I disagree. Far too often, information is presented that is, at best misleading or mistaken, and at worst outright lying. Usually the former, but in any case, those seeking outreach are being given false information. And because of the strict "Christians-only" answer policy, this false information cannot be corrected (at least, not without violating the rules and receiving warnings/penalties). I myself have many times had to hold my tongue as false information was presented., with no real recourse to rectify those errors.
This of course is, is wrong information based on what you have chosen to believe, which is not the Christian faith, as such, ideally, you will disagree with any answer you do not like.
Now. in the off chance, the slim and ever so minute possibility that you might be an unbiased observer, then your input might not be such a bad thing, however, to open the door in the direction you seek, is to just make this another debate forum. This is something you can not deny, and even given the restraint of some non-Christians this restraint does not apply to all, nor does maturity, or even logical rational thinking.
These attributes have been validated on GA and Creation Evolution, that not everyone that claims to know what they are talking about, does. And Atheism does not make one correct on subjects of science or things of scientific development.
As such, this is a door better left not opened, as it stands we get enough trolls here in QBNC because of the sheer amount of trolls that used to go to GA are not coming here, because of the 100 post limit. The last thing that is needed in this situation is to add hecklers, and debaters to the list of things that people have to deal with here.
I do agree that, for those seeking answers about Christianity, constant debate between believers and non-believers would be less than ideal. On the other hand, though, I think anyone, Christian or not, should be able to step in when necessary.
I would have to respectfully disagree, because that generates debate, and that is GA realm, if they feel the need then they can move on to GA, or one of the other debate forums, this is not the place for such things.
This is an outreach, and truth be told, the people like yourself are not involved in learning about the Christian faith in a positive matter where they want to know more, but only seek to challenge it, as such, you have not viable place in an outreach environment.
And yes, it would just stir up debate, and there is enough problems with that as it is, with the vast amount of trolls that do already come here. We don't need to add more "message board atheist" to the mix.
It certainly is a fine line, though. Yes, only Christians should be answering the Christian-related questions. But there are many sorts of questions that can be readily answered by non-Christians as well, and they should be free to do so.
And it is commentary like this, that makes me more then sure you have no idea what you are talking about, and why your desire to try and "correct" people is a ruse.
Let me explain, You do not believe in Christ, or follow him, as such, anyone seeking answers about following Christ, should not be going to you for guidance, because th truth is, it's not something you can explain, or give guidance to in an experienced manner.
It is like people who do not have children trying to teach people how to raise them. This might sound all great and full of book knowledge, but they really have no idea what they are talking about, because they just do not have the first hand experience.
Somethings, sure, book knowledge might work, but Faith, and Christ is not one of them, neither is children.
Would you come to me to give you answers about Atheism?
But usually, the nature of the question is fine for this forum. I'll agree that it shouldn't be a debate forum, but on the other hand, we should be able to rectify misinformation.
Man.. you just really love that "On the other hand"...
Sure, but who validates what is correct and what is incorrect?
You?
You just know that this is absolute truth?
Given the amount of people on this forum that are Christians, and embrace Technology, as well as possess many degrees in scientific fields, the need for some atheist to offer "correction" is just no there.
Unless you of course you are under the impression that because you are an Atheist that you just know this science stuff better then any Christian, and if that is the case, we don't need that level of Ego in Outreach.
For instance, say a seeker has a question regarding the Christian view of evolution. I'm quite content to let Christians answer how evolution can or cannot fit in with their faith. But if they say something that is patently wrong (such as "Darwin recanted his theory on his death bed" or "it violates the second law of thermodynamics" or "evolution is random chance"), I think anyone, Christian or non, should be able to set the record straight. Without, of course, letting things slide into a debate.
Your right... Christians can correct this issue,, as such.. the need for the "or not" is not there, as Christians can fully take care of that little issue for you, outside help is not needed.
I'm not saying to let non-Christians answer any and all questions. Rather, a little leeway depending on the context of what they are speaking on.
I believe, if they offer addition to the existing question in a positive manner, I have no problem with it, the issue is, opening the door is the biggest issue. As has been proven in the past, people can not refrain themselves from hostile responses or irking on debates.
If non-Christians had acted with honor and respect in the past and continued to do so, I am sure such rules would not be needed, they have not, as such, the rules and restraints are needed.
Sadly.. After all is said and done, The actions of the many have ruined it for the few.
Maybe someday, when the Non-Christians that come here, have proved themselves respectful, and that in fact they can act with honor and decency in these situations, then the rules can change.
But, until then, the rules have to remain as they are.
God Bless
Key.
