The problem in Christianity and Islam compared to Judaism

[Tree of Life]

I heard some argument against Christianty (and Islam) and I didn't know what to respond:

Some people claim that Judaism is more reliable faith than Islam and Christianity because of the fact that Judaism is the only religion that claim God has revealed himself in front of many people on Mount Sinai. However Christianity is less reliable because the story of Jesus and his miracles occoured in front of small group of people. Same thing with Islam: It is claimed that God speak to Muhammad in private, but not if front of other people.

The argument: Judaism must be the true religion because there is no chance that so many people will believe in a story which includes some many eyewitnesses unless it is true.

In contrast to that, Islam and Christianty could be lies because there is a possible chance that people will believe in stories that happened in front of small group of people.

I'd love to hear your opinion about this argument.
(And sorry for my bad English! )

According to Paul the risen Christ appeared to more than 500 brothers at one time.

 

[Tinker Grey]

No, definitely Ariston.

I tried searching a bit and couldn't find much except an obscure reference in an obscure book.

Can you provide some links?

P.S. No love for Rufus?

 

[iluvtheSims]

Christians and Jews can co-exist, but Christians and Jews cannot co-exist with muslims. muslims are not Christians, they are followers of the devil, they are tricked and deceived. muslims god is not the same God that we Christians believe in, allah is the devil, and mohammed their prophet was demon possessed. mohammed admitted before that even he wondered if his thoughts were really from "god" or the devil. Christians do not persecute or behead people who don't accept Christ. muslims give only up to 3 chances, and if someone won't convert to islam then they can behead you. muslims are taught in the koran to lie and kill the infidel (us Christians AND Jews).

 

[RDKirk]

Christians and Jews can co-exist, but Christians and Jews cannot co-exist with muslims. muslims are not Christians, they are followers of the devil, they are tricked and deceived. muslims god is not the same God that we Christians believe in, allah is the devil, and mohammed their prophet was demon possessed. mohammed admitted before that even he wondered if his thoughts were really from "god" or the devil. Christians do not persecute or behead people who don't accept Christ. muslims give only up to 3 chances, and if someone won't convert to islam then they can behead you. muslims are taught in the koran to lie and kill the infidel (us Christians AND Jews).

Christianity and Judaism both contain rationale for minority status. That's inherent in the concept of being "selected" or "elect" or "chosen." Thus, even a missionary religion like Christianity can be a minority of the population, but the religion itself provides rationale for why that's still an "all right" status: "The way is narrow and few find it."

Islam does not provide a rationale to rest as a minority religion in the world or even in a particular region.