Somehow,somewhere,somewhen

[Loudmouth]

While I agree that God is something, there was nothing prior to God creating something out of nothing.

God existed prior to the universe, and God is something. Also, God needs a realm to exist in, so there is another universe that God can see and experience. Something from something.

While naturalism must provide how nothing created nothing from nothing. That is impossible.

We already showed you that it does happen. You can lead a horse to water . . .

In this case, we have something it is appearing from out of nothing. The universe exists and is something so these particles that "appear out of nothing" really are appearing out of something...the universe.

Yes, an area of the universe where there is nothing. Something from nothing.

I think I've shown the argument proves to be on the side of Christianity...the clear winner.

The Black Knight returns.

Let me guess, it's only a flesh wound, right?

 

[Subduction Zone]

While I agree that God is something, there was nothing prior to God creating something out of nothing. While naturalism must provide how nothing created nothing from nothing. That is impossible.



In this case, we have something it is appearing from out of nothing. The universe exists and is something so these particles that "appear out of nothing" really are appearing out of something...the universe.



I think I've shown the argument proves to be on the side of Christianity...the clear winner.

What?

We can observe something coming from nothing. We cannot observe God, how is that a clear win for Christianity?

 

[EternalDragon]

Exactly = we don't know = goddidit?

Well, then it can't mean = we don't know = naturedidit or evolutiondidit.

 

[Davian]

Exactly = we don't know = goddidit?

Is that not the god-of-the-gaps argument, in a nutshell?

 

[Davian]

Well, then it can't mean = we don't know = naturedidit or evolutiondidit.

Oncedeceived is portraying her God as a god of the gaps in scientific knowledge. That's not your God, is it?

 

[Eight Foot Manchild]

Last chance,

I dare you to present one single piece of scientific evidence, sourced to primary literature.

 

[Oncedeceived]

What?

We can observe something coming from nothing. We cannot observe God, how is that a clear win for Christianity?

No, we see something coming from something. These particles are in the universe which is something.

 

[Oncedeceived]

Last chance,

Who was this for?