Thank you for your contribution to this thread. I do appreciate that you are speaking from your experience, from the heart. I do not know if God is guiding your words. If not, than it would be great if God did guide the words of someone soon, so that God could reach me through those words.
I had not thought that you were blaming me for failing to use spiritual eyes and ears. Some Christians have blamed me, but you are not one of them. I must admit that when I first came across the expressions spiritual eyes and spiritual ears, I was completely mystified. I find it difficult enough to conceive of the idea of a persons spirit. But the thought of that spirit (whatever it is) having eyes and ears of some kind was even more strange to me. Whatever did it mean? I think that now I do understand the concept of the spirit, and spiritual eyes and ears. But I remain convinced that I have absolutely no awareness of these things. And I have no idea how I could possibly get acquainted with my spirit in any way, let alone use it to receive spiritual communications.
I wrote this: During my time as a Christian in the 1970s I engaged in all of the activities that you mention. But there was still no communication from God.
Your response was this:
I may be wrong, but I do think youre letting your previous experiences hold you back. Maybe you didnt get what you were looking for in the 70s, but that was a while ago. You are a different man now to the man you were then.
Absolutely right, my previous experiences are holding me back. They happened, they are my main experience of Christianity, and they had a major impact on my life. I agree that is was a long time ago, and that I have moved on since then, but the length of time can also be considered in a different way. For example my prayers of the 1970s, and the prayers of the people who knew me then and prayed for me, have still not been answered more than 30 years later. Besides, in recent years I have found a possible explanation for why I cannot have any spiritual experience while most other people do experience them, and that is something else that can hold me back.
Even so, in April this year I was able to put those past experiences to one side and come to God afresh. Not with all of me, but with part of me, so that part of me believed and part of me was not yet ready to believe. But I asked God to work on those other parts until all of me believed. Unfortunately it did not happen, and instead I now have all of me unable to believe again.
In April I did try putting my past experiences to one side and coming to God again, but it did not work out. That tells me that it was the wrong approach. So I will say thank you for the suggestion. It was a very sensible suggestion, but unfortunately it did not have the desired effect; it did not help me to know God.
You then wrote this:
I dont have all the answers. For a long time, I thought that I was a bad Christian because I couldnt answer all of the questions posed of me, but in truth there are some answers that only God has. I personally just keep an open mind. I concentrate on Him. I think about Him. I look for Him. When my baby nephew comes round to play, and he laughs, I dont hear him moving his vocal chords to express amusement, but a miracle of God. Personally (and any Christian can only talk from his or her own experience) I think its about a mindset. You need to be openly thinking I am going to see God in this and then make a conscious effort to do that.
No Christian that I know of or have contacted, has been able to help me to find the answers that I am seeking. I have no criticism just because you do not have all the answers. As you imply, this is a problem that perhaps only God has the answer to. But so far God has not shared the answer with anyone.
You wrote about having a mindset to see God at work in all things. When I started to trust God again in April this year, I was surprised just how quickly I returned to some of my Christian ways of thinking. It just seemed to come naturally to me but only for the first two days or so. After that it became more and more of a struggle to think in that way, until eventually it disappeared again. However, even in my most Christian moments I have never thought of seeing God at work in all things. Maybe that is one of those spiritual experiences that always pass me by. Or maybe it is simply a way of thinking that I am not yet ready for. Certainly it would be impossible for me to do it now, in my present state of non-belief.
You wrote this:
We all have them (spiritual eyes and ears). God gives us all the opportunity to see and experience Him. We just to need get rid of any hang-ups we have and fully embrace.
I appreciate what you are saying here, but I can only say that it is contrary to me own experience. I do not agree that we all must necessarily have spiritual eyes and ears. There are people whose natural eyes and ears do not function at all. Why therefore might there not be people like me whose spiritual eyes and ears perceive absolutely nothing? This means that God might not give us all the opportunity to see and experience God.
I agree that the problem could be hang-ups. But I am completely unaware of any hang-ups affecting my spiritual awareness either. I just seem to be a person with no spiritual aspects whatsoever. I am very much aware of how this limits me, because it is a kind of disability. But short of a healing miracle I do not know what I could do about it. Certainly I cannot get rid of any hang-ups, because as far as I am aware there are no hang-ups. Maybe you need spiritual awareness to become aware of these hang-ups which leaves me still unable to access spirituality. However, no Christian that I have spoken to has mentioned any spiritual hang-ups that I have.
It is not only Christians who have noticed my lack of spiritual awareness. I have had conversations with Buddhists and with people interested in new age spirituality, and both agree that I seem to lack any kind of spiritual nature. Interestingly, just as many Christians have also told me, they suggested that I should step out in faith anyway and trust that spiritual awareness would come. But it did not come.
You wrote this:
So, can I ask what exactly is it that you want from God? You said that this sort of thing happens regardless of whether one is a Christian. Of course it does. God works His wonders for all, hoping that He will convince people of His existence. He doesnt work exclusively for Christians. Again, what would be the point of creating these people if He wasnt going to care for them? Non-Christians are His children too. Also remember that God has His own time frame. It doesnt matter that it differs from mine, so long as His will is done.
I cannot tell you exactly what I want from God, except in general terms. I want to know God, to have a personal relationship with God, and I want to serve God. But the details of how those things might happen, I will leave up to God. Who am I to limit the ways in which God might work?
You write of God working wonders for all. Wonders? I have to ask what are these wonders that God works for all. Are there wonders all the time that I am not aware of? Or are you speaking of Gods wonders because of a mindset of seeing God at work in all things? If so, then I can understand why you say the things that you do. But I do not have this same mindset. Indeed, for me as an unbeliever it would be totally inappropriate for me to have such a mindset. So I do not see God at work. I simply see things happening, or not happening, and there are plenty of perfectly rational explanations for the events that I see. There is no need to involve God at all in order to explain them. All it requires is people making decisions and acting.
I agree that Gods time frame is not like ours. That is why I suggested later that one possible explanation for my failure to find God in the 1970s or in 2007 was because the time was not yet right for God.
You wrote this:
I wonder, are you trying to be a Christian rather than find God? Because they are two very different things. Finding God has to come first, following His word and conforming to the rules of a religion comes second. Otherwise you are following a set of rules for no real reason. Following the Commandments doesnt help you to see God. Turning the other cheek doesnt help you to see God. What does help you? It varies from person to person. My epiphany, admittedly, came from music. After years of being a Christian and following the rules I heard a song, and then God touched my heart. Everyone has a different epiphany, and it will come at a different time. There are no steadfast answers, Im afraid.
No I am most definitely not trying to be a Christian rather than trying to find God. Finding God is my priority. I happen to have chosen Christianity as my way to find God.
I am absolutely delighted that you say that finding God has to come first, and following Gods rules comes second. You would be surprised just how many Christians have told me the opposite.
I have no idea what would be my epiphany. If anything. Probably not music, because even though I listen to music, play music and write music, it has no spiritual quality for me, and no real emotional quality either. But then, nothing seems to have much emotional effect on me, and no spiritual effect on me at all.
Originally Posted by losthope I can only think of four possible answers to those questions that are consistent with my experience.1. God does not want me (my name not written in the book of life).
I dont believe in the notion of the Book of Life. I find it difficult to believe that God would create someone and then not want to save him/her. He creates us all to be His children, we just have to accept him.
You may not believe in the concept of predestination and therefore that some people cannot possibly be saved because they are predestined otherwise. But many Christians do believe in this. I also do not think it very likely that God has created me not to be one of Gods children. But while I agree with your conclusion, it is for a completely different reason from yours.
Quote:
Originally Posted by losthope 2. It is not yet the right time for God, for me to be saved.
Youre obviously being stirred for something, mate. Maybe its time for you to begin your journey to God, even if it take a while for you to reach your destination.
Well, I did try to begin my journey with God. Twice. In 1974 and again in 2007. Unfortunately I have not yet found God and so cannot begin my journey with God. I agree that it may take a long time to reach the destination after starting out. But first I have to get started, and to do that I must first find God. Or, more likely, God first has to find me.
Quote:
Originally Posted by losthope 3. I lack spiritual awareness and so cannot know God.
I believe that, anthropologically speaking, we are all built with spiritual awareness. That's why religion has flourished in some form in every culture. You have that awareness, mate, even if it's buried inside.
As I wrote above, I do not agree with you that we are all built with spiritual awareness. I have no spiritual awareness, and that means there must be at least one exception to your certainty. It seems to me to be playing with words to say that I have spiritual awareness but it is buried inside. An eye that is buried inside will not be able to see anything. However, I accept that most people do have something inside them that they call spiritual awareness, and that is why religion has flourished in most cultures.
Quote:
Originally Posted by losthope 4. It is all delusion.
Not in my experience, but I may be wrong. I think that the testimony of so many people shows that God is not a delusion, but that's a personal interpretation of the evidence presented.
If you are deluded, that means that even though it all seems real to you, it is not. I can understand how that can happen to millions of people, creating huge numbers of believers, for example to Christianity. I also understand why I would be excluded from this mass delusion. That is my personal interpretation of the evidence, but not just my personal interpretation. There are many strong Christians who recognise the possibility of mass delusion, but whose faith causes them to reject this possibility.
I note that you rejected all of my four possible explanations for why I failed to find God in 1974 and again in 2007. As far as I can see, your preferred explanation is a variation on #3, that I need to find some way of unburying my spiritual eyes and ears and to get rid of any hang-ups that are preventing me from being aware of God. And that brings us right back to the beginning of this posting, my difficulty in understanding the concept of spiritual eyes and ears, let alone doing anything about it.
Perhaps you can understand why I say that the next move is not mine to make, but Gods.