I read The Shack. I was not impressed.
I don't think reading should be censored because something is theologically unsound. If you are taking your understanding from anywhere except the Bible you are already on dangerous ground theologically, imo.
Quite frankly, the only thing The Shack made me think about was "Should I put down this boring book." I kept slogging through it because I have a friend who had read it and was raving about it.
Mr. Jim, in your list of "hit" books (none of which I liked, although I do enjoy the Left Behind movies for the outstanding acting & special effects) you mentioned the Prayer of Jabez - which is the only one I haven't read. I have, however, picked up a copy of "Secrets of The Vine" same author and I actually enjoyed it - what did you think of it?