Hmm, so what does everyone think about getting back on topic. Granted the debate was interesting for a while, but now it's just getting ridiculous. You both have your own opinion and IMHO they are both equally valid.
Just like any other group in history; (Wiccans, Christians, Atheists, Communists, etc.) Puritans did some good and some bad things. The Puritans get a bad rap because of the Witch trials, which where an atrocity I agree completely, and they also severely mistreated the Quakers, but that is not the only things they have done in history. The actions of a few (or even the majority) of people in a group should not disqualify that there has been some good done by the group at one point.
Of course, like all things, there are exceptions to the rule. The KKK, Nazis, and various other groups had little if any redeeming qualities. However, that is a debate for another time and place.
Now that that is settled, can we get back on topic before this thread is locked.
One interesting thing I've learned is that when it comes to a fantasy setting, there are many "Excepted" ways to write a story or race, but there will always be a few authors who don't write that way.
Not every author I've read, writes there elves like the High Elves of Celtic Mythos or Tolkien stories and not every Vampire story creates the race of Vampires exactly like Stoker. Fantasy has to be my favorite genre, just because of the freedom it gives you.