The No true Scotsman Fallacy

[Red Fox]

There is a context to the question.

You asked Hetta if she believes wrongly, so I asked you if you do.

 

[seekingsolace]

According to many other Christians, yes I do. I have been told that I'm not a Christian a number of times.

Well your faith is 'Christian-seeker'.

 

[Red Fox]

According to many other Christians, yes I do. I have been told that I'm not a Christian a number of times.

We should start a club. LOL.

 

[Red Fox]

Well your faith is 'Christian-seeker'.

And?

 

[seekingsolace]

And?

Red fox, try not to reply to a message specifically directed to someone else. Thank you.

 

[bhsmte]

There was a context. You should follow the discussion (especially since she quoted you).

Being the thorough guy I am, I checked back and didn't see content that addressed my question that I missed. But, I will try harder to follow along.

 

[Red Fox]

Red fox, try not to reply to a message specifically directed to someone else. Thank you.

Ha ha ha... that's not how it works on a PUBLIC message board.

 

[seekingsolace]

Ha ha ha... that's not how it works on a PUBLIC message board.

If I address a poster referring to 'Christian seeker' when yours is not, am I speaking to you? No, I didn't think so.

If you have no intention of contributing properly to the thread, then why are you here?

 

[Red Fox]

If I address a poster referring to 'Christian seeker' when yours is not, am I speaking to you? No, I didn't think so.

She's a Christian-Seeker, so what? My question was meant to be why do you care what her faith icon is.

I can ask a question if I want to, you don't have to answer, but you can't tell me I can't ask a question.

 

[Hammster]

According to many other Christians, yes I do. I have been told that I'm not a Christian a number of times.

Let's me set the context since it seems to be missed.

Well, doesn't address the question I posed, but that's ok.

In the end, everyone on earth believes wrongly, according to groups of people who hold up their theology, as the correct belief.

As long as there is religion, this reality will never change.

This, so much.

You agreed that everyone believes wrongly. Do you believe wrongly?

 

[bhsmte]

We should start a club. LOL.

You could have a lot of members.

 

[seekingsolace]

She's a Christian-Seeker, so what? My question was meant to be why do you care what her faith icon is. I can ask a question if I want to, you don't have to answer, but you can't tell me I can't ask a question.

Perhaps if you were the person addressed this would be simple to understand.

 

[Hammster]

Being the thorough guy I am, I checked back and didn't see content that addressed my question that I missed. But, I will try harder to follow along.

That would be good.

 

[Red Fox]

You could have a lot of members.

It would be a huge global club with probably millions of members.

 

[seekingsolace]

You could have a lot of members.

Yes, the trinity of Me, Myself & I.

 

[Red Fox]

Perhaps if you were the person addressed this would be simple to understand.

My seven year old daughter could understand it, so I don't know why you're having a hard time with it.

 

[Red Fox]

Yes, the trinity of Me, Myself & I.

Now you just interpreted a conversation between myself and another person, so... you really don't have a lot of room to talk.

 

[bhsmte]

Let's me set the context since it seems to be missed.




You agreed that everyone believes wrongly. Do you believe wrongly?

Maybe you are missing a bit of the context.

If Hetta agreed with my statement, she agreed with the fact that there will always be a group of Christians out there, that will tell you your belief is wrong.

Now, whether Hetta feels she believes wrongly, would likely be up to Hetta to decide, not those who claim she is wrong.

 

[Hammster]

Maybe you are missing a bit of the context.

If Hetta agreed with my statement, she agreed with the fact that there will always be a group of Christians out there, that will tell you your belief is wrong.

Now, whether Hetta feels she believes wrongly, would likely be up to Hetta to decide, not those who claim she is wrong.

Hence, my question.

 

[bhsmte]

If I address a poster referring to 'Christian seeker' when yours is not, am I speaking to you? No, I didn't think so.

If you have no intention of contributing properly to the thread, then why are you here?

Who determines whether someone is contributing properly to a thread, on a public forum?