and abandonments that he once had.".

He believes every person, as a child, as the same basic needs and issues with abandonment. Since a single parent cannot be at home most of the time, a child will certainly feel abandoned.

This is not only idiotic, it's representative of the American worship of individualism at the expense of family. For someone who has been through the same emotional trauma that he has, then sure, but for everyone else, no. He's broadly painting everyone with the same brush that he himself was painted with.".

In the realm of psycholanalytical psychology, an adult cannot fully comprehend and experience the wounds of childhood if one is emotionally or physically close with their parents. I can definitely bear witness to this as both my sisters, close with mother, have not made the emotional/mental strides as I have. When I look around me, many times the adult children who are the closest with their parents are the least successful and/or most psychologically wounded.


Hiring help to do ALL of the raising of your child is different than hiring help to assist with childcare. If two parents work, then it's absolutely necessary, and not all parents are called to have one staying at home. In fact, hiring help can be beneficial for a child, who might otherwise not experience having an authority figure or caretaker besides a parent, or a teacher, and whose parents are good parents.".

I believe it is best that a parent, particularly the mother, raise the child without assistance. However, what if a family has sextuplets? Obviously, hired help is needed and the workload needs to be multiplied. I, myself, would like more details on this point.

Again, idiotic. Even when a pregnancy is a mistake, 9 months is more than enough time to reconcile with the realities that you're going to be a parent, and to ready one's self for it.".

Not all mothers know at the beginning of nine months. Time is not necessarily the factor here but the mental anguish of having a child and not wanting him or her. This may come and go through pregnancy and a child's life but I believe a child will find out, in some way, that he or she wasn't truly wanted. Some people a mother's emotions during pregnancy can already have a negative/positive affect on a child's journey throughout life. If a mother is constantly wrestling with the fact of having a child, while pregnant, I cannot see how this is can be positive on the hormonal cycling of the fetus.

Flawed and borderline Scientologist. Someone who drinks a beer once or twice a week or smokes a pack every week or 2 isn't automatically a less-fit parent for it. An alcoholic or a 2 pack a day smoker is a different story, but obviously, he didn't specify that. As for the anti-depressants ... sure, they are quite overprescribed in this day and age, but there are those who truly do have a chemical imbalance that needs to be corrected, and just because the author is NOT one of these people, doesn't mean that nobody else is.".

Of all the points this man makes, I agree wholeheartly with this one. If you must take a substance, for whatever reason, it is unwise to have children. Since you are attempting to silence a feeling/thought, it is considered an inadequate coping skill. Like he said, you are "abandoning parts of yourself," by doing this.

If you need to be prescribed medication for mental health issues, your level of consistency of mood and action is extremely jeopordized. However, people don't take child rearing seriously and have children anyway. Too often, there is a script that must follow one's life and this includes" must have children."


More new age mumbo jumbo and half-truths. If you DON'T WANT CHILDREN, then don't have them. But you can certainly be unsure at the time of procreation (even if you are leaning towards having children) and sure at the time of birth.".

Bottom line: First of all, this man doesn't have children. I'd trust the opinion of a Roman about Rome before I'd trust a Wikipedia enthusiast who has never been to Rome. Second, he is painting everybody with the same brush that he himself is painted with due to his own childhood traumas, but his writings clearly show that he has no ability to look outside of his own universe. Not to mention, his new-agey eastern perspective gets in the way of a lot of those pesky "facts".[/quote]

He is not only speaking of his own experience but that of counseling and studying child psychology for many years. He certainly has some authority on the subject. His experiences have been highlighted by his awareness and through this awareness, he can "see" what other people cannot. Certain people have psychological insights of talent. I think its fair to say anything can be skewed or biased upon. But, that should automatically rule something out.


"My writings might sound like I am setting the bar impossibly high for parents. Good! I am. For most parents I set the bar impossibly high because most parents have absolutely no business having children. On their deep emotional levels they can barely take care of themselves, and still ARE emotional children themselves. The horror taking place in our world is enough proof of this!"
 
Upvote 0
C

CelticRose

Guest
If God had wanted children to have perfect parents he would have made parents that way. Instead He allows fallible, imperfect people to parent as best they can in order for the child to learn only God can meet his needs perfectly; that forgiveness brings healing; that there can be imperfection & love together. Thus he learns the father heart of God for His imperfect children ~ because no child is any more perfect than their parents. We are all sinners. One needs to be realistic ~ & teach a child to be realistic also. Anything else is a recipe for disaster & failure.

Nor do I think it is healthy to either view children as being so emotionally fragile nor encourage them to see themselves that way. We should take our cue from God's parenting of us; we are allowed adversity in our lives to teach us to grow strong, overcome adversity, perservere, help those weaker, ask for help when we are weak, practice love & patience & longsuffering that we might grow in holiness because there but for the grace of God....

Honestly, not even Jesus got *perfect* parents. He was dogged by rumours of
illigitimacy all his life. He begged for the cup of suffering to pass from him. Suffering is part of life. Teaching a child how to deal with it effectively so that they overcome rather than succumbing is far more to the point than looking for perfect parents because there are none!
 
Upvote 0