Rodriguez & Tarantino

[kurabrhm]

Was Tarantino's part in Sin City worthwhile? He directs the driving scene featuring Clive Owen and Benicio Del Toro.
Or does Tarantino spoil the movie? I'm not sure...

 

[SUNSTONE]

When I first saw the commercials for that movies I was soooo hyped about it.
But the movie was a let down for me.
It had some great moments, but I think it was a little miscasted, and not the best writting in the world.
Not a bad movie, but not what I had expected.


Now for the topic question.
That was one of the few scenes that got a reaction from the audience where I watched it.
It was a funny little scene.
I don't think it hurt or helped this movie.

 

[awesome liver]

the movie is a masterpiece of pulp noir film making. sin city as written and drawn by frank miller is unique for its graphic art (not violence). it's starkly black and white, but all the characters are in the gray area except the bad guys who are die-hard bad guys. the movie was a testament to miller's vision and rodriguez's technical and creative know-how. tarantino's input is hilarious and actually is a breather from the hard core violence of the rest of the film.