interesting post, from a jew right here on the forum..about messianic Judaism, gentiles trying to act like jews..
Originally Posted by ChavaK
Hey, LLOJ, what a loaded question you ask!
Personally, I do view them differently. I respect Christians and have absolutely no
problem with them following their faith.
Messianic Christians are another issue.
First, they insist on calling their faith "Messianic Judaism", when it's beliefs are
totally foreign to Judaism-they profess the standard tenets of Christianity, but
insist that it is "a Judaism". Most of them are not Jews...so how can you have
"a Judaism" when they are as a whole not Jews, and hold beliefs that are
contradictory to Judaism?
Second, the sabbath was given to Jews, not to the gentiles. Gentiles are
not in the least obligated to observe Torah, but Messianics insist that they are.
Some Messianics no longer consider themselves to be gentile, but "Hebrews",
or "Israel" or "Ephraim", in short a type of replacement theology.
Next, Messianics take Jewish rituals and ritual objects and use them in an
inappropriate way of worshipping, as considered by Judaism. They insist
they are following Torah and the faith of Jesus, but they copy so much of
Jewish customs and culture that either were not in existence at the time,
or there is no evidence they were.
It's embarrasing when gentiles see these Messianics and assume that they are
Jews...it happens a lot, and I cringe every time.
Messianics as a whole absolutely refuse to be called "Christian" even though
they hold the faith of Christianity at their core. They also claim Jews are not following
true Judaism, that we follow man made law (yet they also follow a lot of rabbinical
law, while at the same time decrying it), that we can't understand our own bible.
Now, I know this is painting all Messianics with a broad brush, but I have seen it
over and over.
Guess you can tell I am not a big fan of the Messianic faith, eh?
Now, as far as Messianics or Christians observing Saturday as sabbath, rather than
Sunday, I don't have a problem with it at all...what I do have a problem with is
the method of observance...copying Jews.