revrobor said:
What you say about Jesus is true. But you have blurred the line between being a follower of the Lord and being a member of a religion.
There is no line, save for the one that a Prot has put up in a fallacious didactic. St. James tells us quite clearly what religion is:
Religion that is pure and undefiled before God, the Father, is this: to care for orphans and widows in their distress, and to keep oneself unstained by the world. (James 1:27)
There is no contradiction here between religion and what we are called to do by our Lord Christ Jesus - for how could anyone say they love as Jesus calls us to love, yet neglects orphans and widows in distress and prefers to remain in the stain of sin? What does it mean to follow Jesus? Does it not mean to live in the life in the Spirit? If religion is as St. James claims it to be, then how can it not be a part of the life in the Spirit, which is in the vitality of our Lord Christ Jesus by way of the Holy Spirit. Vain words of refutation concerning the true nature of religion mean very little and do not reflect the true words of the Word Incarnate. And that Word [that is Christ] puts all our words to shame in their vanities. For our fallen words can in no wise measure up to the unfallen Word of our Lord.
You are apparently devoted to a religion with all it's dogma, traditions, rules, regulation, icons, Pope worship, etc.
I am devoted to religion in the purity that is stated by St. James, an Apostle of our Lord, whose dogma (interpretation) I assent to because of Christ. In like manner, I also assent to the Apostolic succession of St Peter in the Pope. I assent to Tradition, being that it and the Bible are closely intertwined and come from the same source - Christ Jesus our Lord. I also assent to rules, being that Christ in no ways destroyed the law, but instead traded our hearts of stone, so that the law may live in the heart of flesh. And, if I am to of conscience follow "the rules," then certainly I am bound in conscience to the duty of regulations, for they are a means of justice - and Christ does not condemn justice, but instead says that the just are blessed. Of course I consider icons, as they have been used since the beginning of Christianity as a means of reference to our Lord. Furthermore, no Catholic in their right mind worships the Pope. That is a common slandering fallacy used by anti-Catholics who have not intellect enough to argue in a reasonable manner. I could easily go the rout that even Protestants bickering between one another have gone and say that you worship St. Paul, or maybe Luther or some other Refermer is your "icon" and distracts you from Jesus. But where would that lead but to more bickering and nonsensical denouncements of each other's Christian faith. In short, such arguments are futile and unworthy of any Christian - yet, we still plunge into such fallen use of language. May God have mercy and, though we may be unworthy, may He say the Word and heal us.
These are not things Jesus instituted. Jesus said "Follow me". Whether you want to admit it or not there is a difference between being a follower of the Lord and being a member of a religious institution.
Well, it depends. The head needs a body. So the question then boils down to which body is connected to the head. If we speak of Christ as the head, then surely the religion of Christ is His body. Or would you that the body be headless or the head to be dismembered from His body? Either we are or are not a part of this body, this Church, this religion of Christ we call Christianity.
However, I will admit it is possible for some to do both. But being a member of a religious instution is not essential for our salvation or spiritual growth.
Being a part of the Body of Christ, the Church, is indeed necessary. This should be all the more apparent for anyone who went to Easter services in which the Baptismal vow is revisited to remind us of our commitment to Christ since becoming a part of His body. Romans 6 tells us quite well how we are a part of Christ's body and what it implies.
Pax Tecum,
John