If I may, why did you leave the Presbyterian church for the LCMS? Were you not happy with the teaching or was the church going in a direction away from the Bible and sound teaching?
Well, we first visited the LCMS church primarily because my husband was unhappy in the Presbyterian church we were attending. It was too.. analytical... for him. He is Baptist, and he wasn't at all interested in theological discussions from the pulpit. He wanted the Gospel, pure and simple. The Presbyterian church preaches the Gospel, of course, but sometimes scholarship in a sermon is emphasized over clarity and simplicity of presentation. I loved it, because I get excited by Christian history, theology, doctrine, and Bible studies. He, however, felt like there was a great divide between what the Pastor said and his own life. In truth, sometimes I sensed it too, in that I was so busy studying ABOUT Christian thought and belief that it was removed from the realm of not-Sunday-morning.
Also, for me, I felt like there was something else missing. Some... mystery... that I'd encountered once or twice while visiting other churches but couldn't put my finger on.
So we visited the LCMS church when we moved. We chose it for no other reason than it was the closest church to our new home. I looked at the bulletin and thought "we won't be coming back here again!" I know the basics of liturgy, for I've sung church music most of my life. I know my husband, too, and knew that he had no interest in Catholic or pseudo-Catholic liturgy styles.
But then, Pastor began his sermon.
Down to earth. Rubber hits the road. Gospel centered. Grace proclaimed. Scholarly, and yet practical. Loving and yet strong.
Come to find out, Pastor used to be an Army chaplain. His style is JUST what my husband needed to hear. Not highfalutin'. Not dumbed down. Not fire-and-brimstone. Just Christ and Him crucified.
Hunter was impressed. I was amazed. The liturgy, which had seemed like such a hurdle in my mind, was as nothing to him. (though he did have a hard time with the use of the term "Israel" throughout the liturgy at first)
We both liked the strong conservative nature of the congregation, compared to the much more liberal PCUSA (and our particular Presbyterian church had actually been one of the most conservative in our local Presbytery -- when they had dicussions/debates about the "marriage of a man and woman or chastity in singleness" issue, our Pastor was often the one asked to debate for the marriage/chastity side).
So we started attending regularly (which at that time was about twice a month, due to his work schedule) and I joined the choir. I started looking at Lutheran doctrine and the FAQs on lcms.org to learn more about the church. I had some reservations, of course, but it sure sparked some interesting discussions!
When Gem got out of the nursery and was old enough for Sunday School, we started attending every Sunday, and began going to adult Sunday School. We went through the Book of Concord, and got a better understanding of Lutheran doctrine.
And I found that the mystery that I had been looking for... and had only encountered once or twice before...? was the real Presence of Christ in the sacraments. The more I studied it, the more I realized that the Reformed church had thrown out the baby with the bathwater on this point.
Now we do still have some difficulties, doctrinally. My husband still has mild Baptist ideas about "making a decision" for Jesus, although he's slowly coming around to a more Reformed/Lutheran view on that. And I still have serious troubles giving up the LIP of the Reformed TULIP.I believe both Lutherans and Reformed pretty much agree on Total Depravity and Unconditional Election, but there are strong differences on Limited Atonement, Irresistable Grace, and the Perseverance of the Saints. In addition, I was ordained an elder in the PCUSA, and while I am willing to give up that authority, and I accept the reasons, it does still sting at times.
But the Gospel is central, as it should be. Christ is celebrated. We are taught the Word. THe means of Grace are offered regularly.
Strangely, it's been... like coming home.